Which one is the best season in American Idol ?

@femimi (872)
Indonesia
April 18, 2007 4:36am CST
This is already the 6th season. But which season do you think has the best quality of their finalists ?? According to me I like 4th season, many good and quality finalists there, and each elimination seemed like a hard choice at that time (not like right now we usually hope some finalits will be gone). I remembered there are Carry Underwood, Bo Bice, Constantine, Anwar, Vonzel, even the good ones has been eliminate from the beginning. What a tight competition. Which season do you thing the best one ?
3 people like this
18 responses
@ritchel (890)
• Philippines
18 Apr 07
I still go for the original which is the Season 1. They have produced the hit maker and is selling a lot of albums worldwide Kelly Clarkson. She is just the best. I think for the other seasons that follow no one has ever reached where Kelly is right now. She has becoming so famous as time flies by!
@femimi (872)
• Indonesia
18 Apr 07
Too bad I never saw the 1st season :( maybe it also full of surprise. But I really think that the 4th is full of good competition inside.
@kgwat70 (13395)
• United States
18 Apr 07
I would have to agree with you as the 4th season was definitely my favorite because of the same contestants. I loved Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice and bought both of their albums. The other ones that you mentioned were very good as well and a few others that I can not remember their names. It was tough seeing the top 10 leave the show then. Last year was not as good as there were only a few good singers and the one who should have won (Chris Daughtry) did not win.
@femimi (872)
• Indonesia
18 Apr 07
Yeah, I also think the Chris Daughtry should win last season. He is the best performance than others.
• United States
19 Apr 07
I think the time of Carrie Underwood was also the best one, although closely followed by the time before that (or when Fantasia won). That time of Carrie Underwood was really a tough competition because everyone had very good vocals and a lot of them had very strong stage presence. I even thought that Constantine wouldn't be eliminated that fast, and that Bo Bice would win (I actually like his very strong stage presence and very powerful voice). They all seemed to be professionals to start with.
• India
19 Apr 07
Season number 1 was the first and best. It was unexpected and surprising, everything very different than what it is now. Season 4 was my second favorite.
1 person likes this
@emma412 (1156)
• United States
18 Apr 07
I think the first season is the best season. None of the winners have compared to Kelly Clarkson. Especially this season, it has become such a joke! I think the producers should learn to recognize when a show has run its course.
1 person likes this
@khoskins (20)
• United States
18 Apr 07
I think season 5 was the best.. even ones that got eliminated before the finals have cd's out. I enjoyed all the music types and love chris daughtery. this season seems to be a little boring..
1 person likes this
• United States
18 Apr 07
I would have to say even though I am not an american Idol fan that the first and second season were the greatest. I think that all the shows now are very weird and they make me upset
1 person likes this
@cindyd (36)
• Philippines
18 Apr 07
I like the batch Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice. For me, their season eas the best. Most of them are really great. Carrie Underwood, being impeccable, great vocal powers. Next one is the season on-going right now.
@gegegelay (934)
• Philippines
18 Apr 07
I loved the season of Bo Bice and Carrie Underwood and also Soul Patrol and Katherine Mcphee. It was really a tight comptition but I all love 'em! Of course, I also love the season where Jasmine Trias made it to the final three. Jasmine is a pure-blooded Filipino that's why we Filipinos are so proud of her. She was really good coz' she made it to the final three!
• India
18 Apr 07
I think that the best season was the first one. because everything was new back then. The whole concept and stuff. Plus Kelly Clarkson was is my favourite contestant ever. I think that she really rocks and she is great.
@vesuvius (1677)
• Philippines
18 Apr 07
My favorite season is the 4th season. I loved almost everybody in this season and my favorite candidate Carrie Underwood really won! I have awaited for almost all the performances on that season and my favorites are: *Carrie's 'Independence Day', 'Inside Your Heaven' and 'Angels Brought Me Here' *Constantine's 'Bohemian Rhapsody' *Bo's 'Money, Money' Nothing compares to that season really.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
18 Apr 07
my fav season is season 4 & 5. both season had really talented people. my fav contestant for this season is melinda. Its like she doesnt need this competition to succeed. she's wayy out of her league. for season 4 i liked bo bice, who i thought should win. for the last season, i liked chris daughtry, elliott yamin & katharine mcphee.
1 person likes this
@yvonne1968 (1065)
• United States
18 Apr 07
I would say my first choice for best season would be when Taylor won last year. He deserved to win and i was so glad he did, he is way better then katherine or chris. Then would be the year Carrie won with Bo and Constantine. This year really isnt that good and i havent watched it since they went to hollywood, only time i catch anything on it is when they do the idol rewind on the local news.
@Ysh2phyd (45)
• Philippines
18 Apr 07
the season where anwar was in.....
@femimi (872)
• Indonesia
18 Apr 07
that was 4th season
@speedy1279 (2667)
• United States
18 Apr 07
I would have to agree with you. Season 4 with Carrie Underwood was the best. I am a very big fan of hers. Plus the other contestants that season were also very good. This year I would have to admit I haven't watched. Just to much drama with Sanjaya still being on the show and stuff. I have found better things to watch. Like Dancing with the Stars and Gilmore Girls!
@femimi (872)
• Indonesia
18 Apr 07
-lol- this season is easy to guess -lol- not like the 4th or 5th.
@gemini1960 (1162)
• Philippines
19 Apr 07
its my first time that i have seen it just last night..but i like the style of sanjaya..so innocent and trying to win..and the theres the one woman i forgot the name that really sings well..shes got long hair and chubby..
@evlo173 (435)
• United States
18 Apr 07
I like season 1 because there are several people who went on starring in various sitcoms and tv shows. Kelly clarkson have several albums out, so she is doing very well.
• Philippines
18 Apr 07
My personal favorite season of American Idol has gotta be Season 3. The very reason is because two of the top 10 are both coming from the Philippines or having Filipino blood running through their veins. As a matter of fact, top 3 was Jasmine Trias. After she was eliminated from the show, she became an instant success here in our country. You go, girl!