She has Beautiful voice...but some say...

A male voice? Ha-ha-ha! She has a rich voice, not a male voice. Well, there are male singers who scream like a girl but do you call this a male voice? She is so cute, absolutely gorgeous!

hi there,i like shakira too..and even i have heard such comments about her and one of them said she sings like a goat..LOL..well i don't believe in this unfair criticism and i have my own judgment about her that she sings just appropriate..people who call her voice alike males most probably are the ones who don't like her or who themselves don't know the different kinds of female voices which vary according to country like she is a Latino singer and the songs she sings and the Columbian region as a whole has a bit different phonetic output for females specially what we call voice from rest of the world..she sings in her native way and she can not change it because its natural and i don't find it manly..may be such people are more used to the sissy and extra-feminine stuff of female voice rather than the confident and rough-n-tough kind of a thing..so she rocks in the Latin land because of her super feminine voice..rather than the girlish shrills and Oprah hall squeaks..lol ..so her voice may not be girly sweet but is truly feminine..

Yeah she is a great singer.....I like her song bcoz off her freaky voice!!

Shakira is a good artist. She has sweet voice and good figure. She is also a good dancer and have good figure. After all these talenst she is good in nature and she is always in between the media but not in humours. so, she is perfect in all fields.

I like her hips and back as well as her face and hair also. I can mary with her without any criteria and conditions.

I like Shakira too. She's gorgeous. People will always have a negative comment on someone. If it wasn't Shakira it would be someone else. In my opinion, she does have a deeper voice than some female singers, but it still does not sound like a man. It just makes her seem like a strong woman to me and that is not a bad thing.