What do you think about the state of the health care system?

@LCecelia (1124)
United States
August 28, 2007 7:05pm CST
Many citizens in the US have no health insurance coverage, myself included. Because of my underemployment I am able to get some things taken care of at a local hospital that has a program for low income individuals. One day last week Michael Moore was on Jay Leno promoting his film, Sicko. It is a documentary on the state of the health care industry. He related a story of some of the people who were at ground zero who had gotten ill and their insurance would not pay for their care. He told how he took those people to Cuba because he heard that the captured terrorists were getting free health care there from the Cuban government. The people he took there were given medical treatment in Cuba. He also said that America is one of the only world leader without a national health care plan. In England doctors are given bonuses for having the healthest patients. You can get some really good information from Michael Moore's site @ michaelmoore.com
2 people like this
2 responses
• Malaysia
29 Aug 07
It also showed that 47 million people had no health insurance in the United States last year, an increase from the 44.8 million who had no coverage in 2005. If you read this article, I think you will be speechless; http://aspe.hhs.gov/health/Reports/rn20.htm full data and details.
1 person likes this
@LCecelia (1124)
• United States
29 Aug 07
You're quite right. There's really nothing to say after reading that. And yet we're in 2007 almost 2008 and still no progress. Sad.
• United States
29 Aug 07
If the government supplies "free" health care (at your expense, with your tax dollars) it has more of a say in how you live your life. For example, if you smoke or eat fast food, the government could say you don't deserve coverage for certain things because of your unhealthy behaviors. I think the best solution would be to cut government spending and then cut taxes, leaving the average working American more of his or her own hard earned money to purchase insurance or pay for health care. Just my two cents...
@LCecelia (1124)
• United States
29 Aug 07
The "free" health care would be for ALL citizens so we would all be paying for it in one form or another, whether it be through wages or taxes. Three prominent countries, Canada, England and Cuba HAVE figured out a way to make it work. Why can't the United States? And I'm not only saying it because I am one of the millions without insurance and I am working and paying into the system even though I only work part time. Don't get me wrong. I do see your point, I'm no attacking you, I'm just having a conversation concerning why it has not been a priority in this country. I've always had health coverage until I lost my job and have only been able find temporary and part time employment since 1998.
2 people like this
• United States
30 Aug 07
No offense taken. I like a good debate. :o) Our Constitution doesn't give the federal government the power to administer health care. It would only be constitutionally permissible at the state level. Of course, many of the current programs should be state level as well, although that's often disregarded. The founders of this country never intended for us to give nearly half our hard earned money to the government so it could "better spend" it for us. I also don't think the government has a great track record of spending our money. You might also want to look into "rationing" and long waiting periods in countries that offer socialized health care. As a population ages and requires more care, how will the government pay for it? They'll raise taxes again and they may well stop treating the most expensive cases that have poor prognoses. I don't want the government deciding if I'm "worthy" of the cost, and I don't want the government telling me how to eat, sleep, and live or which doctor, medicine, or treatment I MUST use (which it will do if it provides health care).
@LCecelia (1124)
• United States
30 Aug 07
Good points. I live in America but I'm not an American. I'm ashamed to say that I'm not very up to date on which level of government has the authority to do what. I think though because of all the poor and disabled people here in the US we should try to figure something out. I wouldn't want the government telling me what to do either. And I do agree that the government's track record in handling taxpayers money does not fill me with confidence. As for working half the year for the government, I have my issues with that too. But thats another debate for another time. :-) I've heard stories about the rationing and long waits but I have to think that overall that it may just as well be better than no insurance at all. I see every day how badly the population is aging. It just grieves me. There has been a lot of talk lately about how overweight the population continues to get. I have to admit that I do have a problem in that area as well. Thankfully so far I only have my blood pressure to worry, however I think the fact that it runs in my family is also a contributing factor. Again, a debate for another time. I think I'm going off tangent so I'll shut up now. But overall I think that we are on the same side.