school food rules

Canada
August 30, 2007 4:08pm CST
a while back i had posted about only being allowed healthy snacks at my daughter's school. well i got a list of acceptable things today and what isn't accepted. it's crazy. i get the no chips no chocolate and no cookies. but they even are forbidding crackers chocolate milk, those kraft cheese and cracker things together. granola bars, raisins, cereal bars, rice crispy sqares. basically her only option is fresh fruit and fresh veggies, bread and cold cut meats. but my daughter doesn't like sandwitches so basically it's fruit and veggies every day for lunch and snacks. i know she'll get tired of that every day.
6 people like this
21 responses
@tad1fan (3367)
• Canada
31 Aug 07
That's the peanut rule coming in.....if you read the ingredients of all those things,they may be made around peanuts and peanuts are a big no no in the schools
2 people like this
@tad1fan (3367)
• Canada
1 Sep 07
Healthy diet,I can understand
1 person likes this
• Canada
31 Aug 07
no it's not even about that. the principle had a meeting for parents of the new students comming into the school and he talked about it with us. it's for kids to have a healthy diet.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Sep 07
HI tad1fan, nope my kids don't eat pork, it is not good for them.. As for a 5 year old not knowing what he can or can not eat. I am sure that if he had a bad enough reaction that he remembers, he will know and if not, he could always ask. As for kids trading lunches? I seriously doubt this kid would trade something to get my sons peanut butter sandwich. I think it is bad enough that the schools are replacing the true history of this nation with "politically correct" lessons and then they try to force my child to eat things that I know is bad for them. I am ready to pull him out if the lessons get too far out, but when they decided his diet? He is def going to be homeschooled then...
2 people like this
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
30 Aug 07
This seems like it's pretty difficult to follow. Did the school provide any suggestions besides fresh fruit and veggies, bread, and cold cut meats? Is she allowed to bring, for example, soup or noodles or rice to heat up? (One school I worked at had a microwave. A parent would come in and the kids would give the lunch parent their container, the lunch parent would heat these up so that it was warm when the kids came back for them at lunch time). What about homemade pizza or things like that? I mean, pizza dough is like bread, and tomato sauce is made from a fruit, and ham is a cold cut... My mom used to make me rice balls. Little balls of rice with bits of cold cut or cucumber in the middle. (Sort of like sushi for people who don't like sushi rice). What about yoghurt? This sounds really difficult. I hope your daughter likes fruits and veggies.
2 people like this
• Canada
30 Aug 07
my daughter is a mostly fruits and veggies eater but i think she'll get sick of it every day. no there isn't a microwave to heat up their lunches so soup and stuff like that is out of the question. today i sent a pasta salad she likes with veggies in it. i didn't get a letter sent home so i guess that one was ok. yogurt is ok but those yogurt tubes and petit denon yogurt cups are actually on the yellow light list. is goes green light yellow light and red. yellow means it's ok once in a while but not more than once a week. that lists has yogurt, cereal (low sugar ones like cherios) muffin, banana bread
@vokey9472 (1486)
• United States
31 Aug 07
I think sometimes schools get over involved in trying to help our kids stay healthy. My son's pre-school has a list of acceptable foods, snacks and drinks. Every one has to bring their lunch (church run school-no lunchroom facilities) They do not allow any type of food that has to be eaten with a spoon, as it allows for too much mess. No bottled drinks of any kind. Only juice boxes, juice bags or milk cartons, but nothing that must be kept cold. Ever try shelf stable milk? I cannot stomach it and my kid hates it. Only fresh fruit. No fruit roll ups, fruit snacks or dried fruit. No nuts of any kind. All sandwiches MUST be cut into 4 or more pieces. Accepted sandwiches are cheese, cream cheese, bologna, turkey or ham. NO peanut butter allowed. No cookies, chips, snack cakes, or candy. Pretzels are allowed as a chip substitute. NO 100 calorie snacks allowed either. (cookie crisps, chips, mini cupcakes). For parties or birthdays, we are allowed to bring 1 cookie per child. The room mothers assign who will bring the cookies. The other moms are to bring popcorn (unsalted and unbuttered), fresh fruit, cheese cubes, bottled water or juice boxes. Oh, and they actually asked that the juices either be No Sugar Added or 100% juice. Because giving our kids Splenda or 35g of sugar per serving is a much better choice. Last year, if we sent "forbidden" food, it was returned to us with a note telling us that our child was fed by the church for which we owed $2 and that a meeting with the teacher was scheduled for (enter date and time). Then the teacher would give you a long speech on healthy eating and weight control. It is stupid.
1 person likes this
• Canada
31 Aug 07
wow sounds like my daughter's school. if she does bring something that is not acceptable then they confiscate it and then she doesn't get anything to eat. so i have to be very careful. one thing i didn't mention that was on the list of bad things which is driving me nuts. is the fruit cups. so she can't even have fruit in the cups cause of the syrup it's put in. so our only options seem to be sandwitches fresh fruit and veggies. they even said no dip for the veggies. now come on. this is rediculous. plain veggies and fruit every day will get boring
@vokey9472 (1486)
• United States
3 Sep 07
Tell me about it. Ever try getting a 5 year old to eat carrot sticks and pretzels every single day? Trust me, it is not fun. I tried putting those pre-packages sliced apples in his lunch last year and they sent them back to me with a note explaining that they were not "fresh fruit" and were not allowed. I sent some cashews in his lunch one and they were sent back because nuts are not allowed. I told them I thought that they just meant peanuts and was informed that no nuts of any kind are allowed. It is just plain silly of the schools to be so strict about the food that they would actually take it away from a child and not feed that child. At least at our school the church will give the kid a cheese sandwich and some water. Then charge the parents $2 for it.
@Gemmygirl1 (2867)
• Australia
31 Aug 07
Is this for school school or the things you guys have before you enter first grade? It's amazing isn't it? The way other people think it's ok to tell you what you are allowed & not allowed to feed your own children. I think what they're doing is a little over the top & what a child eats should be up to the parent, it's really the parent's responsibility that a child eats healthy but i cant see how an occasional cookie or cup of chocolate milk is going to hurt. It's a good thing they don't do anything like that here in Oz, or i'd consider home schooling, only because if i'd like my daughter to be able to have a cookie after her lunch then i think i am the only one who has the right to make that decision!
• Canada
31 Aug 07
the school is from pre k to grade 6, these rules apply to all those grades
@eanna13 (133)
• United States
31 Aug 07
My daughter's school says almost the same thing. They don't go to the extreme that your does. Thank goodness, or my daughter would come home hungry everyday.
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
19 Dec 07
When we get home she acts like she hasn't eaten all day anyways. Putting her on peanut butter or ham sandwhiches & an apple would likely get my arm gnawed off in the truck. Yet getting her to eat dinner....
1 person likes this
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
31 Aug 07
Hi poppoppop111, I don't know what their idea of healthy is, but cold cut meats will kill you sooner than eating raisins.. None of my kids liked cold cuts either, they took peanut butter sandwich's and was fortunate to hit the middle school when they got sick of them, because in the middle school, they had more choices of what to eat. I didn't see the discussion on allowing healthy snacks, but if my child's school even considered it, I would say, Ok, I have studied what is good and bad for you for years, you want the list? (I may not follow the healthy diet, but I have the information)
• Canada
31 Aug 07
please send a list if you have it handy. i need more ideas on what to send to school with her so she doesn't get bored with the same thing every day. thanks
1 person likes this
• United States
31 Aug 07
Well it is simple, but the fact that they don't allow raisins, I don't think some of what I would consider healthy would be allowed either. I was just saying, I don't know where they get the fact that raisins are not healthy, but that is not correct. Since your daughter does not like sandwiches, all I can say is send her off with fruits and vegetables because that is all they seem to allow. Have you talked to the principal about this? If I could copy and paste, I would send you statistics about how unhealthy cold cuts are..Maybe you can do an online search, I am sure there are plenty of sites that will confirm this. Like I said, my kids don't eat pork and they also don't like cold cuts and unless someone is allergic to peanuts, peanut butter sandwiches are so much better for you than processed meats...You still get the protein too..
1 person likes this
@nishdan01 (3051)
• Singapore
31 Aug 07
Crazy authorities at school. I do not understand what is wrong with creackers, raisins, cheese, creal bars and cookies. FRuits and veggies alone will make children cows and not humans. I understand if fruits and veggies are mandatory as part of diet. IN my opinion school should never say what not to bring. Children at a youn age should eat what they like. ONLY THE QUANTITY CAN BE RESTRICTED IF REQUIRED. Tell as a parent what you think in the PTA meeting of school.
@sweetdesign (5142)
• United States
31 Aug 07
Another reason to be glad I homeschool......being dictated what I can and cannot pack in my child's lunch. That is ridiculous. I'm sorry but I truly think that parents have the right to choose what they pack in thier own child's lunch from home. I can see limiting what is offered by the school but to then tell parents that the school knows better than they do and that the school is going to limit what they offer as well that is ridiculous.
1 person likes this
• India
31 Aug 07
Well that’s definitely taking it a bit too much. As it is children seldom like to eat their veggies and fresh fruits and sandwiches for lunch everyday is just yuck! It gets soggy and once the freshness is gone, it doesn’t taste good at all. And then for sandwich you either have to use butter, cheese, sandwich spread or mayonnaise, none of which are healthy enough for regular consumption. You wouldn’t use low fat cheese, or table margarine or diet mayo for a child, would you? So a granola bar is I believe more healthy if taken once in a while. Chips and chocolates are understandable but cookies too! What is a child supposed to eat! Very soon they would just be chucking those veggies out once the teacher turns her back and would rather go hungry.
1 person likes this
@ravinskye (8237)
• United States
30 Aug 07
my daughter just started preschool this week and they encourage healthy snacks also. but i think your daughters school is going overboard. my daughters birthday is coming up and she is allowed to bring cupcakes. i can't imagine why or how raisins is bad for them.
1 person likes this
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
31 Aug 07
wow, our school has a peanut free rule (it is enforced but people still bring peanut butter/related items) and i have heard of a milk product free school (no cheese, no yogurt etc) but fortunately our school is not like that. i would ask the teacher/principal for a list that you can bring!
1 person likes this
@lucky_witch (2707)
• Philippines
31 Aug 07
That would be a tough rule for the students. Is there any PTA (PArent-Teacher Association) in your school so you could tackle issues like that? i guess that it is important that the school should consult teh parents of the students regarding the new rules and changes in the school. Anyway, its for the benefit of the students. Good luck to your daughter... :)
1 person likes this
@taylorblue (1286)
• Canada
31 Aug 07
Why are they being so strict about it? That seems a little crazy! I know my daughter's school says anything but peanut and peanut products. That is sooooo crazy!
1 person likes this
@tuffy999 (794)
• Philippines
31 Aug 07
that's absurd school dictating to parents what the children can eat. where is democracy?????write to the school board about this, anyway you look at it, it's not right; they might mean well but their implementation is out of this world.
1 person likes this
@kakuemmom (859)
• Canada
30 Aug 07
My daughter would starve, I don't think its the schools place to decide what my child should take to school for lunch. That is my role, no nuts that makes sense but beyond that none of their business. I would be in a constant battle with the school for sure.
1 person likes this
@crazynurse (7482)
• United States
30 Aug 07
wow, talk about a drastic change! If our school system does that there will be a lot of unhappy parents. The children's diets in this area are terrible. The children eat so much 'junk food' and if not junk food then the meals that are laden with fat and nitrates. I agree that we need to do something about childhood obesity, but no child (or adult) is going to eat just vegetables/fruit at every meal!!
1 person likes this
@aretha (2538)
• United States
25 Jan 08
gotta love this. i am having the same problem. i haven't gottin a list of what they can and can not take so i buy things and then my son comes home and says he can't take that any more. pretzels seem to be ok for him to take and he likes crutons and they haven't said anything about that. i even got these little fruit things with apples and carmel like they have at mcdonalds and he was told not to bring them any more. my son don't like sandwiches either so theres not alot out there that they will let him bring. i feel if they are going to be that picky they should supply their snack.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
15 Jan 08
I can see the chips and such but raisins??? Those are fruit. And cereal bars/granola bars? Wow, talk about restrictive. I hope you've come up with something to keep your daughter happy. **AT PEACE WITHIN** ~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~
@squaretile (3778)
• Singapore
22 Jan 08
i guess they meant well. but even that can be too much. like what they say about the road to hell. paved with good intentions haha. i guess no deep fried food is as far as i will go. i suppose you can pack something for her to bring to school? that would solve the problem? how can they control what you give her to bring to school right?
• Malaysia
30 Aug 07
Wow, that school has really stupid rules about food... Do they explain why they're banned? There should be no reason to ban most of the foods you mentioned. Some like chocolate milk are nutritious, only an idiot would ban people from drinking it in school.
1 person likes this