mary j blige vs rhinnna

September 4, 2007 11:08am CST
yesterday i have heard it on the news that the song umbrella sang by rihanna was first given to mary j blige and that she rhinna uses her femenity to have the song given to her do you think that if mary had sung the song would it be a hit would it sound better than rihanna version what do you think
3 responses
@busta1baby (1238)
• United States
5 May 08
is have to go with mary j blige
• United States
4 Oct 07
Girl, You can't believe everything you hear! I don't think mary would have even made an attempt to sing that stupid song!
• Atlantic City, New Jersey
5 Sep 07
Anything is better with Mary :) but....I do have to say that "UMBRELLA" just isn't Mary's style. I have been a huge fan of Mary's since her first album "What's the 411" and just don't think that Rihanna- who just came upon the seen can compete. Don't get me wrong- I like her- and the song- but she won't last like Mary has ;)