Dancing with the stars: Harsh judging tonight!

United States
November 5, 2007 8:53pm CST
Was it just me or was the judging tonight a little too harsh. I understand that at this point in the competion the couples really need to work on thier technique. But I think the judges were too harsh on some of the dances. For example: Jennie's waltz I thought was beautiful and I disagree with the judges on her dance. But I did have alot of favorites. My top two favorite dances would have to be Jennie's Samba. That dance was hot. Especially the part close to the end of the dance where they were embraced and swaying back and forth. I had goose bumps all over. Then my other favortie even though I haven't liked her from the beginning was Mel and Max's Pasa Doble. That was incredible. I would like to see Jennie's Samba as the encore dance, how about you? So what were your favorite dances? What did you think about the judging? Share your comments please!
3 responses
@patgalca (14664)
• Orangeville, Ontario
6 Nov 07
I think the judges were pretty consistent with both their comments and their scoring. Well, maybe not totally consistent. Marie got rave reviews for her first dance yet only got one 10. I think she deserved three 10's. They certainly carried on like they were going to give her all 10's. I looooooved Cameron's Jive. I love the jive to begin with. It is such a fun dance (though Jane seemed to butcher it last week), Cameron did great with it. Both Jennie's dances were beautiful and I would like to see her do the encore dance tomorrow.
• United States
6 Nov 07
Yes, Cameron's Jive was really good and I liked it as well. The jive is a really fun dance to watch and I agree the Jane did not do that dance last week any justice. I was really surprised when she didn't go home last week because her dance stunk.
@jillhill (37383)
• United States
6 Nov 07
They were harsh but they also brought up good points. Jane's dress was distracting....you couldn't see if she was doing the right steps or not. I thought they all did well but some were not up to the standards they have already set but maybe that is because they had to do two dances. That in itself would be very tough! I thought Jennie did wonderful. As did Marie in the quick step.
@3lilangels (4639)
• United States
6 Nov 07
i liked mel and max last night i thought they did a great job and they have a good chance of winning this year,but then again people really have to vote or it will be more upsets like last week with sabrina and mark,they should of stayed.