What movie is the most faithful to the book? And the least?
@RowenaTheWitch (947)
Italy
January 12, 2008 5:27am CST
What movie do you think is the most similar to the book? And the least?
I think the first one is the most similar (but also because there were less facts so it was easy to compress all in a 2h movie) while the third one is the least, coz they didn't explain a lot of things (for example that James Potter was an Animagus), giving too much confusion on the movie-only fans.
3 responses
@mackoy1408 (163)
•
12 Jan 08
I think Harry POTTER SERIES IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE BOOK BEC. IT JUST FOLOWS RECENTLY AFTER IT' RELEASE N THE BOOK IS ALSO DEVELOPING BECAUSE OF THE MOVIE....
@andrechan (97)
• Italy
13 Jan 08
The first three were pretty much faithful.
Instead the 4th was too much centered around the Triwizard tournament while in the fifth Ron's and Ginny's storyline have been completely cancelled (no quidditch matches for them). I can't hide I'm happy about Ginny's absence, by the way
@jsaidmlt (147)
• Malta
12 Jan 08
All movies were faithful to the book. All movies has some things left out, and some extra things. I think the first movie was the most faithful because it was the first movie and they didn't want to experiment too much and wanted the characters and story be as close to the book as possible, in order to build a huge following of fans. and they succesfully managed!
