Do you prefer old Madonna or new Madonna?

I don't prefer either one. I like a handful of her songs but I've never been a Madonna fan. The songs of hers that I like are definitely from the old Madonna. I don't hear anything about the new Madonna. I know she had some songs out the last few years but I never hear them on the stations I listen too.

I definitely prefer the old Madonna, especially from the '80's. I think she has gone too far off center now. She doesn't seem as fresh and edgy as she was, only appears to be trying harder. Guess that being a 40 something woman in the music industry and competing with 20 something chicks isn't easy. I certainly don't envy her.

I prefer the old Madonna.I liked her first hits more than any of her other hits.

I too prefer her old style! Not just the music but also her persona - nowadays she seems very patronising and full of herself! i do admire her talent , her business sense and her ability to stay in fashion and repackage herself constantly - I just don't like HER nowadays! xxx

I agree with you, I like the old Madonna over the newer one. She was one of my favorite artist's in that time frame. She had some great dancing songs and videos too. Now a days I think she's gotten to be a bit boring. Maybe motherhood did that to her? We can only guess.

I am not really a fan of hers. It's a fact that she has a permanent spot for one of music history's very prominent figure. I would say I can't keep myself from going with the beat of her old and not so old songs. I just don't think she still has the magic now like she used to.

Hi coffeeshot, I'm like you, I've always been a fan of Madonna's earlier music, but have gone a bit cold on the later stuff. I think The Immaculate Collection embodies the best of her work, without a doubt. In her younger days at least, Madonna's singing had a quality at it's best that was comparable to Elvis Presley. So I guess that Madonna was the Queen of Pop there for a while (though apparently that crown has been stolen by Kylie). On the matter of Madonna vs Kylie, if it came to a talent contest, Madonna would win it hands down. But Kylie has probably got the edge with personal charisma - makes sense, seeing as how the Budgie started out as an actor and moved on to a singing career, whereas Madonna's career was much the reverse, starting out as a dancer, then moving to a singing in a big way and finally dabbling in some acting parts. I think Madonna would have done well to follow Cindi Lauper's example and bow out of the game at her peak.

definitly her old stuff. i loved he music then but don't really like it now. as far as her as a person i really don't pay attion to her.

Yeah... me too, I like and love to listen to old version of Madonna. More energetic and sounding to my ears. Like these songs;- Song 1 : Like A Virgin http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHrDPD5bFQA Song 2 : La Isla Bonita http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Xl4vl3fZ34 Song 3 : Live To Tell http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvRttd5ESx8 But, for Song 2, she has been 'smashed' by her fan that she involved in lesbian group and the related activity. Ha! Ha! Ha! .... I don't know why. More worse, many fans compare her with another singer, Alizee;- Alizee - La Isla Bonita (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZlgNj-rIxw). I like this Latin culture song very much, come on Madonna....siesta...siesta...siesta !!!