How do you ask a roommate to move out?

United States
March 27, 2008 1:31pm CST
About a year ago, a friend of ours was having trouble with his roommate and looking for a new place to live. All the apartments he could find required long-term leases and were more than he could afford on a minimum wage salary. It was supposed to be short term, just a few months until he moved up north to live with his brother and sister-in-law. Then, it was going to be through the fall semester while he finished his degree (which he dropped out of again) and now there seems to be no end in sight. He has even talked about taking over the lease on the apartment when my husband and I move out, which is probably another year away. The trouble is multi-faceted. First, we would really like the space back. This was supposed to be temporary. Second, we made arrangements when he moved in for him to pay $200 a month for his part of bills and rent. Actually, we let him live her for five months before we even asked for that. But that was not supposed to include food, toilet paper and the like. Now, when I cook dinner every night, I am expected to cook for three, but he never chips in for groceries. He buys some groceries of his own, which he eats for other meals, but my husband and I footing the bill for his dinner every night. He has bought toilet paper once in six months. Third, he seems to have no respect for the house. While he passed himself off as a neat freak, he is a complete slob. His movies are scattered throughout the house while ours are neatly alphabetized and put away each day. He leaves his dirty work boots in the kitchen, etc. Fourth, he complains about things as though we are supposed to fix it for him. LAst week, due to torrential rains, our basement flooded. We lost a decent amount of things stored down there. He may have (he hasn't checked) lost a box of old (but in bad shape, so no collectible value) comic books. He has whined about it, but has yet to go see if it got wet and if it could be dried out. Fifth, he is unnecessarily crass, pointing out that we need more sh*t paper, but failing to go buy it himself. I can't believe his mother let him talk this way, so why does he think its appropriate in our home? Sixth, he is always negative. Though he has never actually been mean to her, he refers to my cat as "damn cat" all the time, even though he's been told she lived here first and its her house too. Also, he seems to expect the world to take care of him. the day that it flooded so badly, I woke him long before he had to go to work to warn him about the flooding and yet he griped all the next day that no one from work had called to tell him how bad it was. Finally, and this is the last straw, he has begun burning scented candled in his room to combat the stink of his filth. My fear is that the room is so messy that he will accidentally burned the house down. This was compounded when he came out for dinner and left the candle burning. The man has been a friend for a long time and I don't necessarily want to end the friendship, but this is ridiculous and talking to him about any one of these behaviors usually results in a week or so of correction of the offensive behavior and the development of some other annoying habit. I need good advice here. Any suggestions?
2 people like this
5 responses
• United States
6 May 08
Knowing precisely who you're talking about, I have to say I'm surprised by the slob part but not surprised about the whining part. The slob thing is definitely a new development, because he used to be a neat freak. The whining, though, he has had that tendency for as long as I've known him (which is not as long as you have). (The crassness, by the by, he's always had. I think it's a military thing.) Unfortunately, I don't have any great advice for getting him to move out. I was lucky in that when I was ready for an old roommate to move out, he got a girlfriend and an offer to move in with her. So I suppose you could start trying to hook him up with single female friends, but that may or may not work... :)
• United States
6 May 08
Great suggestion except that his girlfriend lives at home with her parents! Do you remember Mia (sp?), Shannon's cousin? he's dating her--though I don't think Shannon and Phil know that. On the upside, since he wants to bring her here, he has been less of a total slob and actually cleaned his room. I suppose I should qualify it when I say slop--cause we're not talking Megan or Brenna levels of slob here (though I hear your sister is much neater now). But his room is a disaster and when he lets it spill out to the rest of the house---argh!! And I get sick of taking his clothes out of the bathroom and moving his wet towels off the hook with mine...use another hook already!
1 person likes this
• United States
6 May 08
Yeah, I think having that nice apartment in Nashville got Megan into the cleaning thing. :) And I only vaguely remember Mia... did Jim date her, or try to date her at one point? As for the towel thing, show him a hook, and tell him it's his. That's the ONLY way I've ever found to get guys to NOT use your towel space. If you assign them a towel space, they understand that. :)
@BlackBay (584)
• Canada
27 Mar 08
I think your gonna have to tell him straight that this situation isn't working out and he has to move on....or clean up his act and start paying fair share of the bills. Tell you didn't mind to give help to a friend but theres a point where you have to be responsible for yourself and pay up. Friends or not you don't need to betaken advantage of.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Mar 08
That's kind of what I've been thinking, but it's so hard to do. It makes me feel like I'm being mean. Then, I look at the evidence and know he was supposed to be out of here 8 months ago, so I know I'm not wrong, but....
@BlackBay (584)
• Canada
27 Mar 08
It's probably because your a Nice person and you don't want to hurt his feelings BUT it doesn't sound like he cares if he's hurting yours or maybe you don't want a confrontation. You can say nothing and keep being unhappy and used by him. It' hard but you and your hubby come first.Good Luck to you!
1 person likes this
@subha12 (18441)
• India
28 Mar 08
Hi, look. I am myself very much aware of this roommate problems. I was away for my Job and I had to stay with different types of roommates. I think it would be really difficult to say some one to leave. may be your friend can say that I am having problem with your company so I need to find someone else. May be it can be done.
1 person likes this
@Bizziebod (3497)
6 May 08
It's quite a while since you posted this discussion, have you got anywhere with them yet? If you haven't the only suggestion I can give is not to drop hints and be straight with him, explain that you like having him around but you need space now. There's not much else you can do but be polite but firm and try not to hurt their feelings at the same time.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 May 08
We sat down and talked to him and got some things straightened out (like buying toilet paper). But if it only lasts a week or two, then I'll just ask directly for him to move out.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 May 08
It is time to say hasta la bye bye to him. He has over stayed his welcome and totally taken advantage of your generosity and big heart. It is time for him to move on, so you and T can have a home together again, without a third wheel. It is not being mean at all. You went way beyond the initial agreement. Just be diplomatic, say we are going to be needing the extra space for work. We were glad to help you out, but we would like our home to ourselves again.I think that is a normal thing for a couple to want. Give him written notice too, to make it legit and make him realize this is not an extension or a warning to clean up his act. It is notice to move out. I am sure he can post places for a new apartment with a roomy, just like he has now. Don't back down out of guilt. You two have a right to your own place. It would take some stress out of your lives too. Less stress makes for calmer people and home. You have talked to him more than once about problems and they just reoccur again after awhile. Obviously that didn't work.