What do you think of the judges of American Idol ?

Tweet

I think that having the three judges is a good mix. They all have their place and are all needed. If Simon were the only judge he would completely crush the people with his comments. I agree that he tells how he feels, but I don't think he is the expert of all experts. I usually agree with his opinion about their performances or their song selections, but when he makes unnecessarily rude comments about their clothes,their faces, their bodies, or their personalities then I don't like it. Again, all three judges are really needed because they kind of balance each other out. Paula knows music really well and she makes some really good points at times. who is your favourite Judge and why ?? What do you think of the judges of American Idol ?