Forget the grilled cheese, have you tried grilled peanutbutter and jelly?

I have had this using those sandwich grilling machine thingies and the peanut butter tastes so good all hot and melty and mm now I am getting hungry!

I LOVE grilled peanutbutter and jelly! It's one of my favorite snacks and my girls love them too :)

no I never tryed it but it sure does sound good. I wiil try it and let you no if I liked it...Do you put butter on the bred when you grill it like you do the grilled cheese?

Yes, I have grilled a peanut butter and strawberry jam sandwich before. It makes the jam warm and yummy. It makes the peanut butter all 'melty'. I really enjoy making old standby sandwiches in a 'new' way and this is one that I sometimes do.

wow that sounds really good. i don't think i've heard of that before. my kids are forever asking for peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. i'll have to give it a try with them one day and see what they think. i'm sure its not all too healthy though lol.

Grilled jelly, No. Grilled peanutbutter, Yes, I have tried it. I tasted nice as long as the sandwich is wrapped up. To grill it openly over fire, the peanut butter tastes a weebit dry and hard. Perhaps some honey after that might do the trick. Well, it's for you to try and for me to know :P

I have done something similar to this. I saw on Top Chef one season that they made kind of a French toast peanut butter and jelly so I tried that and it was amazing. Another thing that I have tried that is similar to the grilled peanut butter and jelly was peanut butter and jelly on toast. I'm going to have to try making just a grilled peanut butter and jelly sometime soon!

I'm iffy about that. They had those in our cafe once and I'm just not fond of the thought of that. Grilled cheese yes, grilled peanut butter and jelly no. Which is odd because I like peanut butter and jelly on toast.

Wow, loujac3. I've never heard of a grilled peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It does seem that it would be really tasty: all warm and crunchy. I bet those who love bananas could add those on there also. Well, maybe I should try to whip this one up. PearlGrace

Yes, I have had them before. They are really good. I also sometimes do them with peanut butter and marshmallow fluff. Cream cheese and strawberry jam grilled it good too.

grilled peanut butter and jelly, no kidding? It might be good at that. never tried it but hey 'why not, cannot hurt to try something new' for a change.

Yum...I have tried it..so good. You might also want to try grilled cheese and peanut butter sandwich. Sounds weird, tastes good! Another good one is a peanut butter and jelly quesadilla. Take 2 flour tortillas put pbj in the middle and grill....kids like it.

That's such an awesome combination! I love how the peanut butter melts into the nooks and crannies of the toasty bread. My favorite is a toasted peanut butter and banana, though. Mmm! I have, shockingly, bananas in the house, so maybe I'll do that for lunch tomorrow. Thanks for the reminder! :)

I have tried this before and it is very good! One time my husband got a crazy idea and poured some pancake syrup over the sandwich too, you talk about good!

I love peanut butter and jelly sandwich's. I have never tried that before or heard of it for that matter. I will have to give it a try and see what it taste like.

I love that idea. No, I've never tried it before. I'll bet that it warms the jam and peanut butter and tastes all yummy! I try to warm the peanut butter before spreading on regular non-grilled bread. I like grilled bread and toast, so maybe this could be my next big food obsession! Thanks for the idea. Be well.

Yes I love it! I love mixing up and grilling sandwhiches. Try grilling a peanut butter sandwhich and eating it with maple syrup. It's so good. xD

I love grilled peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. For some reason it does make it taste so much richer than if it were just slapped on two pieces of bread and made into a regular pb&j sandwich.

yep it makes peanutbutterjelly yummier. i have also tried peanutbutter and banana and it tastes as good as well. i think anything (sandwich) grilled is yummier. i have tried sundried tomato with cheese and its like instant pizza..

OOh! That sounds delicious!! I'm trying it tomorrow!