who is the best replacement for anil kumble???

@vinay049 (1839)
India
November 4, 2008 3:43am CST
i know it is very hard question to be answered by anyone.but anil kumble declared his retirement suddenly.as of now amit mishra has performed quite nicely against australia in the recent series but there are few options left for the place of legendary leg spinner--called jumbo.piyush chawala is also good option and he is also leg spinner and young and also bats well but only problem with him is he can't bowl leg spinners well but he does bowl googly nicely.other option is pragyan ojha--he has got his chance.he had done well.another option is murali kartik --he is experienced player but haven't got many chances but when he gets chance he performs well.who will be your choice for anil kumble??
1 person likes this
5 responses
@ram_cv (16516)
• India
5 Nov 08
I think it is a tall order for any spinner to replace Anil Kumble. He was a class act and a match winner. This does open up a window for the likes of Amit Mishra, Pragyan Ojha and Piyush Chawla, but I guess these are not yet finished products. They are all products very much in the making. Amit Mishra has been around for some time and has impeccable temperament for a leggie. Piyush is still young and has delightful usage of the flight for a leggie. Pragyan Ojha to me seems more a containing option rather than a wicket taking one, so might be fitter in the ODI and T20 formats of the game. All in all I do not yet see a clear replacement emerging from the current pack, though this is a tremendous opportunity for the youngsters to step upto the plate. Cheers! Ram
@vinay049 (1839)
• India
5 Nov 08
yes i totally agree to you friend.this is wonderful answer.
1 person likes this
@ram_cv (16516)
• India
6 Nov 08
Thanks for the best rating. I think the Nagpur test is a great place for Mishra to cement his place. If he can take 5-8 wickets in this test, he would be on his way to cementing his place. Cheers! Ram
4 Nov 08
i think dhoni deserves............
4 Nov 08
2 be t captain........... n karthik cn replace dhoni
@vinay049 (1839)
• India
5 Nov 08
thanks for reply.but here we are talking about bowler not captain.and it is murali kartik--left arm bowler not dinesh kartik--wicket-keeper
@jazz555 (236)
• India
4 Nov 08
My answer is piyush chawala, he bowls pretty well. He is young , if he plays more matches. He will bowl great
@vinay049 (1839)
• India
5 Nov 08
yes he bowls well.
• India
6 Nov 08
I dont think Piyush Chawla is a replacement for Anil Kumble, he still has to play a lot of domestic cricket before he is ready for International cricket, I dont understand why these under 19 players get a chance so easily, there are players like Amit Mishra and Murali Karthik who have been performing in the domestic cricket for many years and they surely devserve a chance ahead of Piyush Chawla.
@gvaisakh (356)
• India
4 Nov 08
Well, it is a difficult question to answer............ I think the battle will be between amit mishra and piyush chawla......... Since Amit Mishra impressed in his very match against the mighty australians, I think Mishra would be the exact replacement for Anil Kumble......... HAPPY MYLOTTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@vinay049 (1839)
• India
5 Nov 08
at the moment,amit mishra is the best choice.but can't forget piyush chawala and murali kartik also
@subha12 (18463)
• India
6 Nov 08
I think a sof now we can't say there is any definite replacement. but some have to fill the gap. many spinners are coming and they should improve the performance to take place