Which part of Saw series you think was the BEST ?

India
January 2, 2009 10:47am CST
With inclusion of Saw 5 latest in the heart stopping series of SAW, which movie you think the JIGSAW killer played his best "GAME" ? I, personally, feel second and third were the best ones. How you people count on that ?
5 responses
• United States
2 Jan 09
Absolutely the first one. It has a very good plot and suspense. Personally, I thought the writing in the first movie was flawless. I have a habit, good or bad is to be determined, of picking apart movie plots. It's a writer's instinct thing but a lot of times I'll pick through a movie until I find something that doesn't fit with everything else or questions that were left unanswered and shouldn't have been, and I found nothing wrong with the original Saw. Something I don't think people realize is that only the third movie was written by the same pair of writers who wrote the original, James Wan and Leigh Whannell. Whannell co-wrote the second one and the fourth and fifth were written by two complete different guys. Another bit of trivia about the movies... Leigh Whannell was the other guy in the room with Cary Elwes in the first movie.
• India
3 Jan 09
Thanks for all of your trivia. Its was nice to see a movie buff of your type who takes interest in details of a movie to that depth. Keep Going...
@Tushavi (2078)
• Karachi, Pakistan
2 Jan 09
actually The Saw Movies is totally Gross & Useless if you wanna Watching a Real Horror movie watch out the "Hostel Part 1 & 2" & you know that the SAW series is Useless. have a nice day.
• India
3 Jan 09
I think you should re-consider your mind. There is no matching between the script of the Saws and the Hostels. Saw is far ahead in mind twisting storyline.
• Dominican Republic
3 Jan 09
Well, the first one I ever "saw" was the 2nd one... I thought the plot was great and it totally blew my mind off. The third one was a little too predictable for me and the 1st one is a definite must-see. I haven't seen the 4th or the 5th, but I bet they're great. Happy MyLotting and have a nice day! Xp
2 Jan 09
I really liked them all although I guess it is because I liked all the different things that were thought up! I bet a lot of work went into all of them to do the films! x
@di1159 (1580)
• United States
2 Jan 09
I agree with you. Of what I've "seen", (since most of the time, I'm covering my eyes during these movies), I liked the game of two and three best. The rest were mostly about coming up with different ways to chop off body parts. It's too gruesome for me to watch all, but the plots of II and III were good.