Renting a flat or buying with mortgages

@faisai (1138)
Hong Kong
June 3, 2009 5:18am CST
We know that one of the biggest cause of the financial crisis we are experiencing now is that people incapable of paying their mortgages are offered with super low interest rate when the economy is high. Later when the interest rate shoot up, they cannot payback their loan and thus trigger the fall in housing prices. Now, after such a long period of time, interest rate has fallen, housing prices have fallen. Would you consider buying a flat with mortgages now? Or you still prefer renting a flat?
1 person likes this
10 responses
@Jemina (5770)
3 Jun 09
We have a proverb in the Philippines saying, "Habang maikli ang kumot, magtiis mamaluktot" which in English simply means live within your means. Many Brits became a victim of this credit crunch and it has like a domino effect because not only are the debtors affected but many businesses and establishments as well. It has turned into a vicious cycle. As I look into these options you presented, either way you are literally losing some money either by paying rent or mortgage interest. We are currently on a mortgage and it will take 20 years more to pay off all of it.
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
4 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. As long as you need a place to live which is not already owned by you. You always need to pay for it unless your are getting any kind of assistance from your family/friends/government. So, the point is which one to go is better. Lose money on the rents or lose money on the interests.
1 person likes this
@Jemina (5770)
4 Jun 09
I think in the long run, mortgage is better. My husband just got this house about four years ago (before we even met). So it's still a long way to be able to pay off the rest. At the moment he is the only one who's got a decent job but he's receiving only an average wage. I on the other hand earn only between 50-100 a month. Anyway, what's helping us pay the bills is that we got two tenants and my husband is a very wise spender.
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
5 Jun 09
I wish you all the luck and hope that things will get better for you and your husband soon. In fact, it is sensible to believe that our wages will get higher rather than lower in a long run as we improve in skills and gain more experience. The mortgage, on the other hand, will only change due to fluctuation of interest rate.
1 person likes this
@amylan (187)
• France
3 Jun 09
Of course buying real assets as long as you could make sure a stable imcome to pay the mortgage. It's investment, while renting is just spending from which you're not gonne benefit from. Falling housing prices is just a short-term phenomene casued by the current crisis ,but on the other side , plus the low interest rates, it's the best oppotunity to purchase assets.
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
3 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. I also think that the crisis has pushed down the housing prices and with the valley of interest rate, it is a good time to make the purchase. I understand that having a stable income is required but then you need to pay the rent otherwise, so why not just draw a loan up to 30 years and buy a flat? At least I think it that way. :)
1 person likes this
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
5 Jun 09
Of course in the end we have to pay. But paying for the place to live seems to be quite a reasonable thing. I am just curious why so many people insist of renting a house when in fact they can use mortgage to buy the flat out. The monthly payment is very similar but you obvious get the ownership of the house in the end.
1 person likes this
@hairypits (294)
4 Jun 09
My advice to anyone right now is to take advantage of the current climate and buy. You can buy property at an all time low price and get a fixed rate mortgage with a really low rate and in 5 or 10 years sell for a major profit. We are doing this at the moment and renting them out
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
4 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. I also think that it maybe a good time to buy. Good not in the sense that the price will not go down in the near future. Moreover, everyone is saying that inflation is around the corner now and having a flat is one of the way to offset the adverse effect of that.
@arkasen (748)
• India
4 Jun 09
The fact is that whether to buy a flat or not depends upon lots of thing. Firtsly how sound you are financially and what is your income levels. Again if you are earning well then also you need to consider how steady your income is because you have to pay emi for a long time. Now in this time of crises there is no job security. Stable earnings are loosing their jobs. In this situation I think investing money on buying a flat may be risky. Again if these are not your concern then also you need to think of how often you switch places. If you switch places in two three years then it is always better to rent a flat. At this point of time if I were asked to rent or buy a flat then I will definitely rent a flat.
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
4 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. But even if you rent a flat, you still need a stable income or otherwise you will be forced out by the flat owner. The fact is if you go to purchase a flat, you can still walk away if you really cannot handle the monthly payment. As far as I know, other than not able to keep the flat, there is really no adverse effect of leaving the flat and let the bank have your flat in US if you just walk away.
• Italy
3 Jun 09
It depends on my incomes, friend... If I have the necessary money I certainly buy a flat, because, after that, it is mine! If I have some financial problems I think that I rent a flat, but, whenever I will have the possibility, I buy a flat! This is my opinion!
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
3 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. Of course it depends on the financial situation especially the income. But even if you don't buy a flat, you still need to pay the rent which in effect is helping the flat owner to pay off his mortgage where in the end, you get nothing.
• Italy
3 Jun 09
Exactly! But I want something at the end, not to get nothing! For this reason I will want to buy my house!
• India
4 Jun 09
hi faisai, in older days so many people's mostly in the middle calss families they are trouble but in now a days most of the banks give us loans for us to build a new home.so it is so easy for us to own a house but in this system interest rate is so high that is the one of the disadvantages but also it is not atall a great disadvantages there are so many advantages in this system
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
4 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. What is the average interest rate for taking out a mortgage at your place? Is is rather low in where I live that it is next to free money. It is always said that the banks are full of money without any purposes and thus they are willing to loan money at very low interest rate now.
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
4 Jun 09
Buying real estate is still a good investment but the key is to get a good price on the property and a fixed rate mortgage. The mortgage crisis was caused by people getting adjustable rate mortgages, which went up when interest rates went up. Many people didn't believe that interest rates would go up and some just didn't understand what they were getting themselves into.
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
4 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. To get at a good price is difficult. It is just like asking people to only buy low sell high in the stock market. I believe that as long as you can pay off the monthly mortgage payment, then you should consider purchasing a flat. In the end, paying the mortgage and paying the rent are not that different as long as you still want a place to live. I think that the crisis is actually because people have a misconception that the interest rate will be low forever which is simply not necessarily true. I will say that when we calculate the amount of monthly payment we can handle, we better factor in the fact that interest rate can increase over time and that our earnings can actually cover the extra interests when the time comes.
@med889 (5941)
3 Jun 09
Here in Britain people prefer to have their own house to live in so buying a flat for oneself seems more reliable than paying the rent every month. We have a house not an appartment and I am very happy for that. My parents have surely done a wonderful job to buy a house. Even my boyfriend has a house he has built up and I am just happy as I do not have to pay rent every month or to mortgage anything because as You said we can mortgage something but when we cannot pay then we loose everyting. I do not want to fall in this category though.
@TrvlArrngr (4045)
• United States
3 Jun 09
buying is usually always better. you get the tax write offs for owning a home. plus you can make noise or change the structure without having to get approval or get in trouble. You can plant what you want. fence it in or not - depending on if it is a house or flat. have pets. have kids. have a pool, have a hot tub. i love it.
@faisai (1138)
• Hong Kong
3 Jun 09
Thanks for your reply. I also think that having a house give your more freedom as you can do whatever you like with the house without the fear of the house owner want you to undo everything when you leave it. Still, there are so many people prefer renting a flat instead of owning one for the sake of flexibility in choosing locations. I just want to tell them that as long as you have found one location good enough, there really isn't a reason to change at all.
@tpayne33 (52)
• United States
4 Jun 09
Well,buying your own home is always better the renting. Buying at the right prices it he tricky part. The reason I say owning your own home is better is because once you pay it off no one can throw you out of because you didn't pay this month. You also have to consider the financial benefits. Even in these hard times a flat,as you English say it, can help you get a loan if you need it especially if you have a good payment history. So owning a "Flat" is always a better.