Should we follow tradition?

United States
September 9, 2009 11:41pm CST
When I was growing up as a kid my family didn't celebrate holidays and birthdays. It never bothered me. I probaly questioned it once. The other kids would have things to say because it was odd to them that we didn't celebrate the holidays. Now that I'm older and have a child of my own I'm at a crossroads because my fiancee has been into the holiday thing. I don't see why we have to raise our child on these traditions. When my birthday came around I was just happy to make it to see the next age. Halloween and Christmas are the two most expensive holidays. Yet people save up money to buy gifts, candy, and decorations for these days, and end up broke for the new year trying to pay off their debts. Should we continue this pattern? What is the purpose behind these holidays? If it's just for fun can't we find another less expensive way to entertain our kids? What's your take it?
1 person likes this
8 responses
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
10 Sep 09
Hi Hadrian, We celebrate birthdays to thank God for the blessing of another year. God likes celebrations and parties are external ways of showing our gratefulness and happiness. The same with Christmas and Halloween. We remember the birth of the Christ child more than two millenniums ago. We exchange gifts because we want to extend the graces we have received from the Almighty. With the Halloween, we remember the departed. The business people had capitalized on our emotions and traditions. The celebrations had become materialistic and grandiose. Do celebrate only with what you have. My family exchange gifts with perfumed soaps or scented candles, inspirational books or art craft tools. We give only what we can.
• United States
11 Sep 09
I couldn't have worded this answer better myself! I completely agree with you. Holidays are celebrated to give thanks to God, to give thanks for our lives, and to remember those who have passed. There is nothing wrong with being thankful and celebrating. If you do what you can, and keep it simple then there should be no debt incurred and everyone is just happy to have been together to celebrate.
1 person likes this
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
Thanks coach. Here's a prayer that you live on with many more meaningful celebrations with your loved ones.
• United States
16 Sep 09
I understand where you are coming from as far as doing what you can and not going overboard. I can appreciate celebrating birthdays to thank God for seeing another year. Even if it was started when a young woman asked for John the baptist head for her birthday. I don't want to get to into religion, but as far as christmas goes no one really knows when Christ was born. We just go on what tradition has taught us. Even if it is certain I would think that praying everyday and following Gods laws shows our apreciation. In fact that's all he asks for from us. Now with Halloween I don't see how dressing up and going out for candy has anything to do with remembering the departed. And what departed should we be remembering?
@lamar91 (25)
10 Sep 09
Tradition is best way to have a respectful and happy life ,when the tradition is related to fair judgment. This is one of the reasons ,our society have fail today when it comes to conduct . The modernism of the world has changed mind of a lot of people ,made then worse in behavior. Overall it is a good idea to follow traditions when ii is based on a fair judgment ,because it will allow us to have the best manner ,highly respectful,best conduct ,love because all humanity are one family. Fair tradition bring union and love
• United States
16 Sep 09
How does tradition set your manner, respect level, or conduct? Those are things that should be taught as a child just because in order to function properly in society you should possess those values. I do agree though that the tradition should be related to fair judgment. It should be tradition that you create wth you family.
@pooh08 (671)
• Vietnam
11 Sep 09
I think now we are living in the modern life. We have to change our life for suite with this life. Of course, we only change somethings we think these don't suite with this life. Somethings in tradition are good and benefit, we should keep it forever. For example, in my country, member of family will meet together in the dinner for relax, chat, talk everything he/she met in weekday. It help each one can more understand each others. I think some traditions are good for us, we should keep it and develop it. Others can be rejected.
@lynnemg (4529)
• United States
11 Sep 09
I can kind of relate to your situation. My husband grew up not celebrating holidays, but I grew up always celebrating them. When we got together, he was against the whole idea of celebrating them and as a matter of fact, he actually made them miserable for me due to his negativity about them. Now, three years later, he is beginning to warm up to then a little more. I do agree that most of the time, people go way overboard, and there is too much commercialism with holidays, but I also think that kids should be able to experience the joy of them. You don't have to spend a lot of money and go all out, there is no sense in going in debt for it as far as I am concerned. As a matter of fact, if we can't afford it, we don't buy it and it is very rare that my kids get anything expensive for any holiday. They still enjoy it though. It is not so much about the gifts as it is about a family holiday spent together making memories.
@cbakin20 (149)
• United States
10 Sep 09
I don't personally like the idea of holidays too much, they're too commercial. I agree with your points about saving up and then having to just repeat the next year. It seems crazy! But holidays have some good to them, too. It's true there are other ways to amuse your kids, but having that one time to look forward to is a lot of fun for them. If they can get one night where they get tons of free candy, it just makes them incredibly happy! The same goes with christmas when they get other free stuff. It happens various times throughout the year--just often enough to make it so that the kids really like the holidays and look forward to them.
• United States
16 Sep 09
That's just what I mean. I want to give my son other days to look forward to other than the traditional society holidays. If he doesn't learn about them then there is nothing to look forward to. I'm not saying create your own holiday, but why not compensate with something that you started rather than following tradition.
• United States
10 Sep 09
Just a thought...I'm glad you're looking at this now, before you marry. You and your fiance' would need to agree on this now rather than it become an issue after you're married. It doesn't have to be a big deal. Would your fiance' be happy to tone down the celebrations? Or would you be ok with having something simple and small that your fiance' would also enjoy? Would he be happy if you didn't celebrate at all? I'm betting not. Would you be totally unhappy if you celebrated in some way? You'll have to do some soul searching and so will he, before you tie the knot. Best of luck to you both!
• United States
16 Sep 09
Thank you for your advice. I agree this is definitely something that we need to straighten out before we get married. Right now he is just two so he doesn't really know to much about the holidays. I think if we don't make it sch a big deal he would not look forward to them. But I think I will have to bend a little to keep the peace. Thank you for the luck.
• Philippines
11 Sep 09
Yes, I strongly believe that doing things that would make you even happier is necessary for yourself. Enjoy those days of yours. Follow a tradition and you will see the good effect in your life. It is the way of thanking, celebrating! It is really a good feeling and you will feel contented if you are celebrating holidays. It is a fun of life. Give yourself a gift by celebrating it.
• China
11 Sep 09
For me, I think I'd like to follow the tradition. But I agree with your opinion completely. I miss the traditional festivels when I was a child. People in that period had less money than today. But everyone was simple and sincere. When the traditional festivals, I didn't get many gifts, but I really enjoyed the feelings along with my whole family, my parents and relatives, friends, and neighbors. But now everything seems changing. People will celebrate these festivals and their birthdays wantonly. They spend a lot of money and receive expensive gifts. But the feelings are not good. And relationship between people are also changed. Now I still celebrate traditions in my own way and enjoy the feeling in real tradition, and also think about the real meanings of each festival and my birthday. No expensive gifts or large-scale scenes, but absolutely warm and meaningful!