Is justice being done to Harry Potter books by makin the movies..??
October 8, 2009 1:47am CST
I dont think that justice was done to harry potter books by making movie atleast the last one i.e 6th part.....smthing is written in the book n is shown completely different in the movie....Wth i mean complete changes in the movie.why so..?? Why changing the story...?? what will it help in benefitting..??
12 Oct 09
I think all HP fan will completely agree that the adaptation is not as good as the book. It will not and never will. Harry Potter is a book with hundreds of pages which impossible to be made in 2 or 3 hours movie. Besides, there are some text that just cannot be translated into moving images. I just hope for a nice adaptation of the book coming in the final installment. The last one is good (although many of you may disagree), but the fifth one is the worst. I still wonder why they're keeping David Yates as the director. I much prefer Alfonso Cuaron approach in HP 3. It's dark, gloomy, and although some important plot cut from the movie, it's very enjoyable.
8 Oct 09
I liked the first movie though, the most accurate one if i remember correctly. No, the movies don't do justice to the books but it's the way it always turns out in the end. You can't put everything in the movie but I think that if they were more concentrated on the story rather than on the money they could have made better (more accurate) movies. As movies alone they're are ok but if you know how the books look like you'll hate them:)
13 Oct 09
When i was reading the book, i was so fascinated i remember one part of the book and when the movie came on the big screen (movie house) that part was totally wicked.. i mean there's a lot of changes in the story. The book was different from the movie.. It was a kind of diffrent of the two.