Why is my brother-in-law so concened about my body weight?

@cream97 (29087)
United States
November 3, 2009 5:00pm CST
My brother-in-law and I were in a conversation about general topics. And all of a sudden he told me that there was a product that I could use that would shrink my belly fat. He said that he told some girls about it and they have used it. and it has worked for them. Which I thought was great. But, I am somewhat confused... I did not ask of his opinion about my body size.. I felt offended after this conversation was over with. I told my husband about it. And he said that I should have stood up for myself. He told me that his brother had no right to approach me about my body weight. So, it bothered me and I could not just let him get away with being too personal with me. A week later I calmly and politely told him that he should keep his comments to himself. I told him if I did not ask of his opinion, that he should not give it. It is so many things that I can get on him about, about himself. But, I don't. He does what he do. So, I try to keep my personal comments to myself. It bothered me because, if he saw my belly, then I know that he has been viewing my rear end.. He is my brother-in-law, not my health doctor. I don't want him to come to me in that kind of manner. It is very uncomfortable. Especially, coming from his mouth. I told him about this, and he has never been too personal to me ever since.. My mother-in-law said that he was out of line for saying that to me. Honestly, my belly fat is not all that big, My brother-in-law has never accepted the fact that I have put on added weight. He is used to seeing me skinny like a string bean. But, since I had my kids, I have put on an extra 40lbs. I don't look fat at all. I am still a small medium size. When he told me that it made me feel fat and ugly. My brother-in-law is very tall and skinny. He eats a lot of empty calories, which are sweets.. I guess to his eyes I am a little plump.. But I am not. He should worry about himself. I am not at the risk of being unhealthy with my added weight. I wondered.... He is always on the phone texting and talking to all kinds of girls all day long.. When I was in college 12 years ago, he claimed to have seen me on campus.. I wondered if he had some kind of attraction for me.. Not that I wanted him to. And one time a couple of years later after that, he was trying to talk to me in the mall.. He wanted to get with me... I was not at all interested. The guy looked just like him.. I turned him down so fast... This was before I met his brother, which is his brother, whom I have been married to for eight years.
2 people like this
10 responses
• Southend-On-Sea, England
4 Nov 09
I don't think it's any of his business how big or small your belly is. It sounds as though you dealt with it well but it's sad (natural though) that his insensitive and possibly untrue comments have made you feel bad about yourself. Maybe it's he who should be feeling bad about HIMself?
3 people like this
• United States
3 Nov 09
That is just so inappropriate that he brought that up. If you feel comfortable in your body, and you are happy with your weight, then that is all that matters. You need to tell that man to see how his body will look after having kids, and then have him come back and judge you, he definitely needs to take a big step back, get off his judgemental high horse, and be more of a gentleman to the woman that his brother married. He sounds like he is just one of those jerky guys that has to point out others faults to make himself feel better.
3 people like this
• Singapore
4 Nov 09
glad that you told him off. Whatever size you are in is definitely non of his business. i think it's rude for him to even suggest any products to you. Dont let him bother you much, the most important thing is that you got a husband who loves you for who you are, and your kids :)
1 person likes this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
4 Nov 09
Hi, eunice, yes my husband loves my body size. When I call myself fat, my hubbie will get annoyed with me and tell me that I am not fat at all. I know that many women feel that way when they have children. He says that he loves my body, it is very sexy. He loves touching me. He is very intrigued with me. His attraction for me is very obvious. I don't care what my bil says, I am not his girl, I am his brother's girl.
• Singapore
5 Nov 09
you are really lucky that your husband is so loving!!! my hubby is so skinny that it made me felt so inferior....worst thing is that i dont even have kids yet LOL
1 person likes this
@royal52gens (5488)
• United States
4 Nov 09
I can understand that his comments bothered you. He caught you off-guard initially. But you are right. He should have kept his thoughts to himself unless you had asked for his thoughts and advice. Then he could have presented his idea to you. He probably thought he was being helpful but you and I know he used the wrong approach. I hope he did not intend on insulting you. It is good you talked to him and let him know how you felt about the issue.
2 people like this
• India
4 Nov 09
Hey cream97, it is obvious, that your brother in law has got the hots for you. If he is able to remember you when you were in college, it certainly shows that he was attracted to you. It is quite certain, that not only he is looking at your belly, but he has been looking more things than that. Well you need not have to worry about this unduly, because usually as soon as he gets married or he starts dating a girl these things go away. You have to worry only when, even after his marriage, he gives the roving eyes on you.
1 person likes this
• India
4 Nov 09
Well, I thought this happened only in India, it seems men are the same wherever they are.
1 person likes this
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
4 Nov 09
Yes it happens here in America. Some of it you see and others you don't see. Men and women have roving eyes.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
4 Nov 09
Hi, ramesh... I feel like he may be watching me in not a brother-in-law kind of way, Not that I want him to. Sometimes when he is on the phone, I can swear that he is looking at my rear end as I past by him when he is sitting on the couch.
@rg0205 (2636)
• Hong Kong
4 Nov 09
He had no right to talk to you like that. Actually, no one has the right to talk down to you about your body. I think that's a bit overboard. Good for you for telling him off. I can't really say whether he has the hots for you because I dont know the guy personally but then, either way, he has no right to talk to you like that.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Nov 09
some people seem to think they are "helping" and offer unwarranted advice,not realizing they sound like a jerk. if he keeps it up,i'd do the same thing back and see how he likes it.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
4 Nov 09
cream I just hate people like your brother in law who got so personal and was onto you about belly fat. It is not his place to talk to you like that.my goodness most women who have had' kids always put on a little weight.You do not sound fat to me and anyway he was way out of line. Don't let him make you feel bad, perhaps he is not so healthy himself even if he is skinny.Tell your loud mouthed bro in law that empty sweets could well land him with diabetes if he persists with the fat belly stuff. I bet your husband was really teed off with him. dont take it to heart. you know you look good.
1 person likes this
@kellyjeanne (1576)
• United States
6 Nov 09
Yea, it's only natural for a woman who has given birth to have some amount of belly fat. Even if he was trying to be well meaning he should have known that that is a touchy subject and should not have brought it up. To be concerned about your health is one thing, but, to be obsessed with it is quite another. His concerns are in the wrong direction. Take care, cream! Purrs, Catwoman=^..^= & Mija
• China
4 Nov 09
It maybe careful from his heart. You have a good family, a good brother-in -law, a good mother-in -law. I think you have a happy life.
@cream97 (29087)
• United States
4 Nov 09
Hi, x. I would like to think so but a part of me feels that there will always be issues with him towards me. My in-law's have not always been kind to me. There are various moments and circumstances that I can name that can validate my story.