Is it a right decision to play Saha keeping a talented batsman like Rohit Sharma

India
February 6, 2010 12:19pm CST
even though bengal wicket keeper got a chance to make his test debut,i think the best option was rohit sharma.he is very talented.eventhough in the last match he didnt perfoemed well,dont forget the triple century made by him in the ranji trophy.
2 people like this
4 responses
@ram_cv (16516)
• India
7 Feb 10
Rohit Sharma was injured at the start of the match and hence Dhoni was forced to play Saha. It was not a decision he wanted to make, but was forced to make. So in that sense it is not because Saha is more talented, but because Dhoni had no choice to make. I do not think Saha can play as an out and out batsman, so the balance of the team is definitely affected by this, but when there are no options available, you are not bothered about the balance. Cheers! Ram
@ajithlal (14569)
• India
12 Feb 12
Now a days Rohit Sharma is becoming a very good player and is becoming more consistent than before.
@Wismay (2038)
• India
6 Feb 10
I heard Rohit got injured while practicing. Actually he was selected to play in the place of Laxman if Laxman is not available. Young pace bowlers should have got the chance to play. Selection of final 11 players could have been better but only captain and coach can choose the final eleven. Happy Mylotting!
1 person likes this
@ajithlal (14569)
• India
8 Feb 10
I think one more batsman should have been picked instead of Laxman since Laxman was not completely fit.
@amitavroy (4824)
• India
6 Feb 10
Well my friend I think you have not followed the news from the start. If you would have seen then you would know that Saha was picked because Dhoni was not at his 100 percent. Which meant the team should play an extra player who can keep. Dravid is out of question. And so the obvious choice was Saha. And more over, as far as I know, Rohit Sharma is also injured or had some problems. But I guess the best player for this situation would have been Dinesh Kartik. But the sad part is that he is a part of the team.
@ajithlal (14569)
• India
26 Feb 12
I think everybody should be given equal chance. I think it is great to take a player who is in form that to take player who is not in form. I also think that player who is injured should be rested so that the player does not increase his injury.
@ajithlal (14569)
• India
7 Feb 10
I also read the news that Rohit Sharma had got injured and that is the reason why Saha was picked. I think most probably selectors should have picked some extra bastsman rather than injured team. I am on the opinion that there should be a fitness test and the players who are injured should not be picked and other players should be given so that they don't have less players to chose for the playing eleven.