What purpose is there really in having children?

New Zealand
February 27, 2010 3:17am CST
I am fascinated by people that dfeel the need to replicate themselves. I mean the childis probably going to suffer somewhere along the way then die of some disgusting disease. So if it is a truly caring gesture, it isn't a particularly well thought out one. If you can explain it to me I am all ears. No one has ever come close to clarifying a decision to have a kid in my eyes.
7 people like this
34 responses
@MrKennedy (1978)
27 Feb 10
Wow mandybeau, you certainly don't have an optimistic view on children. I mean, "they will suffer along the way then die of some disease"? That's a terrible way to look at it Just think, if everybody thought that there was no purpose in having children, neither you or I would be here today, and the Earth's population would vanish so fast
2 people like this
• New Zealand
27 Feb 10
Wow MrKennedy lol/ I have exactly the right view point that uis exactly what will happen, and you and I both know it. As for the last paragraph, we wouldn't miss what we never knew, as for Earths pop vanishing so fast. look at the mess mankind is making of it. Prob. best it does. Thanks for your reply. At least you don't want them to look after you when you are old. Have a Great Night.
@RawBill1 (8531)
• Gold Coast, Australia
28 Feb 10
I am surprised by your negativity towards having children. What makes you think that "the child is probably going to suffer somewhere along the way then die of some disgusting disease"? My experiences with being a parent are all positive. It is not an easy path sometimes, but it is most definitely worth it and I could not imagine life without my kids. As soon as I became a parent, I felt content, like I had found peace and could stop searching for happiness as I had found it in becoming a parent. Watching them grow over the years and learning each and every new thing in life has been a joy and will continue to be for a long time. I personally think that if you do not have kids, then you will most likely be lonely in your old age. I love to watch older people that are the head of a big family and the respect that they are given for creating everyone around them at family functions.
@lelin1123 (15595)
• Puerto Rico
27 Feb 10
Most women go thru this feeling deep inside of wanting a child. I know I felt it back in the day. If I had to do it all over again though with what I know today I would not have had any. Like you said children will suffer one day due to hardships that everyone goes through at one time or another. I think about this now seeing my granddaughter and wishing her to be happy. However, I know she will, just like everyone else have to deal with things that are not good in her lifetime and the thought of that makes me so sad.
1 person likes this
@messageme (2821)
• United States
1 Mar 10
Before I had my first child I didn't think of the negatives that would come for the child or the positive. But knowing what I know now I don't think I still would ever say I wouldn't have had none. Children are part of our lifes challanges. Isn't life more boring with no challanges? I feel hurt when they get hurt, I feel happy when they are happy. When my kids get older and have to deal with more heartships I will feel for them but we are here to guide them and help them. It is more of just a preference of your own if you want those challanges or not.
• New Zealand
27 Feb 10
Seems like it is an instinct as said before, and sadly an instinct people just give into. At least you know where I am coming from, Your grandaughter will have heaps of good times too. Its just from my slant I think it is all pointless. But don't get me wrong I have no issues with depression, an a person that lives it to the max. I think its because i have a High IQ I analyse too much. Good topc tho and I am hearing from others, most of the males I know said they only had children because their wives harped on. They would have preferred to stay footloose and fancy free. But there again most also said they would have stayed single lol.
• United States
28 Feb 10
Lelin, your post is a bit confusing to me. You say that if you had known then what you know now you wouldn't have had children but at the same time you mentioned your granddaughter. To have not had kids, she would not exist. I have five grandchildren and I can't imagine thinking that if I had things to do over they wouldn't be here. Of course, she, like everyone else will have to deal with life's little ups and downs but isn't that what makes us stronger, isn't that what molds us into being who we really are?
@allknowing (130067)
• India
27 Feb 10
It is a natural craving to have someone in our life who we can bring up and be proud of seeing them grow. But in today's world with the problems that one faces some opt for the DINKS status (Double Income No Kids) and perhaps use their resources to improve the world in other ways.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
27 Feb 10
Thats me, the World is a mess I come from a privileged background in terms of schooling food always there good clothes, I have never seen the point in having Children, so the Dinkys was invented for me. I have never been able to find anyone that can give me a real reason why they are doing it. Most say and this is selfish so I will be looked after in my old age. They obviously do not know the reality of this. I have never had any cravings to have kids. I though well I'm here I'm gonna make the most of it before I kick the bucket, as it were.
@allknowing (130067)
• India
27 Feb 10
Most seniors are languishing in their homes, forlorn and lonely children having left the shores seeking greener pastures. It is folly to think that children are brought into this world so that the elders can be taken care. Children have their share of burden in a world such as the one we are living in just now.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
I know, I know, I was in a Youth Club and we mowed lawns for needy in the Community, you had three sorts. Genuinely needy, with no one Ie they had no rellies to help. 2 Those that saw you as a cheap alternative to the lawn guy. Then there was the third Group. I always remember, this old lady living in a cruddy pension flat. We mowed the Lawn and she gave us the usual biccies and Tea, and the cursory chat. I noticed all these pictures of literally piles of kids all over her walls in various states of aging. Turned out she had nine, I asked her Are they Abroad, Oh no she says, They haven't got that kind of money the smallest of their families is also nine, By now I am thinking her relatives are here and we mow the lawns for free. She then tells me that 4 were unemployed and they were too busy with the problems that they had with their kids to bother about her. So much for having kids to look after you when you are old. In our Culture it just isn't so.
• United States
27 Feb 10
I don't have children myself, and probably will never be able to, but for the most part is, if people did not have children, likely the human race would die out. On top of that, you don't know if a child is going to suffer a horrible disease or what they might go through, just as your parents couldn't tell what hardships you were going to face. To have a child is entirely up to the person and to the partner, but to bring a child into the world just to get money, care, and attention, is sick in my book. Children are not money making machines. If people can honestly bring a child into the world to learn about love and acceptance, by giving it to the child, while teaching the child the same in return, I see nothing wrong with that. But again, as I said, just like animals who reproduce, humans must also reproduce in order to keep the species alive and ongoing. Otherwise, we'd all die out, and not a single one of us would be left.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
Firestorm am hearing you, but everyones parents knows the kids aren't going to have a brilliant end. I mean How many cool ways of dying are there, they are all pretty horrible. I think the last generation, only had kids, because they felt it was the thing to do. Many more question it today. But as for happy and the to look after you when you are old and sick, you are right that is so sick, I cant comprehend it. So many in this country of the lower socio group have kids to ensure a State paid benefit, till the kid is 16, 18 if still at school, it used to be 5 but they got around that by having more children. Sadly the people like you, sane and nice are not the ones having all the kids, seems its the thicker ones that just have two instincts. One to breed and the other to gain pecuniary vantage from the process.
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
Firestorm if it was mandatory to have children perish the thought, then i think you would be one of the best equipped intelligently that I have come accross, Happy and some of the others are just so behind the times. I didn't know there were still people that thought like that. There is a woman doing a reality T.V Show I saw that on here, she is pushing all the boundaries, and that is for money her name is Michel duggar.
• Bulgaria
27 Feb 10
The prologation of the species is one of the strongest instincts. Of course, there are emotional, psichologycal and social aspects. But first of all, it's an instinct.
1 person likes this
@ghieptc (2522)
• Philippines
28 Feb 10
I think kids is our hope & future because we are going to be old. Kids is our treasure. We have to multiply in order to exist.
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
lol. We agree to disagree o.k.
• New Zealand
27 Feb 10
I have strong survival instincts, I have instincts to go shopping lol. But I don't have an instinct to have Children, Surely I am not the only one out there. I have friends exactly the same.
@jbrooks0127 (2324)
• United States
28 Feb 10
With the kind of outlook you have about children don't ever....ever....even think of having one. You sound like you have had an experience in your life that was pretty bad involving children. I can't imagine you just picking this attitude out of the air. No one that has ever been born will get out of life alive. It is only a question of when and how. To dwell on that alone and make that your primary reason for not having them guarantees a very miserable live for you and your family if you ever decide you are wrong. I have a daughter and a son and I can't even imagine ever feeling the way you do. My son became a diabetic at age 8. We learned how to handle it and today he is 38 years old and doing well. Both have families that I love dearly and if I had your attitude I would have missed out on sooooo much. I thank God I never...ever felt the way you do.
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Mar 10
I consider it a compliment that you see that I am a religious person. As such I do believe in immortality but it in no way reflects my desire, or lack of it, to have children. Some people truly love children and to have their own is the ultimate goal. Others have children because they believe it is what you do following marriage. The former or course we would expect to be very good and loving parents. The latter would be a toss up. But both have a legitimate reason for having them. All living things are programmed to reproduce. It is what makes the species continue on. Clearly there are some people who should not have had children as they have no clue how to raise them and find them to be something that holds them back from the wonderful life they envisioned. That is sad for the child. Regarding my son's diabetes. This was inherited. The potential of both my children to contract it was there but at the time we had them, only my wives mother had it. No other history that we knew of on either side. So we took the chance. Strangely enough at age 41 my wife contracted it also. The thing I am trying to point out is that there are no guarantees for any of us. But when things go bad we do what we can, and move on. My son contracted at age 8. My first wife, his mother, at 41. My second wife got it at age 42 but failed to take care of herself. She suffered the consequences of that and passed away at age 64. My son is 38 and doing well and his mother is 67 and doing well. I will read what 'Chanelgirls' has to say. I think we all know that, for the most part, men do have all the breaks regarding this issue. What I am trying to tell you is that I am 69 years old and looking back at most of my life I can tell you I would have not done anything differently. I love my children and the thought of not ever having them, at least for me, is unthinkable. However because you feel the way you do, you are very right in your decision. It clearly reflects that you are a very responsible person, not willing to compromise. That is very much the way it should be.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
No, I plucked it out of the air, without any justification, perhaps because my life was as easy and perhaps because I saw people that had Children often as broke, wondering where their lives had gone. Don't worry won't be changing the mind ever hahaha One thing I do is make a decision and stick to it. You say one of your kids has diabetes, thats a horrible thing, so really you have simply added fuel to my fire. It doesn't even need to be in your family diabetes is everywhere these days. I simply cannot get why people are so hell bent on having kids. Why don't you have a look at Chanelgirls discussion, she sees things from a diff/ point from me. She sees it as men having all the Breaks. So it has opened a wide discusion sometimes heated, sometimes in agreeance. But one thing I have noticed is that people with kids, seem to need to justify their position more than those that can't be bothered. You are clearly religious so possibly you look at things in a light that you will all go on into immortality, I dunno
@bdugas (3578)
• United States
28 Feb 10
First of all you got one heck of a outlook on life, second of all I didn't know that I brought 3 children into this world to make sure there was someone to take care of me when I grow old. You are suppose to work and have those plans made, so that you are not a burden on your children when you grow old. I agree that some are not cut out to have children, they lack the patiences that it takes to raise a child. And I guess if that is what they want then it is ok by me, because I figure that any child brought into that kind of a home would not be treated the way a loving set of parents treat their children, so they better off with out kids. I have 2 sons and a daughter and they are my life, I look at them and where they are in life and know that I did a good job of raising them and I'm very proud of all 3 of them, they in turn have children and those being my grand kids are also my life. The only reason that you need to have a child is to want to have one and love it. So the world is messed up, I'm 62 years old and it has been messed up since I can remember, but they had a chance at life just like I did, what they decided to do with that chance was their decession. We all suffer along life's way, yes some die at a early age, that is part of life. You said you was brought up in a good home, you never said whether you had brothers or sisters, but you sound to me to be a very selfish person, wanting every thing for your self and nothing to share with the world, but then that is my opinion. God made it possible for us to have children, he blessed us with that. And as a parent I am proud to be one, and suffering along the way is the way we grow strong. Wonder if your parents thought that way and you was a mistake, they didn't plan on making, I feel sorry for you. Can't say that because you was raised in a well to do home that you come across that it was a loving home. You can have all the riches in the world and fine clothes to wear, when you are a kid, if there is no love there then it isn't worth 2 cents.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
2 Mar 10
My parents were the ultimate, my brothers well one I decided to write off as a selfish tosser, but I had it all. Yet still decided no Point. You are 62 so you are alot older than me. My outlook I believe is based on fact not fiction. Thanks for the reply it didn't surprise me.
@bellis716 (4799)
• United States
1 Mar 10
If no one had children, the world have -0- population in a generation. Then, there is the fact that we do get old and frequently senile. It would be nice to have at least one younger person who cares about us.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
1 Mar 10
Yeah they'd be awful busy lol.
@iridium (431)
3 Mar 10
yeah i've never understood the desire to have children. i don;t like them and i don;t want to ever have them.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
23 Mar 10
Sensible Person. Lol
• United States
28 Feb 10
It's part of life, and if you don't want that life then don't. It's called Family and what we were designed for, not some self absorbed pittyful life you describe. Life was wasted on you my friend. You are self destructive and will die with no other purpose to live except money.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Feb 10
Ouch! That was a bit harsh, your opinion but a bit harsh. I don't really understand people that don't want children either but I guess not having different opinions is what makes the world go round.
• India
1 Mar 10
Some days ago I started a question who is happy Parent (couple) with or with out children. About 20 responses have viewed and their responses were very good. and I have commented all the responses.This question is about the children. What is the reason we have come to the world, to earn, to sleep , to eat and when we do not know our purpose what is the purpose we should have a children. The present world is not good for children.Every where there is no peace and some elements do create problems for the selfish reason. Selfishness and Money power rule the states.
1 person likes this
@happy2512 (1266)
• Philippines
27 Feb 10
The children are considered the fruit of love in a relationship or being married its really very bad if some couple was not able to have a child of their own. Because the happiness that the having a child cannot surpass any wealth that you have & the child can make us more rewarding especially if we were able to do our part of fulfilling our responsibility to our children not just clothing them & feeding them but also the major gift we can give them by educating them & giving the best that we can give them. The more we can raise them well the more that they will do their part to serve us when we are old & sick. Its just a matter of giving back in return what they show us.
1 person likes this
@messageme (2821)
• United States
1 Mar 10
I'm just curious happy do you take care of your parents?
• New Zealand
27 Feb 10
Happy that is so selfish you had them so they can look after you when you are sick and old lucky old them.. Exactly my point.
@Mady2791 (545)
• United States
28 Feb 10
The purpose is to be able to take a family portrait, along with others, frame them and put place them all over the house and show them off to visitors that don't have children so that they can feel sorry for themselves.
1 person likes this
@Mady2791 (545)
• United States
28 Feb 10
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
thats naughty mady hahahah I think it is the funniest response do we have a button for that we should.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
30 Mar 10
hi mandybeau Children are lucky if they do not have a mom who feels like you. I admire your stand as it takes a special kind of woman to want to raise children, and not all women fit into that category. Why on earth would a child have to suffer and die of some disgusting disease? this is the 21st century not the 17th century. Those things rarely happen. but women who are born with the maternal instinct do want children and they will make great mothers. but if a woman is forced into having children who feels as you do that they will only get sick and die, she will make a very bad mother. We will all die some day but so what. Does there have to be a purpose in having a baby, say we love children and we want a family is that not enough purpose? lord. what an odd question. Please do not ever have a child as you would not make a good mom. I do not think that you will get an answer that would suit you, as you do not want to believe there is any reason to have children. You are all ears, thats a sarcastic saying so you will not be satisfied with any of our answers. I feel that you are very intelligent. You know how you feel and you should stick to the life style you want, some women are not meant to bear children, and children are safer if those women do not ever have children.
1 person likes this
@GADHISUNU (2162)
• India
27 Feb 10
You are right saying that having a kid or kids is any guarantee that they will take care of you in old age. That culture or concept is fast vanishing in countries like India too, where family values are high. In the sense family feels answerable to eah other, and it was toll a generation ago an unwritten principle that sons take care of their parents in their old age. Today many are consigned to Old Age Homes, an idea a few decades ago would have been thought sacrilege. So, on this point yyou are rather right! Now onto the point why have children at all. If you ask me I would mean for records. By that I mean to leave your genetic imprint in the world. Now, how does it help? What if you are one of the most intelligent or one of the most beautiful persons. Then the loss of your genetic material is a loss to the world in general Now in societies like India, having a child is the only [B]hard evidence[/B] that the couple copulate with results! Otherwise, you are just a male and female incapable of producing! Now this will also vanish, but then in places like India it will be a few decades before DINKs will be the norm. For Indians don't mind sharing what little they have with their children. If not for anything at least India with her unrestrained creation has proven one thing to the world. That is: A natin that keeps multiplying, stays "young". See how the Indian youth are storming the world!?! If not for anything they have falsified the doomsday predictions.
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
the Indian kids here are changing alot don't you think?, many are not going through with arranged marriages, which is prob. not that great an idea as most Indian Couples did at least try to stick with it. Intersting remarks. Thank you BTW I love the Culture and the food.
@thezone (9394)
• Ireland
27 Feb 10
Hi mandybeau, You are serious, aren't you ? If the concept of having children has to be explained, then you will never understand.
1 person likes this
• New Zealand
28 Feb 10
Hi thezone, do I sound like I am laughing lol :) You just answered a question, with out answering it. Shrewd.
• India
2 Mar 10
Sometimes we can not explain our feelings by words. In the same way i can not explain it in words about having children. You have to experience it, then only you can understand.
@lindsiko (355)
• United States
28 Feb 10
I'm pretty grateful that my parents decided to have me. Yes, there is a lot of suffering in the world for everyone, but I believe that's just part of the learning process. I've suffered in my life from medical problems and have been hurt by people who I love, but I wouldn't trade those experiences for anything. I feel that they have made me a much wiser and stronger person. There are a lot of really wonderful experiences that come with the bad. I want to have children so they can experience both for themselves. If all experiences in the world were positive, then we would never have anything to compare the good times to.
1 person likes this
@Tambunan (28)
• Indonesia
28 Feb 10
I never gave a thought to having children of my own. I never thought I would get married either. I was so happy just being single, traveling the world, and contributing to it what I could as a single person. But then I fell in love, got married and now I'm 7 months pregnant with our first child. I have to admit, I wasn't to excited at first. I wasn't disappointed either, just a little scared that all the adventure had disappeared from my life forever. Now that it is almost time for my baby to arrive, I find myself excited. Why? Because of the love that I have for my husband. I am excited to see my husband in my son, to watch my little one to grow up to be as wonderful and influential in the world as the man I married. Yes, there will be difficult things in life, thats part of living in a decaying world with other deprived people. But when I look back on my life I am thankful for ALL the difficult things I have gone through; they have made me stronger. I would never wish for my child to sail through life with no trials. He would be a weak and worthless person with no human sympathy. Life is a joy. The bliss of a carefree childhood, the adventure of discovering new things, falling in love, and then creating a tiny helpless being who loves you unconditionally. For me, it's not about pro-creating for the purpose of replacing myself of perpetuating the family name or being taken care of in old age. It's simply for the joy, adventure and challenge of being such an intimate part of another human life. But if that's not how you feel, if you'd rather not have children, who can judge you? It's your life anyhow.
• United States
28 Feb 10
Congratulations on your baby. Trust me, when you hold that tiny little life in your arms for the first time, you will realize that you have someone that you love more than ever imaginable. You said that you the difficult things in you life made you stronger and that you would never wish your child will not have trials...thumbs up on that statement, I agree 100%.