No need of Dhoni for India for few months.. Give rest to him.

India
May 16, 2010 4:42pm CST
It proved that there is no need of Dhoni. Karthik is very Good Keeper than Dhoni. His batting too looks like he is playing responsibly. Where as Dhoni missing many catches and stumpings. His batting too looks like he is playing carroms or cricket. But, his captaincy is good. But, He is not putting his fielders in correct position. He just depending on Batsmen. I think Managemenr has to give 4 months rest for Dhoni. What do u think?
2 responses
@Gany15k (1674)
• India
17 May 10
Do you say Karthik is good in batting and as keeper than Dhoni...Do you really see cricket matches..Dhoni lost 2 tournaments and you guys pulling him down..Whether this is fair.If you want the batting to be in style then lot of players will not be in team.What is there if he plays like carrom..? Whether the runs coming or not is important.. I just wonder why you said like this..
• India
17 May 10
Good Comment. Keep up on ur opinion. Dont change it.
• India
19 May 10
I think manoz is correct, kartik is better in keepering as well as in batting technique also. But previously I was thinking that Dhoni is a better captain but after last 2 World T20 perormances, I can say that Dhoni is a good moneymaker rather then a captain. I a captain can't see that their players can't pay short balls and he is also not hhaving plans for it in full 1 year and still is promoting those players in playing 11 then I can say he is a ver-2 weak captain. He won so many series as captain because he is lucky, he has sachin, dravid like players in his team. But now in T20 format of game nobody is there and his favorite player Yuvi is not in form from last 6-8 months but still he is playing 11.Which shows he doesn't care about Winning the series.
• India
19 May 10
Hey, Thanks for supporting me yar. Who is ur favorite cric player?
• India
25 May 10
I don't really agree with you. karthik is an average keeper and if Dhoni is out of form as a keeper, he still is our best keeper. Karthik's batting is also a problem as he isn't a consistant player. The problem with Dhoni is that he only had one world class bowler in Harbhajan and one very good seamer in Zaheer Khan but they both aren't in the best of form so Dhoni had to rely heavily on the batsmen.