Gandhiji Has Made a Big Mistakes..?

@siliguri (4051)
India
July 7, 2010 2:07am CST
The root cause of chaos in kashmir i can say Gandhiji is responsible of it. At the time of Partition Between India and Pakistan after Independence on the basis on which Gandhiji Separate this two nation was very incorrect. Gandhiji told that who ever want to go pakistan can go but it is absolutely wrong verdict and we are facing the result of it. I think if that time gandhiji told that all muslims should go pakistan and hinduism stay in india might be a right decision and there might be no chaos as we are facing now.. This what i feel..Want to know..about your thinking..?
9 responses
@common_man (1799)
• India
7 Jul 10
Hi friend, Before commenting on historical events it is necessary to understand the event, the context in which it took place and try to understand logic behind the decision. If Hindustan had only hindus then we would also have become Hindu nation as Pakistan has become muslim nation as on date. The Basic idea of secular country would have been lost. The gameplan of British rulars at that time to divide nation of based of religion would have got success and we would have been in same dire stage as Pakistan is today!
1 person likes this
@siliguri (4051)
• India
7 Jul 10
I think the gameplan that british had will profitable to our nation.
• India
7 Jul 10
I don't know friend, what would have happened. Might be we might not have muslim terrorism in our country,But then in that case there might be some other issues.
@kukueye (1761)
• Malaysia
7 Jul 10
It sometime diifficult to judge person after so many years ago.YEsterday terrorists can be todays freedom fighter and vice versa. BEcause a person has to act during his time during his situation in that particular time. HArd to said if Gandjii did not ask 2 secular force to separate maybe there are more communal fighting going on and such.Certain events can be blamed on a particular individual as series of events can occur because of multitudes of factors.
@arunmails (3013)
• India
7 Jul 10
[b]This is something wrong mr.siliguri... if gandhiji says all Muslims should go to pakistan, then it will be treated him as another hitler... since this is a democratic country.. all people have own choice of choosing their residence... We are facing certain circumstances because of not accepting the truth behind the humanism... not because of the caste and religious feeling.... [/b]
@siliguri (4051)
• India
7 Jul 10
Jinnah did the same thing no body compare him with hitler..he treat like a god in pakistan and most of the country.
• India
7 Jul 10
Well Gandhiji was known as the Father of our Nation if you know well. And you know how hard it's tough to find people like him nowadays. No one wants peace now. I just believe that he was maybe born at the wrong time. During that time no one could protest against the Britishers who came and conquered India. Gandhiji's policies were simple to understand but hard to follow. Even today it's hard to live on the basic principles of truth. And i also heard that the advantage of truth is that you don't have to remember what you said. With that principle he did his best for the country. Now tell me do you follow his principles? I don't think so. He was simple and a plain ordinary man that's what made him really famous. Can you find any people like that nowadays?
• Pakistan
7 Jul 10
Gandhi ji was a democratic leader, he was not hitter i guess, as he killed all the jews, world is a global village , we cant live separately among all religions, partitions should be on the basis of Right of the people not on the basis of religions. Kashmiri's have right to live their own lives, i think kashmir should be released , as both countries are suffering only bcoz of that issue, it should be solved to normalize the relation
@siliguri (4051)
• India
7 Jul 10
I don’t understand why Pakistan always interrupt in Kashmir issue as it is not a part of their nation and do spread the nuisance in the area of kashmir as you also claim that india should released Kashmir from his country why we isolate Kashmir. We sacrifice a lot for this state many people have losses their relatives and still sacrificing and one think we(indian) like to mention that we would never never never never let go Kashmir from india till the last breath and it would better for Pakistan give attentiveness on the condition of their nation it will be beneficial rather than keeping their eye on Kashmir as always. !!!!!JAI HIND!!!!!
• India
7 Jul 10
I am 100% agree with you, Most problems faced by our country today are due to Gandhiji's biased and wrong policies.This farcical secularism family politics, controlling of media and abjection of Indian culture are all Gandhiji's brainchildren...I personally don't like the way he took decisions,thus I strongly admire and supports SARDAR VALLABH PATEL's political views and decisions...
@siliguri (4051)
• India
7 Jul 10
Thanks Friend for agree with my opinion Personally i like subhash chandra bose as human beings most and his firm view..
@venkit (2957)
• India
18 Jul 10
ya that should have been a good option. but there are some good patriotic indian muslims, your statement woud make themdissapointing. actually gandiji should not have accepted to partiton the india, thats what i feel.
@satz0249 (125)
• India
7 Jul 10
Yes me too feel the same Gandhiji must have ordered the muslims to go to pak and hindus stay in india .. so that india would be more peaceful country.. and could have avoided all this kashmir tragedies..
@SHAMRACK (8350)
• India
7 Jul 10
Dear friend, There are lots of mistake of great leaders. One of the most crucial mistake is that of adopting law and order that do suit the Indian culture. We were slaves of Britishers once but now we are still slaves of their law and order. Once Britishers used this law and order to exploite Indian, but now rules, law makers and law breakers are using the law and order to exploite the Indians who are unable to buy these laws. I hope India is named by Britishers the actual name of India is "Bharat" which is rarely used. If this goes I hope India will become just a cultureless nation with no values in family relations. Lots of people are getting divorced as in western culture which makes a lots of problems in Indian family values and next generations. Hope only god can save Bharat.
• India
7 Jul 10
The Line what you specified "All Muslims should go Pakisthan and Hinduism stay in India" that littile bit milted lines. Because Our country is mainly popoular about for our Culture & Humanity. At the same we have the ability to show the truth. Attitude in some muslims people cuses to devide the land. If there is no-word of Community differentiation then we are all be one family. The desicion what Gandiji have done is completely outbound. But i Supports UNITY. The political condition at the time we don't know but somewhere we have a feel of sad about the seperation.