How do you dispose your kid's excess stuff away without upsetting him/her?

@devijay78 (1573)
India
October 14, 2010 2:15am CST
The stuff my three year old daughter has is enough to fill a big room! She has a number of toys and keeps accumalating more and some of them are broken or tattered and torn, but she still does not allow me to throw them away or give them to some poor child. The whole house is filled with her things and now it is getting out of hand. I have boxes and boxes of her playthings which I have no place to store. If I store them in the attic, what is the point of getting her such toys? Most of them are gifts and some of them are bought. She clings on to all her things and I hesitate to dispose them without her knowledge because one fine day she comes to me asking for that exact toy which I thought of disposing. Phew! Such a close call! Any suggestions? Or do I have to put up with a houseful of toys both good as well as broken, just for my daughter's sake? My house is overflowing with them and I find it difficult to keep it clean.
3 people like this
12 responses
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
14 Oct 10
Very sneakily...I find that children accept what they can not change more readily then adults. I used to have sneak out of my house, whenever my cousin came to visit, because if he saw me leaving he would flip, but if I was just gone, he would accept it. As for toys, when we did that this summer with our three year old, we just told him we were having a yard sale, and he seemed to accept that, he snuck a few toys back out, and we just gently reaffirmed that that was a yard sale toy. We had a lot of toys that we had boxed up and had in the basement for a few months, so he seemed to have forgotten we had them. Sincerely and With Appreciation.
1 person likes this
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
I tried hiding her toys but felt bad about it when she started searching for them. I see her always in her room going through the boxes and bags to find one of her favourite toy to play with. The boxes are so big that I find half her body inside and can see only her butt and legs outside. Such a cute sight. I do have a lot of soft toys too in the attic. But she seems to yearn for them now and then which makes me feel guilty about hiding them there. Oh it is so hard being a parent! There is no yard sale kind of stuff in our place so all I can do is give them up for charity or my maid maybe? I just hope she forgets too
1 person likes this
@CJscott (4187)
• Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
15 Oct 10
I am sure you will find a solution, eventually. I wish you the best, and I understand what you mean by it can be hard to be a parent.
• United States
14 Oct 10
I would not sneak around to sort out the toys for my girls. I taught my girls if the toys were broken they were thrown away if they couldn't be fixed. My daughters believe me had alot of toys and stuff they collected. So in order to keep the house somewhat organized we would go through the toys together. I would ask how much to you actually play with this one, do you really need it. They would answer first yes it is played with and I want to keep it. I told them that if we can't sort out between what to keep and what to get rid of, then there wouldn't be any room for new ones. What we did was sort through toys and then sold them in a yard sale for others to be able to enjoy and play with. The money was used to help teach the girls what it cost to have those toys. They had to use the money they earned to purchase gifts for family or friends for birthdays and holidays. I would take them to the store and they would have to choose, after we would look at several of their ideas. They would also have to pay the cashier with their own money. As they got older they would actually sort out their own toys and stuff to put in the yard sale. Eventually they would use the money to purchase things they wanted as well as gifts for others. That was one way I would learn what they truly would like for themselves for my gift giving.
• United States
15 Oct 10
In other words she is having trouble with sharing. She needs to learn how to share before she is in school. You can involve her with this, saying there are children that don't have toys that if she gave some away to charity she would be making other children happy.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
I like the way you taught them to save and puchase gifts for others. I have not tried selling till now. Here it is normally not done that way, they are simply thrown away or mostly given to some one. Since she is too small, she yearns for her toys even if they are broken and does not allow other kids to even play wiith them. I will try to give it to charity though.
@yspmyl (3435)
• Malaysia
14 Oct 10
I probably having the same problem like you, my son is 3 year old, and having lots of toys in the store room. Almost everyday, he will make the whole store room's with all of his toys on the floor. And there are so many that broken and he still playing it. So what I did is I will tell him that if he not going to keep it every time after he played it, I am going to throw it away, so after telling him for many time, sometime he get frustrated and just ask me to throw it away, so I will just throw those broken and not playable toy away, when he ask me about the particular toy later, I will just tell him that he asked me to throw it away already.
@yspmyl (3435)
• Malaysia
14 Oct 10
Sometime you just have to bear with it for a while and children will forget about it in a very short period. And they will be happy again, no worry!
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
It is just that she gives a hurt look and sheds silent tears when she knows that I have thrown some of her broken toys away. And she never forgets nor does she let me forget about it And I go like "awwwwwwww shucks, I should not have done it!"
@CTHanum (8234)
• Malaysia
14 Oct 10
hi devi! i have the same problem with my sister's kids stuff. but i am a bit strict with them. this way may not suit with you. i just dispose them without they know about it. the day they come back they just realized that some of the toys are gone. and i am telling the truth to them and reasons why i did so. some of the toys need to be dispose as soon as possible.they can't even play with them anymore. luckily they can accept it. sometimes i will ask them to help me to dispose them as those toys can't be use any more.this way i will supervised while they will choose which one should be dispose or not.
@CTHanum (8234)
• Malaysia
15 Oct 10
haha...a very smart little girl! i think the cruel way is better for her.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
Hi CTHanum. I do have her with me when I clean and make her choose what toys she wants to retain and what she would like to dispose. But expecting a three year old to throw stuff is like banging my head against the wall. She just picks everything up and throws them inside her box or bag to be stored! And the things she does not want goes to her cousin who is one year old and who is taken care of by my parents from morning till evening. So it goes to my parents' place. Very sneaky, you know? She does that because she can play with those toys when she goes there. Smart of her, isn't it? I guess I should try disposing without her knowledge. Being a good mommy and making her choose is not working.
• United States
14 Oct 10
This is quite difficult sometimes, but what I found to be helpful in my home is that from time to time I expressed the need of other less fortunate children so I made a game out of it and we would go through certain things and I would express, now, now think about the little girl and or boy that would find you such a great wonderful person, as when they hold and play with these toys they will forever love you. Oh both my kids felt so important, even if some of the toys I had to discard as really they were broken. So we have to be very sneaky about how we go about it. As if they knew we were throwing them away they would be so hurt.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
That is a nice way of putting things. I have recieved a lot of suggestions from others too to donate the toys to charity or others with my daughter's knowledge. I guess I better try that. Hope it works with her.
• Philippines
15 Oct 10
Let her watch Toy Story 3. If she can already understand things, that movie will teach her how to let go of things that really matter to you most.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
31 Oct 10
I did make her watch. I doubt what she understood but then, something is better than nothing, right? Thanks for the suggestion.
@angelface23 (2494)
• United States
14 Oct 10
I would tell her that in order for her to get new toys she has to get rid of the new. Try telling her about a little girl who's parents may not be able to afford new toys would love to play with that doll she doesn't use anymore. Maybe teaching her about helping others through giving her old toys away will help her let go of them. I usually clean out my daughters toy box once a month when she is not at home. I just get rid of all the broken crayons and mcdonalds toys that she never plays with. Heck most of her good toys she doesn't even play with but I am saving for her little sister. You could also sell them on ebay but giving them to needy is better I think.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
Most of her toys are given to her cousin who is one year old. The same goes with the clothes too. But nowadays it is becoming very rare. She refuses to part with her things and heaven help me if she finds her cousin playing with one of her toys! All hell will break loose. I guess I will have to give them to some one else. I have not tried to sell. Maybe I would try that too.
@jugsjugs (12967)
9 Nov 10
In the past when i have wanted to get rid of a few of my childrens toys etc i have waited until they were at school or out for the day with my husband.Then what i have done is taken up a few black bags and started with clearing drawers and worked my way through their rooms.Every bag that i filled i took to my mums and then put the bags in her bins as well as the lady that lived next to her,that way the children never found them.As soon as there is a broken toy i see i bin that toy as soon as the childrens backs were turned.
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
14 Oct 10
Hello dev, I think you will have a hard time convincing a 3 year old kid. I was able to convinced my kids to give away their toys when they get older already,about 7 years old for my eldest. With my youngest,it was only recently that we were able to give away some of his stuffs. Maybe you can start throwing away some torn or useless toys by pieces without her knowledge. I don't think she knows each of her toys,in that mountain big like piles. Just try hiding some and observe if she will look or remember any,then if she won't asks for it...then you can dispose pieces by pieces just to have some space for new things or gifts to come.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
I would like to do that. It is that whenever she sees something on the street or a shop, she would immediately, on coming home, search for her toy which looked like the one on the street or shop. I have had many close calls that way. I dont mind getting her things but storing them and cleaning them is a pain. I can dispose the torn and broken ones I guess. There are some toys which inspite of being broken, are her favourites. So I might just have to keep them and dispose the others.
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
14 Oct 10
If i need tosort out my children's toys or clothing, i would it in a positive way. i would try to include them in the decision. i would tell them that are needy children in the world who could be helped with their donation,. This would make everyone feel good about the task.
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
Thanks both of you. I have not tried that. Seems like a good idea to me. Will try it.
@oldchem1 (8132)
14 Oct 10
Explain to your daughter that unless she gets rid of some of her older toys there will be no room in your house for any more, and stick to it! She'll soon change her mind
@devijay78 (1573)
• India
14 Oct 10
That is a good idea! I will try it this weekend. Thanks oldchem.
• India
14 Oct 10
I am also the same problem, everyday i have explain my daughter and change her mind. i will expect at the earliest she will change. thanking you.