Equal Gifts

United States
November 29, 2010 1:37pm CST
With Christmas approaching I just want to know what you do about gifts for family members and whether you try to make them all equal. I bought a lot of random items for my family and some people will be receiving more/more expensive gifts than others just because I happened to find good things for that person or I got a bargain on them. Is it fine to be "unfair" when giving gifts to siblings, parents, and nieces and nephews?
2 people like this
11 responses
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
29 Nov 10
we have two daughters and we always try to be fair in what we buy them and how much spend on them. they are older now but it still matters. as for our 4 nieces, we often buy them all the same thing, so its definitely fair that way.
• United States
29 Nov 10
Is it hard, though, to spend equal on your daughters? Is that equal as in equal retail value or equal in appearance? Thanks for your input!
• United States
29 Nov 10
Cher, buying the exact same thing for all four of your nieces is definitely fair in a way. However, do they all like the same things? The reason I ask is because someone that I know does that for their relatives, and while it seems fair on the surface, only one or two really like the gift and the others just have to deal with it and do not like or use their gifts. Unfortunately, it is always the same one or two that the gift is picked out for each year, which really is not fair to the others that have different tastes, in my opinion. Please do not misunderstand me and think that I am not trying to suggest that is the case with you, which is why I was asking. If they all like the same things, then that is wonderful and it would work perfectly. If they don't, though, then how do you decide what to get them that they all will like?
1 person likes this
• United States
29 Nov 10
purplalabaster that makes sense, too. Assuming Cher's nieces are children though, it should be pretty easy to buy something that they will all like - plus you never can really know if someone is going to like your gift or not even if you buy each person a gift specific to them. Thanks for the input!
@petersum (4522)
• United States
29 Nov 10
It's really hard to answer when my own experience of Christmas came down to socks and handkerchiefs! Neither of which were appreciated at all. Just buy the kids what they actually like!
• United States
29 Nov 10
I agree with buying them what they like and want - they are not going to know or care in the least how much money was spent on each of them, especially if they all get things that they really like and wanted.
• United States
29 Nov 10
Agreed and Agreed. Thanks for replying!
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
29 Nov 10
I believe that the main purpose behind a gift is the desire to give someone something they will like so the cost shouldn't matter. I have some grandchildren who are teenagers and they have expressed the desire for money so that they can pick out what fits their style at the mall. Since they live out of state I send them each a check and, in their case, each one is for the same amount. For everyone else, I buy what I think they'll like but I do make sure that all of the young ones get the same number of gifts...because someone having more than the other *will* cause an argument.
• United States
30 Nov 10
I definitely agree that when giving money you should give the same amount to people of "equal importance", haha. Thanks for the response!
@oXAquaXo (607)
• United States
30 Nov 10
FallingFan, I don't think it would be unfair if you think that the gifts that you got them would suit them well. People like different things, and some people may enjoy items that are naturally more expensive than others' favorites. I do the same for my family, and everyone ends up happy. My sister likes lotions and perfumes and makeup, so I got her a little basket of those items at Bath and Body works. My mom loves expensive brands, so I got her a set of perfume from Ralph Lauren. My dad is a very studious person, so I got him a book. My grandma and grandpa are from rural China, so they're very frugal. They hate it when I buy expensive gifts for them and they appreciate the simpler things in life. My grandma loves little notebooks and pencils, so I got her a set of mini notebooks and a good pen. My grandpa jogs often, so I got him and handheld electric fan. All of these items are really different and are priced differently, but each person loved their gift, and that's all that matters. Good luck! Annie
• United States
30 Nov 10
That all makes complete sense and I'm sure your family loves their gifts and is happy despite the fact that their gifts are "unequal". Thanks for sharing!
• United States
29 Nov 10
It is difficult to define "fair" and "equal", in my opinion. I mean, if I get them things that they really want, then isn't that "fair" and "equal", even if I don't spend the same amount of money on them? Similarly, if I spend a considerable amount more money on one gift for someone, so I choose to give another person two gifts that were less expensive, then I would still consider that "fair" and "equal". Overall, I do try to be somewhat "equal" when giving gifts, especially to members of the same family, because I don't want anyone to feel hurt or left out. Mostly, I just try to get them things that I know they will like, because I think that is the best way to show them that I care ... because I was thinking specifically about them when I bought the present.
• United States
29 Nov 10
I get what you are saying and I also try to get things that the recipient will like! :) Thanks for the input!
• Philippines
30 Nov 10
guess it's fine. like they say, it's the thought that counts.
• United States
30 Nov 10
True. Thanks for the response.
• United States
7 Dec 10
I don't always do equal gifts for everyone. I usually get my mom and her husband and his kids about 3 gifts each and I do the same for my dad and his wife. I buy whatever I want and find for my husband and I buy lots of stuff for our son. I also buy just whatever I find for my husband's side of the family too. So I don't really do equal gifts. I just buy what I think the people will like.
• United States
5 Dec 10
For our family, if we gift one, we get one back. If we can't gift, then we don't get anything back. This is good, especially with difficult economic times. I called my bro and sis and my il's and asked what they were planning on for holiday gifts so I would have time to make stuff for them. They don't have it in their finances to buy for my family (I have 6 kids) so that's fine. That way, no one feels like they are obligated to get something for someone else. It's always within personal budgets too. Someone can buy a more expensive gift, but they do it with the understanding that what they get in return may not be as expensive, or may even be homemade. We always give to our parents because our parents always give to us. And we always give to our kids. Everyone else is a big set of variables.
@eileenleyva (27562)
• Philippines
30 Nov 10
When giving gifts, it is the thought that counts, not the price. But of course I like my gift more if it sure looks expensive!JOKE!
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
30 Nov 10
I try to make my christmas gifts as equal as I can. I don't want anyone to feel slighted over a Christmas gift. Sometimes this make the shopping choices a bit difficult because I want to be fair to everyone I give a christmas gift to.
@joystick (1675)
30 Nov 10
I must say that i got a lot of things for people that are family as well as friends in a sale, thanks to a friend that knows where the sales are on certain sites and they have about the same spent on them.I try to get things that are worth getting as well as things that i know the people that i buy them for will use.