Are you going to watch even with new judges

United States
January 13, 2011 12:03pm CST
So im wondering how many of you out there in this mylot world are going to continue to watch American Idol with the New Judges. I will of course start off watching it and see how far i go with watching it with the new judges this year. I have watched every season and have liked them all and hopefully the show will be the same and we all will keep enjoying it as much as we have in the past.
2 people like this
21 responses
@garson (886)
• United States
31 Jan 11
Oh yes. You just have to see how good or bad it is going to be. G.
@lady1993 (15555)
• Philippines
29 Jan 11
I'm still watching it..As much as I love the judges Simon Cowell and Kara dio Guardi, I really love this show. I like t see reality shows, especially those that showcase talent. It's nice to see people fulfilling their dreams and knowing their stories..
@jambi462 (4598)
• United States
14 Jan 11
No I stopped watching American Idol a long time ago. I only watched it to see the really bad auditions because most of the so called talent on American Idol are just singing other people's songs. Then they are automatically famous if they win so they are pretty much guaranteed to get at least some record sales from people that don't take the time to sit down and find music that they actually like. And pretty much every winner of American Idol has a few hits and then fizzles out just like most pop stars do. I would have to say that's probably the biggest reason I don't like American Idol. They only showcase people that are talented on there if they are singing pop songs because they only want to find someone that they can make into a so called musician. They basically just hold a contest for a person with a nice image that they feel they can market to the mainstream genres of music. Maybe if American Idol actually judged on talent and on all kinds of it rather then just one genre I would tune in and watch
• Philippines
14 Jan 11
I have watched American Idol since it started and I never skip watching it; well at least the new judges are singers by themselves and maybe there will be a little flaw that will happen.
@lingli_78 (12852)
• Australia
14 Jan 11
i don't really like this kind of show... so i never really pay much attention to it... i had watched it before but not american idol... it is australian idol since i am living in australia... but i don't really like it... so i only watched it every now and then when i feel like it... take care and have a nice day...
@klarian (49)
• Philippines
14 Jan 11
i am still going to watch american idol because i am more eager to see new american talents. of course, a.i. will never be the same without simon cowell and the rest of the past judges. nevertheless, i am happy with the new set of judges. i can't wait for the 10th season premiere.
14 Jan 11
I might not continue watching American idol since the old judges were replaced, I hope that the show will still be the same as the one in those past years. I kinda miss the old judges by the way....
• United States
14 Jan 11
No! It's getting boring anyway!!
@jamed28 (1910)
• Philippines
14 Jan 11
Yes I'll definitely watch it. I heard that Stephen Tyler, J.Lo will are the new hosts and I do believe they deserve to be judges. They are proven excellent music artist so why not give them the sits.
@reckon21 (3487)
• Philippines
14 Jan 11
I really don't mind if there is new judge in the American idol show. I am still going to watch it come what may. I am more interested with the talented and smart challenger of the show. I want to watch them sing and show their talents to the world and that all that matters to me. Judges I am okay with anybody as long they will do their job fairly and don't insult much of the poor participants who are just trying their best to win. I just want a fair and honest judge, anybody is fine with me.
@salonga (27965)
• Philippines
14 Jan 11
I think it is still worth watching. Let's see how the new set of judges will fare. But I will miss Simon. I am curious how the old judges were voted out? I really did not know that judges here are subject to elimination.
@kel1483 (986)
• United States
13 Jan 11
I think the fact that they changed the time/days it's on will effect me watching it more than the judges. If something else I really like is on the same time as American Idol, I will choose the other show. It will be a shock having only one familiar judge on the pannel, but overall that won't bother me I don't think (though I will miss Simon's comments). They have made some changes to the way the show works as well & so those might also contribute to whether or not I will watch.
@sender621 (14956)
• United States
13 Jan 11
I would still like to watch American Idol. It won't be the same without the judges we have come to know and love. then again, these judges may surprise us and give us something new to cheer for.
• Philippines
13 Jan 11
Hi! Yes , definitely i'll watch season 10 of American Idol. Changes happens for a reason in every way for the better. I think many will judge the new judges because fans long for the old style of the program. I think we all need to see & watch the program & just enjoy & relax to take part of it. Let's all wish them good luck.
@asyria51 (2870)
• United States
13 Jan 11
I stopped watching american Idol several years ago. There just seemed to be too much negativity, and drama for it to be fun anymore. I know that several of my friends are continuing to watch even with the new judges.
@nijolechu (1845)
• Canada
13 Jan 11
The whole show hasn't really changed. It is really just the judges. Its like the show has a complete overhaul with new judges. I think I will give it a try. If I don't like the show then I will discontinue watching it all together. I think I will miss Simon Cowell the most because I like his brutal honesty towards the bad singers. lol.
@carolscash (9503)
• United States
13 Jan 11
I will start out watching it as I have watched every season, but I am not sure that it is going to be as good with the judges that they have now. I think that it will be better to not have four judges, but I also think that it will be a lot different without Simon on there. He seemed to be the one who was always offering the most of the critism and some of the singers need that. i am glad that Randy Jackson is still there as I really like him.
@petersum (4526)
• United States
13 Jan 11
Are the new judges going to make it cheaper? Then all the crap TV stations around the world that can't make their own programming will buy it. God help us!
13 Jan 11
I'm going to watch, simply because it's what most people talk about in pop culture so it gives me something to contribute to the discussion. I never actually cared too much what the judges have to say. I know the music I like and what the judges opinion was didn't change that for me. So I guess I iwll still watch, unless all the singers stink, then I will stop watching.
@katsmeow1213 (28925)
• United States
13 Jan 11
I didn't watch it with the old judges, so I won't be watching it with new judges. The only time I've ever watched it was some of the auditions because they can be funny, but that's only when I really had nothing better to do. These days I'm too busy to watch much TV.