Which Pie is Better Sweet Potato or Pumkin?

Sweet Potato Pie - Sweet potato pie
@wmg2006 (5381)
United States
November 18, 2006 10:04pm CST
I have been in a discussion about these 2 pies for days. Some say they are the same, but I say they are not! They may be prepared the same way but they taste very different to me. I like sweet potato much more than pumkin. Pumkin has a spice in it that my taste buds do not like. Which one do you like the most?
2 people like this
13 responses
leopardxtasy
@leopardxtasy (2426)
• United States
20 Nov 06
sweet potato
1 person likes this
wmg2006
@wmg2006 (5381)
• United States
23 Nov 06
I agree, thank you for responding. You get an a+ because you responded and because you agreed with me. LOL
lsen06
@lsen06 (4998)
• India
20 Nov 06
sweet potato
1 person likes this
wmg2006
@wmg2006 (5381)
• United States
21 Nov 06
Thank you You just got an a+
Undefeated
@Undefeated (4788)
• Singapore
21 Nov 06
Pumpkin pie i think.
1 person likes this
blueman
@blueman (16509)
• India
21 Nov 06
i think sweet potato.
1 person likes this
thatcrazyqbanita
@thatcrazyqbanita (3312)
• United States
21 Nov 06
Sweet Potato pie
1 person likes this
mellbrb
@mellbrb (250)
• United States
20 Nov 06
I like them both. But I'd rather have the Pumpkin pie. I make mine from scratch. So I leave out the spices I dont like ~*~ Happy Holidays ~*~
1 person likes this
wmg2006
@wmg2006 (5381)
• United States
21 Nov 06
Yeah that is a good idea, maybe I could make one and leave the spices out I don't like.
TerryZ
@TerryZ (22076)
• United States
13 Feb 07
There is a big difference in the two of them. I hate sweet potatos and I wont eat it. And I love pumpkin pie that is one of my favorite pies. So yes there is a big difference.
lucy02
@lucy02 (5016)
• United States
13 Feb 07
I prefer sweet potato pie too. It seems like it is a little sweeter than pumpkin pie too.
sweetgirl_k1
@sweetgirl_k1 (3972)
• United States
12 Feb 07
I like both of them. But if I could only pick one then I would say sweet potato pie. It just tastes more fluffier than pumpkin pie if you know what I mean. I do know what you mean about the spices in pumpkin pies too. If you don't have the taste buds for those spices then it will make you not like it.
spiritwolf52
@spiritwolf52 (2300)
•
12 Feb 07
I like pumpkin pie. I really don't like sweet potatoes. There is a big difference in taste between the two. I wouldn't think they have the same spices in them. Pumpkin pie with 2 scoops of vanilla ice cream. If it wasn't so late I would go and bake one now!
zeloguy
@zeloguy (4911)
• United States
13 Feb 07
I actually like the spice that the pumkin pie has to it and if you add whipped cream to the top there is nothing better. Sweet potato pie has a little more of a substance texture to me... a little thicker. Still a great choice. I love both of them but if it comes down to it, it's pumpkin for me.
hmbw_24
@hmbw_24 (404)
• United States
12 Feb 07
girl you are making me hungry today!!! my personal favorite is pumpkin with whip cream on top. a while ago i got one frozen from the store with cheescake swirl in it, it was delicious! and a little different from the norm. that settles it im gettin one for desert tonight!
Ruralchook
@Ruralchook (538)
• Australia
13 Feb 07
I'll eat pumpkin anyway its cooked, but sweet potato has to be roasted or mashed in with potatoes as I find it too rich in flavour.