Do You Help People When You Are Hurting Yourself?

United States
March 23, 2011 2:55pm CST
The most recent big deal that we are asked to donate for it the Japan crisis. Before that their was Katrina, and Haiti, and on a small scale note a woman I knew whose son had leukemia. So each of these times I've had people coming to me and asking me to donate to others in need and it's hard for me to say no, but I have to. Even donating a bottle of shampoo is hard for me because I need shampoo myself and I'm very poor. People give you dirty looks and snide comments for not donating because at least I have a roof over my head and I'm hooked up the net so what am I hurting for? But the thing is that I'm barely staying afloat here and all I really can do is let my thoughts and my heart go out to these people. I'm sorry for the pain they are going through, but I'm not personally in a position to help them.
2 people like this
8 responses
@jennyze (7029)
• Indonesia
24 Mar 11
Yes, sometimes people expect too much of us, when in fact we work hard to still have a roof to stay. I tried to give as much as I can let go, still people sneered and talked. So I stopped giving them. If I have sufficient money, I would send them to certain associations or orphanages.
1 person likes this
• United States
24 Mar 11
I agree. We should have the right to choose who we help and the others that we can't help we should just let our heart go out to them. I hope so much that the people in Japan are able to get back up on their feet soon. It breaks my heart that they are going through this pain even though I can't personally help them.
@jennyze (7029)
• Indonesia
25 Mar 11
Yes, I often think to help them, but I have neither money to spare or any resources. I hope our prayers will keep them motivated and move on.
@thanks1961 (7035)
• India
24 Mar 11
Hi dear, You are rightly said. We know and are cooperating with the situations around. Whatever happened is absolutely unfortunate and we feel sorry for such incidents happens. The simple way is that whatever we can, we will do. But there are situations where we are unable to help in such emergency times. As you said, we are really trying to coop with our problems, an extended help may really painful. Last week one girl come to my door and were asking for a donation to the cancer patients. We had a discussion of about 15 mts. and she wanted to discharge a minimum amount for the sake. She showed me a lots of cheques and other receipts people have already supported. However, I was not in a position to give any amount to here as I was totally out of cash with me and I was not in a position to get a help from anyone else as I have already took money from several people. Even if we have the intention to help or willing to donate, our specific situation may not allow for it. Anyway, all those who have enough and more than enough money, they will give and I am sure that if we don’t have money with us, it is not a compulsory matter to help. We only know how we are surviving. Thank-s
1 person likes this
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
23 Mar 11
I am very choosy who I do help these days as far as collections are concerned as a lot of charities hire people to collect, this I don't agree with, which means the actual charity is only getting a very small percentage of what you are giving, I will help anyone who needs it on to one especially my friends and people I know, it is very hard when you yourself is on limited funds you can't help everyone so you have to do it in the best way you can.
• United States
24 Mar 11
I hadn't even thought about the hiring of people for charity collections. That kind of makes things scary. You don't know who your money is going to. I would really like to help single mom's though. I've been in those shoes and I know how rough it is. I was thinking about every year buying a diaper back and filling it with things that a new mom would need and dropping it off at the local pregnancy help center. It's just one bag a year... but to one mom it could be a lot of help. Plus, the way I am I wouldn't have to pay for half the stuff that would go into that bag. There are baby freebies too!
@cmang83 (285)
• Malaysia
24 Mar 11
I think it's okey to not involve in donation if yourself is in difficulty. I didn't donate to Haiti and New Zealand earthquake victim but i did donate to Japan crisis. It is because i have some financial problem last year and my condition is better this year. Of course, when people ask me for donation, i won't tell them that i am not going to donate because i got no money. I just told them i had made my donation through some organization and bla bla bla =p.
• United States
24 Mar 11
Lol, although I don't normally condone lying that is actually not too bad of an idea. Because really some of these people get rough with you trying to get money from you and it becomes really hard to shake them if you don't have the means to. And you feel bad for the people... but if you can't help, you can't help.
• United States
23 Mar 11
I have often helped people in my life but not before I can help myself. I cannot allow myself to be put in a situation and still help others. I am willing to share what little I have but not be completely without.
• United States
24 Mar 11
Yes, and I often have to think, do these people realize that what they are asking of me could make me just as bad off as the people I'm supposed to be helping? I just got out of a homeless shelter less than a month ago. I'm still trying to get on my feet... if I helped out even a little at this point in time I could end up back in a shelter. And that was no fun!
@Janexiao (173)
• China
24 Mar 11
Helping others is good thing, but i think it's based on your own financial station, if you are very poor,you even have a problem with living, there is no need to donate anything,maybe you can make a good wish for them. And don't feel shame,other people will understand you.
• United States
24 Mar 11
I think that the currency of love can be a powerful thing. And my heart does go out to those people that have lost so much in all the tragedies that have been taking place lately.
• United States
23 Mar 11
I can't always help and I am in the same situation I have a phone and internet, and although i don't 'need' them they do make my life a lot easier. I do a lot of volunteering though, so if someone made a snide comment about me not donating, I would just tell them, I do what I can do. If you can't help from your pocket book, then help with your hands. I have raised money for many different organizations through car washes and performances and I've made a lot of awesome friends that way. Just do what you can, and ignore the snickering, who are they to judge, they don't know you.
• United States
24 Mar 11
That is a good idea to volunteer your hands. I hadn't really thought of that one before. Although when the social worker at school had to have heart surgery my boyfriend and I made her a giant card and had every one at school sign it for her. It wasn't something helping a lot of people, but it was something helping one person that made a huge difference in our lives.
• United States
23 Mar 11
I will often help people even if I'm hurting myself because knowing that I've helped someone else in turn makes me feel better. Knowing that I've made someone's day always makes me feel better.
• United States
24 Mar 11
That is nice that it does make you feel better. I have tended to get jaded over the years because when I do try to help people it ends up backfiring on me. But, I do try to be a moral support even if I can't help with solid things in life.