Relationship dilemma

United States
May 25, 2011 11:46am CST
I am in a commited relationship right now with a man that I have been with for over 16 years, but my heart yearns for someone else. I am still close to the other person but he is currently with someone else. He has told me in the past that when he broke up with me before it was the single dumbest thing that he ever done, but that we are too old to start over again. I would give everything up for him as I know that he is my true soulmate. I love the man I am with and we do get along,but we also have several issues between us. I know that he cares for me, but I am not sure that he loves me the way that he should. I know that I do not love him with my whole heart. What do you all think? Should I stay where I am and have a close relationship and be taken care of well or should I try to revive an old flame that I know is still somewhat burning.
1 person likes this
13 responses
@tlb0822 (1410)
• United States
25 May 11
I think that we have one life to live, and that you should live it to the fullest. Whether it be doing things, loving, building relationships, you name it. So I think you should pursue this old flame that is still burning. Just think clearly about this decision becuase the relationship you are in now will not be there to go back to if this pursuit doesn't work out. So just follow what your heart is telling you, thats all you can do.
• United States
25 May 11
That is probably why I am still here. I hate to leave someone who I know cares about me and this other one not work out.
• United States
31 May 11
fairytale, you are right in so many of your points. My current partner will not do any of the little things you mentioned. He seems to want everything his way and we do not discuss anything unless it is something that I want to do and then we don't discuss it- I mention it and he gives me an answer. He spends money on anything he wants and if I need gas money, I am wasting our money. It is a difficult relationship and I am getting really tired of the work that I put into it. He hasn't held a job in over 10 years, although he has done some odd jobs and yet, I am told each time that I mention money to get a job. I hurt my arm at work 2 years ago and had to quit the job I was at.
• Philippines
26 May 11
indeed tlb0822, we have one life to live and we have to live at our best.. but we have to be very careful with our decisions specially if our happiness is at stake, i believe that it is really difficult for you carolcash to let go of the man whom you've known for quite so long, and i bet 16 years would help us be more mature in dealing with relationships.. don't hesitate to really find your happiness but remember to consider all pros and cons and if you decide to really break up with your current partner, i suggest that you should part in a good way, he deserve to have an explanation.. but real love is not a matter of feelings only, love has it's many forms, and if you and your current partner don't have that serious gap, i bet there is also a chance to rekindle the fire you once have with him, even though i do not for sure what is happening with the both of you, but there is a possibility that because of the long years you have been together, there are things that seemed to be neglected, these may sometimes belittle things but there is a great impact on the relationship specially when taken for granted.. little things like, giving of gifts,flowers and chocolate,appreciating the food that was cook,and so on and so forth.. i hope you don't get me wrong for mentioning this things, what i want to stress out is good communication helps in nurturing a relationship.. just as the song, "live like were dying" said, we should love deeper,speak sweeter for life is too short to waste on things we don't deserve, we should live everyday as if we are dying, so everyday we'll give our best shot! i wish you all the happiness in the world..
@momof3kids (1894)
• Singapore
26 May 11
I think you owe it to the person whom you are with now to ask him what the future of your relationship will be. To me a marriage seals it all. A marriage to me is the one that will protect you should you think of having children and it protects you should your partner leaves you. If he is unwilling to commit in a marriage then i think you should move on and pursue your old flame.
• United States
31 May 11
Mom, I am married to the man and we have children together. The old flame is not in a relationship that involves children. He has children with his ex wife and she has told me several times that they could not stay married because he still carried feelings for me.
• Singapore
26 May 11
Oops I forgot that your old flame has a relationship going on also. This complicates things even more. I think if he has children already with his current relationship then you should forget about him and focus on strenghtening your relationship with your current partner. Like someone here has said, the grass is always greener...
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
25 May 11
Past loves always seem perfect. We only remember the good stuff. There had to be a reason you broke up, right? Generally when we long for a love of the past, we are just tired of the work a relationship in the present is presenting. Work on what you have instead of pining away for something that never really was.
• United States
25 May 11
Actually, the only reason we split up was due to some real issues he was having with things that he had seen in Iraq and having doubts about his sanity. He was extremely ill for awhile from things that happened there to him. Now, he is much better and there weren't problems with us.
@rocketj1 (6955)
• United States
26 May 11
You are with someone else and he is with someone else. This is only heartache waiting to happen. Good luck.....
@piya84 (2581)
• India
26 May 11
If i have glass %50 percent full then i am going to trade it for anything which is more than it and sure shot.This logic applied to human relationships as well. Although he is your soul mate if he has stable relationship with his wife and if there are kids in equation then he is going to think twice before leaving life he has.If he is ready to leave everything behind for you i would say go for it.
• United States
31 May 11
He is not married, but he does have a new girlfriend. However, I am not sure that he would think twice about leaving her if I would say that I am leaving the relationship that i am in.
• Philippines
26 May 11
No one can predict what's going to happen in the future so I guess you just go with your heart. One friend of mine can relate a bit to your situation. She said she doesn't feel the spark in their relationship anymore and there are some other things that push her to say goodbye to him. However, she's afraid to let him go cos she know he takes care of her so much and she's afraid what's going to happen to her. Go with what your heart is telling you. That's what I told to my friend. Good luck and please keep us posted. See you around!
• United States
31 May 11
I can totally related to your friends' feelings. I will follow my heart.
@lajonez (477)
• Poland
25 May 11
I think you should go for your soulmate, because that Love is happening only once per life, you can also love other man but it will be never as it could be with the one, and it's never too late for love!
• United States
25 May 11
I agree with you on this and I am thinking about trying to make this happen.
@lajonez (477)
• Poland
26 May 11
You're feeling he's the one then you really should try because later you can regret it till end of your life, avarage love is great, but not all people can have that amazing heart stopping love and if it happend to you don't waste it!
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
25 May 11
That is a very tough decision to make. Only you know what will make you happy in life. Only you know if the relationship you are in now, will ever get any better. The decision is yours.
• United States
31 May 11
The relationship that I am in will never change. He is not willing to make any changes. He is an only child and like his mom in that things have to be done his way!
• United States
26 May 11
If you have feelings for someone else when you are in a relationship then you should end the relationship you are in because you are never going to be able to devote your all to the person you are with if you are forever yearning for someone else. And seeing as though you have also stated that you would give up everything for this other person you should let your boyfriend know how you feel because it is not fair to him to be giving his whole heart when you are only giving a piece of yours. If the shoe were on the other foot would you want to be with someone if you knew that he wanted to be with someone else? I think not. Also it is never too late to start something over and if the other guy feels the same way then you should also figure things out between the two of you as well.
• United States
31 May 11
My husband knows that things are not good now and he knows that I care deeply for the other man. My husband may be giving his all, but he won't compromise on anything and my thoughts and concerns are not considered in our relationship.
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
25 May 11
Could this just be your issues with your current relationship, projecting itself towards your 'soul mate'? I know that the grass always looks greener on the other side, and relationship matters seem more interesting when the tag 'soul-' is attached, but maybe you just need a re-spark with your current one. Just maybe?
• United States
25 May 11
This issue has always been an issue with my current relationship. Even when things are good between us, I still know that I do not love him as much as the other person.
@eyeabs30 (48)
• Philippines
25 May 11
I think you should go on try to rebuild your relationship with you had with your soulmate. As we all say one tru love come once in lifetime. You onlya have one life so better not to miss one great love. consequences may come to your way just have courage and faith in everything you do and everything will follow. Goodluck to you!
• United States
31 May 11
I feel that the love we shared was one that only comes once a lifetime.
@toniganzon (72285)
• Philippines
26 May 11
You alone knows what the right thing to do is. You said so yourself that you are still in love with that person, but then i have this doubt at the back of my mind if that person that you love is willing to give up his current relationship. You mentioned that he said you're too old to start over again. That statement made me doubt whether he's just saying that he still loves you because you already belong to someone else. If you stay with your current love however, you would be unfair to him as you're in love with somebody else. Yes you love him and that's because you've been together for more than 16 years. There's a big difference between being in love and love. Follow where your happiness will lead you and i hope you will choose the right one. God bless.
• United States
31 May 11
You are so right. I know that I love the man I am with, but I am just not in love with him.
• Malaysia
26 May 11
hurm.....love is subjectives.... each people will have different perspective about love....person A may fall in love if the partner spend a lot for her... Person be may fall in love when that person willing to do anything for her sake....person C may fall in love to the 'most hot guy'..... why do you love him??? whats make you love him??? Is the person you love can give happiness to you?? sometimes, the person we love is not the person meant to bring happiness to us... Short term happiness YES.....how about long term happiness???? are sure he can offer that....
• United States
31 May 11
I know that I can have a long term happiness with the former love. I truly believe that he is the one that I should be with. He has remained a constant in my life even when we were both married. He has never considered interferring in my marriage, but I believe that we would be together if I was not married.
• Philippines
26 May 11
the best relationship you can have is a relationship with yourself... First establish this kind of relationship with yourself. Then decided to whom do you want to share this loving relationship you have within yourself. You are best answer to your question, follow your heart as many have said, but you can only follow your heart when you know how to listen to it...so start a relationship with yourself, open your heart and listen to what it yearns to lovingly tell you...and then for sure true love will begin to bloom in your life....
• United States
31 May 11
I am confident in myself although my husband says I never do anything right.