Are your floors more important than your house guests?

@mindym (978)
United States
July 8, 2011 1:18pm CST
If you have guests over, do you have them take their shoes off at the door? Once I heard someone say that if you have your guests take their shoes off, your clean floors are more important than your guests. I think that is a great way to put it. When I enter someone's house, I either take my shoes off by my choice or I will ask if they would like me to take my shoes off. A majority of the time, the answer is No, you don't have to take your shoes off. When I am at home, I automatically take my shoes off at the door, but that's because I don't like to have anything on my feet, especially after a long day's work. But if I have guests over, it is so important and meaningful to me that they are there as my guests, so if my floors get dirty because of shoes (or any other reason), I will not let it ruin the time I have with them and I will clean them sometime after the guests leave. Do you have your guests take their shoes off at the door?
2 people like this
19 responses
@megamatt (14292)
• United States
23 Jul 11
A lot of the people who come over to my house on a regular basis are pretty good at removing their shoes without prompting. However if they are not going to do it and if they are not that dirty, it is really not all that much of a concern. However nine times out of ten, there are going to be a lot of people who come by these parts who take off the shoes at the door. Its not a big deal, unless they are caked with mud or snow, which I think its fair to state that it should be common sense to remove them. But I'm not about to twist anyone's arm. Its a matter of choice.
@mindym (978)
• United States
25 Jul 11
I want to believe that people would have enough common sense to take their shoes off without being asked if their shoes are REALLY gross. But for guests in my home, it is about choice and comfort. I will also not twist anyone's arm to take their shoes off. Twisting someone's arm to do something they don't want to is not a welcoming gesture. Thanks for sharing!
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
12 Jul 11
Now, I will admit that the majority of the people that I know never wear anything on their feet when they are in their homes. However, I've only been in people's houses a couple of times that will require that you remove your shoes when you enter the home. Both of these families were Japanese families and I understand it because it is a part of their culture. However, they also did have slippers that guests could wear at their house if they didn't like to have bare feet. As for my house, I normally have bare feet in the house, but I am not going to require my guests to remove their shoes.
@mindym (978)
• United States
25 Jul 11
Culture is definitely something to consider when asking a question like this. I like to learn about others' cultures and how they are different or the same to mine. I learned something new from this question about how Japanese families have and use slippers, and even provide them for their guests. Thanks for responding!
@JenInTN (27514)
• United States
9 Jul 11
I don't worry about the floors over the guests either. I think that would make a guest a little uncomfortable to have to take their shoes off when they visit. It would me. I would do it out of respect..but I would feel like I was intruding I think. Now if it was a white carpet or something like that..oh yes..they wouldn't even have to ask.
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
Yes, if it was brand new white carpet, I might go against my word and ask them politely to take their shoes off. But I am pretty sure they would understand my reasoning behind the request. Thanks for sharing!
@bird123 (10632)
• United States
10 Jul 11
You are so right about this one. I know people that their carpet must be the most valuable thing in their life. What ever happen to make yourself at home??? I'm like you. I take my shoes off at home because after a long day in shoes, barefoot is so much better. Guests are guests. If we place too many restrictions on them, why would they ever want to be guests again??
@mindym (978)
• United States
25 Jul 11
I want my guests to feel like my house is their house and to be able to make themselves at home. If they feel more comfortable taking their shoes off, great. If not, that's fine too. I want them to feel welcome and not restricted on what they can do in my home. Thank you for your response!
@asyria51 (2861)
• United States
9 Jul 11
If it is horribly slushy or rainy, I do ask that they take their shoes off, mostly because all the water makes the hardwood floors slippery and therefore slightly dangerous. The rest of the time i do not care. They are easy to clean, and we are vacuuming and swiffering almost every day to combat the dog hair. I personally like being barefoot, i tend to walk upstairs in my own house and take my shoes off up there and get changed if i am coming home from work.
@mindym (978)
• United States
25 Jul 11
Although I am all about my guests being comfortable in my home, I am also all about their safety. You are right in that when it is slushy or rainy, hardwood floors might get a little slippery. Dog hair could also make the floors just as slippery as water, so combatting the dog hair proably makes it a priority to keep your floors clean. Thanks for sharing!
@sjvg1976 (41131)
• Delhi, India
9 Jul 11
Hello mindym, for me shoes are not that important i think the guests are more important its up to them if they take off their shoes while entering or not but i think most of the people understand it does it even i do it when i go to someone's house.
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
I think the same thing, if my guests want to take their shoes off or not...if my guests are comfortable, I am happy.
• Canada
8 Jul 11
Anyone who comes in my house just takes off their shoes on their own... it's sort of a polite gesture here. You never have to ask them to do it unless they really are clueless or not very polite. I always take my shoes off when i go in someone else's house, so I kinda expect anyone who comes in my house to do it. Even so, i don't think my floor is more important than guests. You can always clean it up, right?
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
You got it, Pumpkin! And I do agree that it is a polite gesture and I would hope even someone who is clueless would understand if someone wanted them to take their shoes off. Thanks for your response!
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
8 Jul 11
hello mindym, I asks my guests to take off their shoes because my living room has rugs on it. I guess they won't mind it at all (i just hope so) at least i asks them politely. Same when i go to other's house,I always took off my shoes without them asking me to take it off. have a good day
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
I respect when others want me to take my shoes off at the door. It's not an inconvenience since my pairs of shoes are easy to take on and off. But it might be more of an inconvenience if I had on military boots or something Thanks for sharing.
• United States
8 Jul 11
Yes I have heard people who do this and have visited some homes where we are specifically told to remove shoes. If I am not asked where ever I go that is the first thing too that I do is ask, should I remove them. At my home I do not require and or request anyone do this as I am as you that I, if anything is on the floor later I will clean up. I would be scared to ask anyone to remove theirs and actually I have been asked if they should remove them and I always say no. Some will anyways. I wear slippers all the time at home and the only time I had anyone remove their shoes would be the kids and it was a rule. Simply because they lived at home and would track in loads of mud.
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
Not only will kids track in mud, but they most likely will not clean it up, unless they are asked to. I think asking is a respectful thing to, and even if someone says that you don't have to take your shoes off, the gesture was there. I also say no, but if they want to take off their shoes, they can because I want my guests to be comfortable in my home. The second I walk in the door, my shoes come off and if I have socks on, those come off as well. I don't like anything on my feet, even in the winter. Thank you for your thoughts, hwg!
@tink91879 (742)
• United States
9 Jul 11
Its not that my floors are more important than my guest its that shoes walk everywhere. Floors can be cleaned, but carpets are harder. I prefer my guest to remove their shoes. what if they stepped in something and didnt know it and now its tracked on my floor or carpets? I have two kids and two dogs enough stuf gets tracked in. I find it more respectful when the guest remove their shoes or ask. I want ppl to be comfortable in my house and I feel having shoes on dosent really allow you to do so. I take my shoes off when going into someones home. I mainly started this after my daughter was born. My kids play on the floor and your shoes have more than dirt on them that you can see. Call me crazy, I just want to help to keep my family healthy and house clean.
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
You're not crazy. I understand what you are saying. I respect what others want and it has been interesting to read the responses to this discussion. When I worked in an infant room at one time, the teacher had everyone take their shoes off and either put on slippers or keep their socks on so they did not track in anything since the infants are on the floor and will most likely put their hands in their mouths after touching the floor.
• Philippines
9 Jul 11
In my house, we don't mind people coming in and walking in the living room or kitchen or anywhere with their shoes on, as long as it is downstairs. But upstairs, each and everyone will have to go barefoot. No shoes or slippers. We just prefer it that way because we do not like dirt and trash getting in our bedrooms. The same rule goes for eating. All eating can be done in the dining area and anywhere downstairs. But not upstairs and more particularly in the bedrooms. This is so because we don't want any crumbs or food particles left in our sleeping areas. I think the guests do not mind this. For one, they respect the rules of the owners of the house. Plus, leaving your footwear outside the house can also be a cultural thing. It continues to be practiced in such highly-industrialized countries like Japan. It is part of their culture. To them, stepping inside someone's home with their shoes on is a sign of disrespect. I traveled there as an exchange student. And when I went on a tour in one of the prestigious and private schools there, I was also made to take off my shoes before entering the school premises, and instead, put on special slippers.
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
I absolutely agree that one should respect the rules of someone else's house. If they don't, they don't deserve to be there in the first place. Culture is definitely something one has to consider for many different circumstances, including removal of shoes. Your upstairs must be spotless, but I think it is good to set boundaries to be followed. Thank you for sharing!
@waflay (2737)
• Nairobi, Kenya
8 Jul 11
Sometimes my floor speak for itself.., and I don't lead as an example by being the first one to remove my shoes- common sense matters here. If they remove their shoes before they enter in my house, its well and good... if they don't then its fine with me, infact I won'f force them or even utter a word about shoes or floor in our general conversation...
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
That would be kind of tacky to interrupt a conversation to say, "...oh, and by the way, will you take off your shoes?" You must want your guests to be comfortable in your home, just like I do. So, if they want to take off their shoes, great. If not, even better. Thanks for responding!
• United States
8 Jul 11
I would prefer it if people took off their shoes. I hate having to to vacuum up the crap they drag in. That's just me though. I hope to have a house with wooden or tiled floors in the future so I can alleviate that problem. I never take off my shoes if the people have wood or tile, but if it's carpet, I'll usually ask. A great way to tell if they're okay with it or not is if they're wearing shoes :P
@mindym (978)
• United States
14 Jul 11
I miss my wooden floors that I had in my old apartment. Not only were they beautiful, but they did not show much dirt. Recently, I went over to this family's house that I will be house/cat sitting for when they are on vacation. Their house is BEAUTIFUL and when I walked in the door, I noticed the Mom had on flip flops and I knew what her answer was going to be, but out of respect and habit, I still asked if I should take my shoes off. Of course, the answer was no. But I agree that looking at their feet is a great way to know what they will answer if you ask.
@febrigas (362)
• Indonesia
9 Jul 11
I think this is related to the culture of the country concerned. In my country, usually someone will remove the footwear continues to be used when visiting, it would seem impolite. Because it will polite the house that we visit. Hoe ever, if the homeowner permit, then it's okay if we still wear shoes. Happy MyLotting to All! :D
@leeloo (1492)
• Portugal
8 Jul 11
It is not a common habit where I live for people to ask or take off their shoes when entering someone else's home. My family and I have slippers that we use at home but it mostly for comfort, most of my friends and family are the same. Taking off of shoes, unless they are very muddy or wet as happens in winter - I have some spare slippers for when friends come over so they can dry their feet, is very uncommon. It could be that having tiled instead of hardwood floors, and having mats instead of carpets, makes cleaning easier. Though I used to have wall to wall carpeting in the whole house, in the winter months I placed a runner mat to prevent humidity from soaking in to the carpets, all the people that came over never took their shoes off if they did not want to.
@janey72 (41)
9 Jul 11
We don't wear shoes in the house and we ask our guests to take their shoes off as well.it was something i grew up with. We all take our shoes off in the entrance hall and change into slippers. Not only is it cleaner, especially when there are kids playing on the carpets it also much comfier. Regular visitors haveva pair a slippers here that they can wear when they visit. We do always try and warn people in advance that we are a shoes house so they can bring slippers or thicks socks with them if they choose. Of course when we visit we always at the very least offer to take our shoes off. I remember as a kid my mother always took a bag with the families slippers in it when we visited friends and family. It's a nice gesture and I do it with my own family.
• Philippines
9 Jul 11
At our previous residence, I always request guests to take their shoes off because we are barefoot when inside the house, actually it's a condo. The floor is made of tiles and we just kept it clean because we lie down on it and step on it barefoot.
• United States
8 Jul 11
I do not believe it means your floor are more important plus you should not have to ask them to they should do it out of respect if they have nasty dirty shoes on. Have a Blessed Day
@nezavisima (7408)
• Bulgaria
8 Jul 11
I think when you go to the guest would normally take your shoes at the door. But it depends on the people around you and also how they behaved. I personally to me no one ever took my shoes because when I guest they just sit on the shelf and leave them there. But I think this is a respect for the guests. You come as my guest to try this method because I loved it. Thanks for the interesting discussion. Have a nice day!