Do your 1st impressions of people turn out to be mostly accurate or inaccurate?

@Awinds (2468)
United States
July 23, 2011 7:56pm CST
We all develop first impressions of people we meet for the first time. We take into account a new acquaintance's appearance or attitude and make assumptions about that person. An initial impression can be wrong or right. Maybe the kid dressed in black who prefers to keep to himself really is trouble, or maybe the new co-worker with the bright smile is a kind person through and through. First impressions can also be wrong. The man in the Armani suit really is a poor man just masquerading as a rich boy. Or maybe the sweet little old lady who gives candy to passing kids really is actually a disguised drug dealer. Maybe the man who is charming on the first date is holding back a scoundrel on the inside. So, are you a good judge of character? When you meet new people for the first time and form impressions about them, are your impressions right? Does that person turn out to be like your first suspected, or is their real nature different then what you initially thought? Do your first impressions turn out to mostly right or mostly inaccurate?
3 people like this
21 responses
• China
24 Jul 11
The first impressions of people turn out to be mostly inaccurate. Most people will not show their real nature before strangers. Sometimes they even pretend. Only after knowing him/her for a long time can we know him well.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
That is very true. Our own intuition is useless if the basis of our conclusion is misinformation.
@cathloe (184)
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
for me, some of my impressions to people turns to be accurate and some does not. it depends on the person who you are giving the impression. there were times that i thought this certain girl is quite, simple and conservative. then it turns out that she's loud, over the top, and very liberated. others, when i see them, there's this feeling that i've known them before and they're easy to make friends with. as it turns out, we'll be great friends and shares similar interest +.+ many times i've been judge by other people as snob and very quite. that's their first impression for me. they always say that when they've actually been attached to me and we are very close already. it's good thing that their impression for me turns out to be the opposite. i just laugh at their impressions about me. i thought you were like this and that... impressions could be wrong or not, as long as you see the real person behind that impression you have for them =)
1 person likes this
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
As long as one doesn't allow the first impression to dictate their action with the person, it can turn out to be wrong or right and may lead to something beautiful. :) Nearly all of my close friends have told me that when they first saw me, they thought me to an arrogant, overbearing bully. Apparently many people find my height and the serious way in which I carry myself to be intimidating. I am glad my friends don't hold the same opinion now but the thought that I give off that kind of first impression is kind of disturbing! :)
@KrauseHome (36448)
• United States
25 Jul 11
Many times I would consider myself being a Good judge of character and will usually end up picking people to want to get to know more as Good people and they are. I actually should have recently listened to my gut instinct on the last person we tried to rent too, who just never wanted to listen. I felt a bit of discomfort talking with him on the phone, and then in person the first day he has here, and did not listen. Now that we are interviewing potential renters again I am going to listen more before choosing someone and hope my instincts are right.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
25 Jul 11
I'm glad you brought your experience up. I didn't think of it before, but a good instinct for a person's character can be crucial in actual economic fields - like being a landlord. To be to trusting in such an area is going to get you a succession of lousy renters.
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
I don't usually judge people the first time. I try to know the person first before judging them. Actually, we don't really have the right to judge someone but, these days, we have to keep a mental profile of everyone around us just to be safe.
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
Kind of, yep.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
So you believe it best to be aware of people, but not to judge them? :)
@toniganzon (72285)
• Philippines
25 Jul 11
I'm really poor at judging person so i try my best not to. I am very vulnerable and i easily trust people so now i'm learning not to be so trusting. This reminded me of what my impression was on my high school teacher. I really admired her as she was pretty despite her age. Her daughter was one of my friends but I didn't base my judgment on that. I judged her based on my own observation. I really admired her looks and her brains. I always paid attention in her class and really looked up to her as a very fashionable doting mom and a good wife. One time she asked me, if i believe first impression lasts, to which i answered in the affirmative. She said she doesn't. I was a bit confused what she meant at that time, but later i realized that she was right. She turned out to be a totally different person than i thought. A few months later she ran away with another man and abandoned her family.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
25 Jul 11
That's highly unfortunately. That teacher must have been a good actor. I agree that being to trusting can get you burned, but don't get to hard. :)
@vivamir (671)
25 Jul 11
Hi Awinds..this is a great post! I like to think that I trust no one anyway..but as for first impressions, Im usually pretty accurate..Its like I can tell what their personality is like from the get go.. Im not judgmental in any way and know that anyone can put on an act on, I base my judgments on what that individual is like with ME, and if it ever gets to that point, my family too. Yet this is a gradual process, as it takes time to get to know a person..you can know someone for 10 years and they can still be a mystery.. (",)..
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
25 Jul 11
First of all, thanks! :) That is a great point! People are just to complicated to evaluate in a couple of seconds. It can take years and sometimes longer than that.
• Romania
24 Jul 11
I think the first impression can give you valuable clues about the person in front of you, as long as you pay attention to as many details as possible. Mine are pretty accurate.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
That's true - it can give you a foundation to go off if you are talented in the area. :)
@free_man (7330)
• United States
24 Jul 11
Hi Awinds and welcome to my lot. What your describing as judging is called spiritual decrement. God gives us all spiritual decrenment and HE expects us to know right from wrong. I never think about what someone is wearing who knows what they can or can't afford. When I meet a person I look and listen to what they are saying and how they look when they are talking. A person that can't look someone in the face when speaking to me seems like a person that isn't trust worthy of too much of my time. When I speak to anyone I always look them in the eyes. If I get a bad feeling about someone then it is usually right. I give people the opportunity to prove who they are. If someone is showering you with gifts need to look and wonder why they are doing this. For example my husbands wife she has always been showering me with all kinds of gifts and trying to buy my friendship, but at the same time in my face she is eying my husband up and down like he is a piece of meat, then when she can't force me to do something for her she tells lies about me. She is the type of person I feel that God would want people to stay away from. God gives us all spiritual decrement for us to stay away from evil. If you get a bad feeling about someone it is God telling you to stay away from them. But I never judge anyone not my place just know that first impressions is usually right. Good luck and God bless!
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
That does make sense - a divine instinct. Since we humans on our own can be pretty foolish. :)
1 person likes this
@megamatt (14292)
• United States
24 Jul 11
A lot of times, first impressions rarely mean much of anything to me. I give people a chance to prove themselves over time. Or rather enough rope to hang themselves as the case may be. The fact of the matter is, there are going to be a lot of times where people that we meet seem rather intimidating and rather off at first. Until we really get to know them and that's not something that we do at first. So yeah, first impressions are sometimes spot on but it is very, very rarely that I am right. I tend to judge them by experience, as opposed to what little impression that I might get at first. As it turns out, there are going to be a lot of times where the brighter the smile, the bigger the knife that they are going to stick into your back, but you would think that they were a nice person at first glance. Or maybe they are a nice person, maybe with some people what you see is what you get. There are all sorts out there.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
It does seem that "experiencing" the person over time is the best way. People are to complicated and have far to much potential to deceive to be judged in just a quick first glimpse. As you say, in some cases a larger smile equals a larger knife.
@rameshchow (4426)
• India
24 Jul 11
Unfortunately in my life first impressions was not occur, if occur they were failed. So i can try my level best to show my real way, they can know after some time. That will remain for ever in their hearts.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
It sounds like you try to be honest - which is good. :)
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
Most of the time my first impressions of people turn out to be accurate. I don't know if it's a gift, but whatever it is I'm glad i have such ability, because it really helps me to choose the right person whom I should be friends with. It's like I know how to read someones attitude even if I only see him or her for the first time.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
Congrats on that then - such a gift can save you much trouble in life. :)
@Alechin (217)
• Slovak Republic
24 Jul 11
My first impressions are usually right. I think most of us just give away enough information about us as to enable a accurate first impression. But there are people, that can cheat you by pretending to be something else, if they are skilled at pretending and experienced at it they can sway you to believe them. But this rarely stands the test of time and usually in time you are able to see beyond the lie.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
It seems if people don't think about it they emit a strong hint of who they are in public. It is just a matter of observing it. As you say, time is often the test that shows a person's true colors.
@elida279 (165)
• Bulgaria
24 Jul 11
Yes, usually my first impression turns out to be accurate but sometimes it happens to meet really good "actors" in life that can easily deceive everybody. Fortunately these people are not that many because it's really hard to deal with them. You can't be sure what they really think and what they are capable of doing. I don't like this kind. I prefer the natural people. The ones that when they tell me "Good afternoon" I don't need to check up the sun. :)
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
I think we all would rather deal with honest people then those who put up acts and fronts. You can never sure what is truth and like with the actors in life. :)
@Rick1950 (1575)
• Lima, Peru
24 Jul 11
In my opinion, at the first impression, you can't have an accurate knowledge about the person but an approximately. It's possible to have the wrong impression too. However you can build an opinion by hearing the voice, looking the eyes, the posture, the gestures and knowing the thinking. Each person has different feelings. To have an accurate impression will help by going beyond sympathy and antipathy.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
That is good point - it is essential to observe the clues given by the person even after initial contact. :)
• United States
24 Jul 11
I stopped this when I was in highschool. The first time I saw my highschool orchestra teacher I thought he was mean. But he wasn't. So from then on I didn't go by appearance when I meet someone. I just get to know them first.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
It's good you stopped so early - you probably haven't missed any opportunities with people since you halted the habit. :)
1 person likes this
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
i dont believe in 1st impression as you will never know a certain person unless you live with them in one roof. sometimes its easy to fake people with your smile nor gesture though somehow theres something in them that lies behind those actions.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
That's true. Some people go out of their way to deceive. They can get away with this especially with people who only use the first impression to judge the reality of a person.
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
I am quite in between about this. Well, I do employ first impression on my private opinion of the person and usually take notes on what they are or whatever they are doing. I don't call it judging but observing. However, that would be the start of my opinion of the person. I usually have certain assumptions on a person but I don't act on it unless I know the person better. If I would have the chance to interact, it would likely approve or disapprove of my opinion and my certain observation of him or her. That would start, in return, a relationship or a bond. I don't really judge but they are times that I do, being a feeble and sometimes close-minded human at times. But I try to remedy that and understand the person and their point of view as much as possible.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
That is true. Observing a person we newly meet isn't always bad - it can save us trouble later, as opposed to turning a blind eye to what our instincts tell us about a person we first meet. It is good though to get more information via knowing someone then going of a first impression alone.
@bouncybug (614)
• South Africa
24 Jul 11
I've found that I'm definitely not a good judge of character. I seem to always get people wrong when I meet them - usually I seem to be too trusting of people. Maybe that's not a bad thing, but sometimes it can lead to problems - I never expect people to do anything horrible and I sometimes get disappointed. This is especially the case with boys - I seem to think that some boys are really lovely people and inevitably they end up hurting me! So although its a good thing to be trusting, it can sometimes be dangerous to just blindly trust everyone - you should be careful about who you put your faith in, and wait until you know someone better before you judge them, good or bad.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
Wise words, bouncybug. I'm glad you responded as you bring up a very good point -not everyone in the world is as they seem and not all of nice intentions. :)
@Mysteria (209)
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
first impression happen when we are briefly exposed to a person. The accuracy of our judgment can be right or wrong. In my case, people have always a wrong impression about me. Most of my friends admitted that they put up their defenses right away because they see me as a very snobbish. I can't blame them to be very cautious in dealing with me because I appear that way because of my upbringing.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
I have experienced similar - many of my friends have told me that when they first saw me they believed me to be quite mean and nasty. I would love to discover what quality it is exactly that gives of this impression. It does get tiresome after awhile.
• Philippines
24 Jul 11
As being a human being, hmmm..I can't help sometimes to think something about people I meet for the first time. Some of of my first impression are accurate but there are times that I am wrong. The good thing to do is know the person well.
@Awinds (2468)
• United States
24 Jul 11
You can only verify a conclusion if you spend time with the person. I think what you say is true for all of us.:)