Death of the Craft store...

United States
October 1, 2011 6:38pm CST
I do not know what it is like in other ares for crafters but in our area of P.A. the craft stores are all closing. Now I do not mean just the little Mom and Pop store which where chased out a while ago by the big chains but even the chains are gone. Now even Walmart has just about rid themselves of their craft section. We have to drive 60+ miles to get to the closest craft store. Are the craft stores dying out anywhere else? I mean of coarse I can and do shop on line but there are times you just want to feel the fabric or yarn to get a better idea of how it will work up.
2 people like this
13 responses
@peavey (16936)
• United States
1 Oct 11
So far, so good here, although we've lost a locally owned store. I think it just couldn't compete with Michael's and Hobby Lobby. I know what you mean about shopping online for craft supplies. I have done it when I couldn't find the yarn I wanted, but I try to support the stores we have. I don't want them going out of business! And I'm sorry yours has.
2 people like this
• United States
2 Oct 11
We are rural and I guess many are not crafting anymore. We do have a quilt shop but they are very over priced for their fabric. I take the kids to sewing classes there which are a good price at least. I have heard of Hobby Lobby but never been in one are they nice?
1 person likes this
@peavey (16936)
• United States
3 Oct 11
I love Hobby Lobby. They have a lot more than Michael's does, here, anyway, and the whole store has a wonderful atmosphere. Besides craft stuff, they carry a lot of decorating items, old fashioned style to oriental. Bridal stuff, candles of all kinds, throw pillows, cross stitch and needlepoint, embroidery, yarns, paints and canvas, unfinished woodwork, miniatures, glass and ceramic decorations and on and on. I usually spend way more time there than I should.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Oct 11
Sounds like I would too
1 person likes this
@ElicBxn (63235)
• United States
2 Oct 11
My Walmarts are bringing back the fabric
1 person likes this
@ElicBxn (63235)
• United States
3 Oct 11
Happily, I live in a large city and not only do I have Michael's and Hobby Lobby, but I've got a Joann's nearby AND several quilting store, a cross stitch store AND several bead stores (I personal Waterloo)
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Oct 11
Ours they closed down to only quilting fabrics just about and beading supplies.
2 people like this
@Amfyre (512)
• Canada
2 Oct 11
Mine too and it's about time, our walmart closed to relocate and it has taken 2 years to get a craft section going. They just started bring some quilting supplies, can buy thread there now, even a few lame buttons. But Hey it's a start... I hope!
2 people like this
• United States
3 Oct 11
Crafts are a soft target for the recession I'm afraid. Rents are going up and the numbers of customers are going down, plus their wallets are on a diet. In this climate, the Internet is about the only way to go as the overhead can be near zero to create a very professional looking 'store'. Mom & Pop have not disappeared, they've headed to cyberspace the way the farmers fled the Oklahoma Dust Bowel for California in droves. You can run speciality stores, take risks, and sell things for a nitch market with out the fear of loosing the shirt off your back when you open a Yahoo store. Your inventory can be sitting under the bed for all the world to know, yet your 'store' can look as professional as Amazon. You can do your customer service in your P.J.s.
• United States
4 Oct 11
Along with the Online stores, there are consignments to get products into the community, and you can rent areas to hold classes in for relatively low cost, booths at art fairs you can share with other artists, or even have Tupperware style parties for your crafts. You can send out small free samples of yarn doily type crafties (say an inch round) for touching at these parties. Word of mouth carries a lot of weight. I'm guessing...
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Oct 11
You both have good points. I mean it is easy to do an online store in fact a friend of mine has one and does more sales online then in the actual shop. She does classes in the shop that keep her afloat though. Then again when you are in need of an item that touch is so important for it would be nice to be able to sample so to say.
2 people like this
@Amfyre (512)
• Canada
3 Oct 11
That is all to true, however I am one of the people who likes to browse and feel things and touch stuff and look and look some more. Often something online may look good but in truth its over priced junk. And Shipping Ugh!
1 person likes this
@neededhope (1085)
• United States
10 Oct 11
Actually where I was living this was happening and than walmart did change there craft section to be little as possible. But some good news ahead. I've heard Walmart is bringing back there craft section because of a huge lost in sales. So I hope this helps you and comes back to your walmart. So far this has been true in our area. And I to love shopping in the stores and feeling the things I wanna purchase. but if all ends fails quess online would have to be it. I hope it all works out thou.
• United States
12 Oct 11
Me to will keep my fingers crossed
1 person likes this
@celticeagle (158958)
• Boise, Idaho
2 Oct 11
We have a couple of higher end craft stores left here but not many. By higher end I mean more expensive product sellers. It is sad to see alot of these mom and pop places close but that is the way of the future. I do try to frequent the little places and feel I am helping them as best I can. Sad to see them go.
@celticeagle (158958)
• Boise, Idaho
2 Oct 11
We are a college town too but also a capitol city. We are in the 6 digit population wise.
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Oct 11
lmao we're just at 24,000 when school is in!
2 people like this
• United States
2 Oct 11
Yes, very sad. I love little stores but so many are gone here. In truth we barley even have big stores... in fact we are a college town and Starbucks only lasted 5 months and was gone..Starbucks!
2 people like this
@Amfyre (512)
• Canada
2 Oct 11
We use to have 5 large cloth stores here, we are down to 3 and one specializes only in cotton for quilting, the other one more for the Hutterites, the 3rd is a family owned disaster and you have practicly beg to have service. Walmart did have a craft section that was awesome but they closed to move the store and the new store has taken 2 years to begin to get a craft section. So that leaves Michaels, 3 dollars stores (ack), Staples and Walmart... its so sad! We do have places like Zellars etc but crayola isn't exactly what artists use for permanent displays. Luckily my child is still into glitter glue and is happy with acrylic paint on canvas!
• United States
4 Oct 11
My six year old likes to draw fashion clothes while her 10 year old sister is sewing them. The oldest is 12 and very much into clay, sculpting and what not.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Oct 11
Mine do so much of that in their school work they want other things to do. My older ones especially.
1 person likes this
@Amfyre (512)
• Canada
3 Oct 11
yup but she still wants to do the cool stuff too. Lately it is clothing glitter with permanent cloth glur to go on her clothes and Iron on patches. For most part she is 5 going on 15...sigh
1 person likes this
@pergammano (7682)
• Canada
10 Oct 11
Sadly, I also think that it is NOT just the financial crunch that is causing the "disappearing" Craft store...in my opinion, I think "crafting" except for us, die hard few, has gone by the way of electronic entertainment devices! Very, very seldom do I find young persons, from my son's generation..doing any crafting of any form, and not even interested in creating beautiful things, that are proudly their own! It seems so much easier, for them, to buy..NOT create! I am not picking on that generation...but somewhere the "crafting" interest has gone awry. I live on a small Island, so NO craft stores...but recently 2 of the Michaels in large Metro areas, Victoria and Vancouver have folded. Here in B.C., they were extremely expensive! Walmart built a HUMUNGOUS (quadruple Warehouse size) store in Victoria area...and NO craft items..None, Nada! About 20 years ago, when I took up "pergamano" (parchment craft-ancient) I was able to obtain supplies most places. NOW, I have ONE on-line store on the East Coast of Canada, and I don't like buying supplies that way! I, too, am an avid knitter, but am finding it diminishing from the shelves, too! Very little at Walmart, Zellers, Sears or the Bay! I used to be able to buy "Cowichan" wool most places..not now! Another downside of the financial downturn, in my area, is the diminishing "Craft Fair and Sales,"! Few participants..and NO money! It seems so different, to me...when/where I grew up, about the only thing we didn't make was our shoes..but we did make mocassins...and we would shop (LOL) for 50# Flour sacks..as they all used to be made of beautiful printed cotton that could be made into many things! Dating myself, aren't I? Have a great week!
• Canada
12 Oct 11
I am hoping you will finish the conversation when you come for leftovers tonight...was this another glitch? LOL! Yikes, I had "glitches" galore, all my notifications came triplicates & quadriplicates...the 73 alerts..and not being able to log on for 5 hours, so I have a lot of catching up to do! You must be so proud of your girls, "crafty" little things that they are!
• United States
12 Oct 11
Yes the loss of craft shows has hurt me. I sell at them or did but few go to them anymore so there is little point in selling at the,
1 person likes this
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
4 Oct 11
We have the same problem here...our JoAnn's moved...and two scrapbook stores closed.Walmart doesn't really have anything for either scrapping...or stamping. My two favorite crafts....Dang it anyway!
1 person likes this
• United States
4 Oct 11
Our Walmart moved the scrap booking items over to the stationary section! I was looking to make a card for a Bridal shower and was getting upset until someone told me they moved it.
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
2 Oct 11
Isnt that the sadest thing! Where I used to live there was a Joanne Crafts and a Michaels really near by, but they weren't there until just few years ago...they moved from a farther location to closer to another town. But now.. I have moved to a different area and a Joannes is about 20 minutes away via freeway and smaller than the one I was used to and a michaels about same distance...haven't been there yet. Michaels doesn't do fabric and that is my medium at the moment... but they had great stuff before. But the only other place in this entire area....is Walmart...has an isle of fabric and an isle of notions etc...and that's it. Cutting table is only 2 yards long! It is a shame crafts are not popular anymore. People sure are missing out on a speciality in life.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Oct 11
Yes it is sad and the more rural you go the less stores they have, ironic as the more rural you go the higher the ratio of crafters.
1 person likes this
@bounce58 (17387)
• Canada
14 Oct 11
I think that's just it! The online stores are forcing the stores, even the big chain stores, to close down. Although it's better to feel the fabric when you're in a store, it's better for business to sell their products online. That way when a consumer doesn't like the fabric when he/she receives it, he/she will order more online. Good for business!
• United States
16 Oct 11
I see your point, that works as long as they are not sending the fabric back I guess..
@bagarad (14283)
• Paso Robles, California
2 Oct 11
This is what happens when we do most shopping on line and only patronize our local stores when we need something fast. It's happening to bookstores, too. If we can't support them most of the time, they simply can't afford to stay in business and we will have to do all our shopping for non-perishable goods on line.
• United States
2 Oct 11
Too true. I love to go to the craft stores personally but will admit I buy less since my husband lost his job. Only what I need to make what I am working on. I have had to go online more though to make ends meet for my projects... mostly on Ebay..
1 person likes this
@joni1215 (394)
• United States
15 Oct 11
I live in Dallas, Tx and one would think as large as we are there would be more options for crafting but sadly this is not the case. My favorite bead store went out of business and I have yet to find one that carries the products that she did all under one roof. Many are specializing only. I do weaving, wire work and other types and I am not one for a lot of shopping. I truly felt like that store was home. I guess I get attached too easily! I learned how to bead there and so the staff was like family. A couple of them have gone to work elsewhere but I have to drive 32 miles to that store. Not you average jump in the car and go snooping event. I do have Michaels and Hobby Lobby close by and I love those stores but they are pretty pricey. I usually end up on Ebay but I like to see what I am buying because those photos can be so misleading. We have JoAnns Fabrics and Hancock Fabrics. Like them both and depends on what I am shopping for as to where I go. There are a couple of bead stores fairly close but one specializes in stones and so forth and the other about the same. I dearly love working with Swarovski crystals but they are nearly extinct here because we can't compete with Ebay on prices. And those who do have them are to pricey. I wish I could start my own craft store. I have always dreamed of that.
• United States
16 Oct 11
I too have dreamed about starting my own craft store but the fact that they are all going under makes me to nervous to try. that and I home school my three older children and have a very active 1 year old to chase everywhere
@beenice2 (2967)
• Sackville, New Brunswick
24 Jan 12
The new generation are only for the most part computer literate they don't seem to want to learn other thing that could help them to create with there hands instead of see things on the screen. In here Canada the Walmart still have some crafts stuff for sale. We still have the " Fabricville" store chain that comes from Montreal, Quebec. Not to worry we can make some more money doing things with our hands and selling it to those that don't work with there hands.