The Americans want to follow Indian culture but the Indians......

India
November 29, 2011 6:57am CST
The westerners particularly the Americans learn Yoga, Meditation from India. They respect and love Indian culture, especially our marriage and family systems. But unfortunately Indians want to follow western culture. Lately there has been drastic changes in our culture and family systems. The divorce rate in India has increased significantly, yet India has the least divorce rates when compared to other developed and developing countries. Your views please....
5 people like this
14 responses
@dollar3235 (2062)
• India
30 Nov 11
Hi Vijayanths, Till the time we will not respect our mother tongue (i.e. Hindi), this problem will be with us. The more value we give to English language in our country, the more problems we will have in maintaining our culture. As far as liking and adapting to other cultures is concerned, I would say, "the grass is always greener on the other side of the fence".
1 person likes this
@cobradene (1171)
• India
30 Nov 11
We are still way too illiterate to understand each other's culture within our own nation. We make fun of different state languages, cultures, traditions and ways of living and to the extent that we make fun of the way they worship God. A small example to how we praise the west more than a fellow Indian. There was a Bihari couple and another Bihari student traveling with me and two other sisters (Tamilians) from Chennai to Mumbai. These Biharis start making fun the food we Tamilians eat, the way we apply ash on the forehead, and how we do shashtang namaskar in front of the deity. But...but....look at the hypocrisy. They have been to Germany, and found the culture very nice, and however liberal westerners are with their ways, they say, "It is their culture. We must not make fun of them, but accept them the way they are." We stared at them in awe and I wanted to say,"Excuse me, you just made fun of the Tamil culture and tradition, and disrespected us right on our faces, and you want to praise and respect some culture which is far away and they don't even belong to the same nationality?"
1 person likes this
• India
1 Dec 11
That's a good point cobradene, let us first be united as Indians and respect all from all the states. then we can go to the next level....
1 person likes this
@roberten (3128)
• United States
4 Dec 11
Any way you slice the cultural divide, the grass always looks greener on the other side. We humans long for that which we do not have and often ignore that which we do. I suppose this will never change anytime soon. If these changes continue at this rate the world will be behaving more like one nation rather than many....
@vandana7 (98826)
• India
5 Dec 11
I subscribe to that grass is green on the other side of the fence concept. :)
1 person likes this
• Philippines
30 Nov 11
Not only India but, a lot of other countries in this world has been significantly influenced by the American culture. It is indeed sad because, these other countries have also imbibed or absorbed the bad side of the American culture. All of us wish that it is only the good side which is being copied. However, this is not so. The moral values in the US of A has gone so very low. How I wish, this will not seep through people upon people, country upon country, culture upon culture. May you have a good day.
• India
1 Dec 11
Very true trinidadvelasco. I fully agree with you.Of course there are so many good things of America that we can follow, but unfortunately we are more interested in copying some of the bad things from them.
1 person likes this
@RawBill1 (8531)
• Gold Coast, Australia
7 Dec 11
Indian culture is very popular here in Australia too. Not only do we respect your love of cricket, but many Aussies travel to India seeking enlightenment. I have a few friends who have been there and they rave about how wonderful the country is. But I do know that it has it's bad sides too over there and I guess that is why a lot of Indians are giving up their traditional ways and are becoming westernised. This is not a good thing for India in my opinion as the western way of living is very unsustainable in an environmental sense. With a population as big as India's I believe they need to maintain those traditional values as much as possible. If they continue to leave the land for the city then most of the population will end up in slums I feel.
1 person likes this
@vandana7 (98826)
• India
29 Nov 11
Vijayanths, you are equating staying in bad marriage as sign of culture. Agreed that children are affected in our society so at times it might be better. But when marriage is truly bad, its better that the couple divorces. At least, according to me. The reason - in a bad marriage both partners get into foul mood cannot adjust to each other and spread unhappiness all around. They snap more often, and increase this ratio of unhappiness through their children as well. So bad marriage is in effect bad for the society. The couple would also become indifferent towards whatever is their profession leading to more headaches for others. Divorce rates have increased because there are more well paying jobs, and more women find it easier to survive without a husband.
@vandana7 (98826)
• India
30 Nov 11
And it is not as if we did not have precedence of divorces in our culture. The most famous equivalent of it would be Shantanu and Ganga, where Ganga left Shantanu for not fulfilling his end of the bargain. So our culture permits that.
@vandana7 (98826)
• India
30 Nov 11
Hey - Shantanu wore his heart on his sleeves - that is the reason he fell for Satyavathi - something like Shiny Ahuja falling for his maid. Never mind I am not here to argue but when you called us women cruel then all my antennae were up.
@vandana7 (98826)
• India
30 Nov 11
Yeah, because Shantanu loved Ganga, he fell head over heels in love with Satyavathi.. Gimme a break - two of the best characters in Mahabharata - Bhishma, and Karna. Rest deserve no respect according to Vandy. And two of the best characters in Ramayana - Lakshmana and Bharata. Rest can go to Timbaktoo for all that I care.
@jennyze (7029)
• Indonesia
19 Dec 11
Does it mean Indian men are more loyal to their wives than any other men? I would say that is what is called "The grass in the neighbor's yard looks greener". We look at other people and we want to act or mimic their doings. If only, we can separate the good from the bad and try only to adopt the good things...
1 person likes this
• United States
29 Nov 11
Guilty as charged! I don't do yoga but I respect your marriage rules. The reason to marry is out of the person's hands and there is no romance added until after marriage. And you marry to have kids , period. Why do I like this. the rules are clearly set. You don;t have one not wanting kids and another wanting many. You don't have a relationship that is Only based on romantic love. So both parties Know what is expected. And if you don;t want kids , you don't marry! Over here, many want kids but not to be married and many want marriage but no kids.That is ok! the thing that makes our divorce rate soar is when one want one thing and the other doesn't and they can't agree. But then again how do you agree to have a child you will never love? So they split. Or worse. They Wanted children but couldn't agree on all the other things and argue so much they split. And the kids think marriage Is only fighting. I think this is what is happening too. The kids of divorce are now adults and they are not marrying.So that can be why many, like me, honor your system.
• United States
29 Nov 11
I wonder how many Americans would marry if there was no divorce? I have always seen marriage as the end of happiness and hope.I choose love over marriage and always will. Here in The States you can remain unmarried. many are so pressured to marry and then they divorce.But what if there were no divorce?
• India
30 Nov 11
Hi, sarahruthbeth22 , if there is no divorce there, no one will take the risk of the marriage. I think due to increased court expenses people avoid getting married. Life is so different in different parts of the world.
1 person likes this
• United States
15 Jan 12
My opinion is the grass is always greener on the other side. So much is going on all over the world, and many in the younger generations are breaking away from the traditions of their elders, because they feel they have made mistakes that have brought us to our state today. These people feel that if they try something that is perceived as as far away from their own culture as possible, then they will gain better control of their lives. Plus, when you are looking at the culture mostly through the glorification of television, it loses some of the actual realities of the culture in translation. So you are only seeing the best parts of the culture, without knowing the struggles behind it, which can also make it seem better than your own. But without having lived it, you will never know.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
29 Nov 11
Hi Vijayanths, Americans have been interested in learning about your culture for years and especially the yoga and meditation and spiritual ways. As for divorce, well, it''s sad because marriage is meant to be forevr. It's good that the option is there but it would be nice if people took more time before entering into it.
• India
29 Nov 11
Yes sid556, we have rich spiritual culture. It's sad we are also going for divorce at higher rate these days. Even Chinese martial arts and FengShui originated from India. Ancient India was top in all the fields.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
29 Nov 11
I have to say that I've been interested in the eastern culture for years. I do think that divorce it is good that divorce is an option but I think that too many rush into it as quickly as they run into the marriage...at least that is what I see here in the States. Both Western and Eastern cultures have their good qualities.
• India
29 Nov 11
You are right sid556. We never opt for a divorce even when there is a need for it, wherein you go for it even when there is no need for it.
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
29 Nov 11
Hi,vijayanths, When westerners take the trouble to learn our culture and our traditions, there is nothing wrong in us doing the same with theirs .This does not mean that we forego our values and forget our culture...It is good to assimilate the best of western and eastern values.As for increasing divorce rates and other related issues - it is socially proven that when there is increased freedom of the sexes and financial equality , this is bound to happen - one can expect both negative and positive influences when there is a social change ...all the best
• India
30 Nov 11
that's the curse of our loving country.politicians and leaders are corrupt and have no morals. Good and honest people should come forward to lead the people and people should encourage them when they come forward to lead...
• India
29 Nov 11
Hi, kiran8, I agree with each word you said. There is nothing wrong in accepting the good things from western culture. But do we take only the good things? That's the problem we face now. I agree with you that divorce is inevitable when both sexes get financial independence as you said. We have to give something to get something and that's life, isn't it?
@kiran8 (15348)
• Mangalore, India
29 Nov 11
Exactly! The problem with most people including our politicians who go for foreign jaunts apparently to learn something is that they don't take the trouble to observe and learn what is good in the western system .Instead they shop, gamble and generally have fun and come back.Of course we need to have some fun in our life but, here it is only that...When we look at the infra structure and the way things are run there like clockwork, we have to hang our heads in shame.We don't even have proper roads and sanitation facilities in many major cities...
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
29 Nov 11
dear anna, There is no reliable statistics confirming which country has lesser divorce rate. Yoga and meditation is a good thing. I will consider this idea as well for health matters.
• India
30 Nov 11
my dear jai sister, no need for statistics, India still has lower divorce rate than many more countries in the world. USA has a higher divorce rate for sure. You can do Yoga and meditation daily and stay fit and young.
@vandana7 (98826)
• India
5 Dec 11
Jaiho - quite often it is financial constraints, and at other times it is ignorance. Culture is not the main reason that our marriages remain intact.
• Philippines
23 Dec 11
yes, i agree culture is not the reason why marriages remain intact but personal decisions.
@RobtheRock (2433)
• United States
29 Nov 11
I agree with shailesh5499. There is some good, but also some bad. I think marriage is tied to religion and Western culture to me is against the moral laws of religion. Many people here call this a Christian nation and yet, divorce is not Christian. Jesus said for us "not" to divorce our spouse. Yet, we do, and we're trying to force our beliefs on other countries. Homosexuality is another thing that we're trying to force on us first. India won't be that far behind.
• India
30 Nov 11
I can't agree more RobtheRock. Divorce is not Hinduism. As you said I also think India won't be that far behind.
1 person likes this
• United States
29 Nov 11
You are right, the American culture (including myself) has really taken an interest in Yoga and/or any meditation technics, it has become extremely popular within the last few years. As far as the divorce rate in India, it is sad to hear that marriages now a days aren't forever, I personally believe or still have fairy tale mind in which marriages is something that is to last forever with the person you love. I know that in reality most of the time that's not the case, but I still hope and pray that my marriage lasts forever and they we are as happy then as we are now.
• India
29 Nov 11
You are absolutely right fabsprecious.It's good to note the westerners show interest in Yoga and meditation. It's sad that the divorce rate has increased in India too lately. Still, divorce is a rare thing for us even now.I wish you to have a ever lasting and happy marriage.
• India
30 Nov 11
That's so unfortunate fabsprecious that living happily ever after happens only in fairy tales and not real lives. Though it's a silly dream it's good to have it. may be your dream will come true..Good luck.
• United States
29 Nov 11
Thank you vijayanths!!! It is sad to see that the divorce rate is increasing, I wish everyone could have the happily ever after ending, like in those fairytale stories. I know it's a silly dream, but it is still my dream.
• India
29 Nov 11
I couldn't agree more, the divorce rate is increasing because people are adoring western culture. Actually, there's nothing wrong with that, but they think that getting a divorce and living a western lifestyle stand them above everybody else. These people are living their life in misconception and have a way too different living culture than an average Indian. Probably these Indians are from Metros like Mumbai and New Delhi, attending pubs and discos every night, so their upbringing was in such an atmosphere that makes them ridicule Indian culture and what it is exactly. Americans are loving yoga and they're wise enough to follow what's correct in Indian culture. Yoga is need of the hour, I do yoga every morning and my remaining day goes well after doing it, I feel so relieved after so much of stressful work. Indians need to understand that following westerners is good, but adopt good points in their culture and not the bad ones. Adopt the way Americans respect women in their society, how they have equal rights and not adopting things like divorce.