Will you change your religion because of your boyfriend or girlfriend?!

@Lhenni (1242)
Philippines
March 27, 2012 6:02am CST
My 19 year old niece is in our house for a day. I saw her reading a Mormon book a while ago. And she told me that she's in that group just recently. I asked her what did her mother (my sister) and her granny (my mother) say about it knowing we're all raised in a Catholic doctrine. She said, the granny got mad. Well, I just told her to go where she see and feel the joy brings by religions. I'm a Catholic but I don't see any wrongful act if she's in other group now which my mother (her grandma) fell the other way around. I remember, she's courting before by her elementary classmate which is in the Mormons group. Hmmm... I think, I know the reason behind her shifting...
6 people like this
34 responses
@wittynet (4421)
• Philippines
27 Mar 12
No. He should be the one who needs to do that if he really loves me. If he can't, then I'll consider it a bad sign. I'll no longer continue my relationship with him. I'll not let myself suffer just because of him. If he can't leave his religion and join mine, what else can he do for me? I think there's nothing he can do.
@Runite (307)
• United States
28 Mar 12
So you're going to base your relationship based on relationship not love? :|
1 person likes this
@wittynet (4421)
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
They are both important, Runite. But I can never continue loving a man who is not willing to support me. If he really loves me, he'll consider changing his religion. Anyway, I haven't met a man yet who has a different religion from mine.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Glad my husband and I have the same beliefs... Well, if in case we're not in the same, one of us should go and accept one's faith for it will surely different having kids. I know some coupled neighbors who's in different sect, and their kids suffer.
1 person likes this
28 Mar 12
Since all religions are based on myth and legend with no presence in the real world except how people react to them then it is okay to follow whatever religion you wish provided in doing so you do not harm anyone. When I say harm I do not include upsetting some else's illusions I mean such things as becoming a muslim then killing people because they are not or becoming a catholic and killing protestants.
29 Mar 12
Oh Lhennni the killings are usually politically motivated by the people who instigate them but the way they persuade others to carry out the killings is to use their religious beliefs. Take 9/11 the young men who killed themselves and some 3000 others were not gaining any monetary or political advantage from their acts so their motivation must have been religious
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Oh, I want to believe that the killings were not really because of religions differences...
@ajithlal (14716)
• India
29 Mar 12
I think everyone should have their freedom in choosing the religion. I think one should not force a person to chose a religion especially among the lovers or among a husband and a wife. I think if a person really loves and cares for his partner he or she would not force the person to change the religion.
• India
30 Mar 12
You are right my friend. I also agree with you. Have a nice day.
@SinfulRose (3527)
• Davao, Philippines
27 Mar 12
To answer your title: "Why would I?" I mean, "who are they to get to me to let go of what I believe in?" As for my opinion, there really isn't anything wrong with changing one's religion as long as one feels "at home" where one is. In other words, I do not see it a "wrong" if one just decides to go where one believes something is true and is right. What's wrong with doing what you feel is right? But if one transfers religion just for a pitiful excuse or reasons like "because of him" or "because of her", I think we're going to have a debate in the making. I'm sorry but for me the action, with such a reason, is the same as insulting the religion where one came from and where that one will go to because one do not see the following religions as Holy and is worthy of respect...That's only in my opinion...
• Davao, Philippines
29 Mar 12
If that is so then that is okay. She has the freedom to choose for herself too--as long as her decision is right.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Maybe my niece, accepted to belong in that group not only because of the love of her man but because she saw and feel something in their faith to be accepted too.
• Slovenia
2 Apr 12
That's a metter of one's own will I would say. I'm in a situation where my boyfriend is muslim and I'm christian, he too asked me to convert and I always said I'm not sure, I just don't feel completely right changing it, but as far as I know isnt is a mandatory for one to change religion if two want to marry, like in any religion they have to have the same religion? so maybe if love is so strong, maybe then one could decide to convert, to give this final meaning to your relatinship, which is marriage.
@riempie9 (1021)
• South Africa
12 May 12
I was in this situation for a long time with a born again Christian who tried every minute of the day to convert me. He was looking to score points with God by recruiting as many people as he could to convert them to Christianity. I saw the under deacon at my house at least four times during our two year relationship. He was such a fanatic that he sometimes did not have money to buy a new shirt and wanted a tv, but he felt guilty and had to give them a certain amount. In the end I sold my house and moved out of the neighborhood to get away from him. He still calls me now and again and says jokingly, "Riempie, do you want to become Christian?" Look, he's adorable, but is completely under the control of his under deacon. I still like him - not love - but I can like him from afar.
@samar54 (2454)
• Egypt
27 Mar 12
I believe that my religion is the true religion which God choose it to people ,for this is not to I change it to any one regardless of his value in my life, my religion remains for me, but the man could leave me .
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Hmmm... seems you got a very solid foundation samar. Me either!
@samar54 (2454)
• Egypt
29 Mar 12
Yes , it is very solid foundation more than you can Imagine , Gods guide you to His way
@owlwings (43915)
• Cambridge, England
28 Mar 12
I see no harm in wanting to find out about other religions because you know someone who is a member of that religion. What she is doing, in fact, is probably more about trying to understand and know more about someone she is fond of. I wonder if she encourages her Mormon friend to attend Catholic meetings, especially Bible discussion groups. That would show that he is as interested in her as she is in him.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
I think the guy was once a Catholic. That's a good wondering owlwings. How willing each partners with different religion to study each other's beliefs *wink!
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
I'm religion neutral so it won't be hard for me to embrace one.Well,it depends on the teachings.Religion is just a belief system.Why would you let anything get in the way of love if it's true love?
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Yeah! Religion is just a group system beliefs. Our own faith will still matter most. Well, getting in a way of true love is an obstacle to surpass. And spiritual faith should not be classified as such. But it should be complimenting for the partner to have so much complimenting years too to enjoy.
@derek_a (10874)
28 Mar 12
Personally I would not change my religion for my partner and never did for my girlfriends either. As such I don't have a religion but practice Zenm which is a a way of life that involves regular meditation and mindfulness. I do no follow rules and regulations, but follow my conscience about doing no harm to another human being. I would also never expect a loved one to change their religion either as I think we are all at different levels of spirituality and have to discover truth for ourselves. It all leads to the same space of enlightenment anyway, it's just that we each tend to see things differently. _Derek
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
That's what important, following our conscience. For I believe, our conscience is also the goodness in ours.
@tonyllenium (6252)
• Italy
27 Mar 12
i think that if a person want change the religion is because they feel important for him/her in private life not because somebody tells that you should change or because you married a person believing in other religion...
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Yeah! Maybe she see some uplifting power hearing their doctrine why she belongs in there now...
@bhanusb (5709)
• India
28 Mar 12
If love compels someone to change his or her religion he or she can do that. But I feel there should not be any bar of religion to marry someone who is beloved. A man and woman can be life partner with different religion.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
I knew some too who prefer to be in different religion and yet, still together in a harmonious relationship they has till this time.
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
28 Mar 12
Hmmm.. if you are changing for someone else, i do not think that is good thing. But if she is changing for herself then it is good. Personally, i would not change my religion for the sake of another person, if ever i would change, it would be for my own personal reasons.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Likewise, it will be a strong spiritual reason if in case it's me...
@Metatronik (6199)
• Pasay, Philippines
28 Mar 12
This was Ms. Universe question to Shamcey Supsup. If I were to ask at first I would like to know their beliefs then compare it to my recent religion. If I found out that they have more strong good moral values and I was motivated then that is the time for me to think twice if I would change or not. Second honestly I have frustrations at times in Catholic especially the people around it. So I would be also concern on how other people value that religious aspect. I would change it not because of the person I love but because I was more motivated on their beliefs. In your niece's case then I think she was motivated by the religion itself not because of her boyfriend.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
I firmly believed in that too Metatronic.
• India
28 Mar 12
I think that religion has any role in the relations. People worship in different goddess for their sake and no one has any right to change or force him to change his religion.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Maybe my niece wasn't forced to. She freely submit in a very strong spiritual reason she had.
@GemmaR (8517)
27 Mar 12
I don't think that I would ever want to change my religion for anybody, let alone somebody who is supposed to love me the way I am, and no matter what. My boyfriend is not the same religion as me, but I know that he will accept me as I am and would never ask for me to change. If you were sure about your religion and the God that you believed in, surely you wouldn't want to change it to something that you didn't think was the truth. Surely if you change your religion at all, it could be argued that you weren't all that religious in the first place.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Yeah! I think my niece is not that religious or maybe no solid foundations in her religion which happen to be just an inheritance from her parents.
• Philippines
27 Mar 12
Hello Lhenni, Religion should be a personal devoted choice and not because the one you love is there.but i know from a person i used to work with changed her religion because of her boyfriend i think they are now married.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
I know some too that accepted one's belief for the unity of their soon family. Maybe it's true that it's because of their partner, but I believe too that it can't be possible if they won't see some light in there to be accepted.
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
27 Mar 12
Based on the fact that I grew up in a family that was very religious, I could not ever see myself changing religions. However, if I didn't grow up in a family that had a firm set of beliefs, then changing religions so that I was able to share my faith with my future spouse would be something that I might be willing to do. When I met the man that is now my husband, he came from a family that didn't have a firm set of beliefs and he decided to explore my religion (I'm a Roman Catholic). After attending RCIA classes he did decide to become a Catholic.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Wow! Your're right, maybe my niece has so solid foundation with regards to her inherited beliefs that's why she changed.
• United States
27 Mar 12
sometimes we learn from each other. I would suggest to pray about it and seek for truth and go from their and ask questions , ask God to lead you that is the most important. ask in Jesus name for all things given unto him and ask not in a form of prayer but as if you are direct talking to another but to Him tell him your question and get your answer you will know. I would not change anything unless you took it God first. for what man puts together does not last what God does last for ever. who knows God may move you totally into a differant area to better serve Him and it may not be either the one you have now nor the other talked about...
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Well, you're a highly opinionated goldenteardrops! Maybe my niece, see some light to belong in their...
• Philippines
27 Mar 12
That depends on what the religion teaches. If I am not mistaken, mormon's allow their members to marry twice,maybe thrice and so forth (not sure about this) If this is the case, I will never change my religion. Maybe my religion is not the true religion, but joining a religion that allows bigamy is even far from the truth.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Oh, I know nothing about Mormons beliefs. I won't join too if that's true (glad I'm not to choose). Got to ask my niece about this if it's really in their beliefs...
@TheIzers (680)
27 Mar 12
Why somebody has to change a religion for love? God exist in any religion so why anyone who loves each other can't just stick to what they believe? I see so many couples who stay forever even though they have different faith, so why bother to change? Convert to other religion is ok but not because of a human love but finding the truth he/she learn in their heart.
@Lhenni (1242)
• Philippines
29 Mar 12
Maybe my niece got some spiritual reasons why she opted that way...