My Son Talks in Third Person!

Valdosta, Georgia
July 29, 2012 3:42pm CST
My son constantly says things in third person. If he is thirsty, he will say Jackson is thirsty. Instead of saying I'm thirsty... My son is 4 years old by the way. Do you think it is just a stage he is going through? I don't want to dismiss it as that if there really is something wrong. Has anyone's children ever talked in third person for months on end? Did they out grow it? It may be small to people but he's my son so to me it seems like a big deal...I haven't noticed anything else different about him except his clinging to me around anyone new a LOT and being very anti social. Any ideas on this one??
10 people like this
18 responses
@thezone (9394)
• Ireland
29 Jul 12
"Hulk Smash"
3 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
29 Jul 12
3 people like this
@thezone (9394)
• Ireland
29 Jul 12
Cheers I was hoping you would get it
2 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
29 Jul 12
I did, thanks for making me smile!
3 people like this
@Sandra1952 (6047)
• Spain
29 Jul 12
All my three children went through this phase at around the same age. I asked my doctor about it, and she said it's just the normal process of experimenting with language and trying out different sounds and expressions. By the time he goes to school, he'll probably have grown out of it. If not, as his vocabulary increases, it will gradually fizzle out.
• Valdosta, Georgia
29 Jul 12
My oldest daughter never did this so I didn't know if it was normal and I did not want to dismiss it if it was something more serious. Thank you, I feel better! =) He has too much vocabulary for a 4 year old already, maybe he heard that from somewhere and is copying it. He does that a LOT. Picks up on too much and repeats it.
3 people like this
@GardenGerty (157551)
• United States
29 Jul 12
I believe it is just the age he is. My kids did not do this, but I have heard it and seen it before. If you are concerned you may mention it when he goes to preschool or kindergarten. It is kind of like kids saying "him" for "he". Another thing he may do at this age is call you and your hubby by first names or if he writes he may experiment with writing certain letters or whole words backwards. If it really bothers you you may tell him " Oh you are telling me 'I am thirsty'," but I do not think I would at this age.
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
Okay good. My daughter never did it either which is why it kind of worried me. Then like an idiot I was looking up what it could mean and that worried me more! Hopefully he will just stop. He has never called my husband and I by our first names, thank goodness! My husband would definitely not go for that.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
29 Jul 12
you can ask your doctor but I think it is just a phase he is going through.
3 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
29 Jul 12
Were waiting for Medicaid to go through so I can't ask his doctor right now. Hopefully it is just a phase though.
3 people like this
@AmbiePam (85484)
• United States
30 Jul 12
Maybe he just picked it up somewhere, like on television. I see athletes talk like that all the time. It's just a phase I bet, and I wouldn't be concerned. Think of it as one of his quirky attributes you'll embarrass him with when he gets older and has a girlfriend.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
2 Aug 12
What I did not know that my mother told me the other day is my nephew is doing it too so one of them probably heard the other one doing it so they copied it. Lol. Yeah hopefully it will pass very soon!
1 person likes this
@suzzy3 (8342)
29 Jul 12
Like you say he is only four,I bet at school a teacher says does maurice want a drink or Jackon need a pencil he is just repeating what he has heard.He is shy and wants attention,Explain to him you love him and ask him to speak properly ,just explain it is not Jackson is thirsty as you will not answer him.Tell him to start a request with "please can I have." He should soon realise he gets no notice of him untill he says the proper words.Give him loads of cuddles.He is a bit insecure thats all.
2 people like this
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
Well, he does not go to school yet. He is still home with me and my husband. He picks up many things though from TV and other kids. I babysit a lot so he might have even heard it from another child. Yeah I am just hoping it is a phase and he will get over it...
@Jshean20 (14349)
• Canada
30 Jul 12
I don't have kids of my own but I do have neices and nephews and two of them talked in third person at this age as well and they did not end up with any developmental issues at all or anything of that sort. The anti social part is probably just a phase as well but if that starts to occur around people that he knows, I would get that looked into and that's coming from personal experience ( I have an anxiety disorder and depression). Good job for being a concerned mama though! Take care.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
2 Aug 12
Yeah, my son is the only one of my kids that have done this! It was very new and strange to me. I have seen other children do it but when its your own it causes some concern of course. Thank you! =)
@ElicBxn (63235)
• United States
29 Jul 12
I do think you might need to talk to a doctor about this, at least do some searching online
@ElicBxn (63235)
• United States
30 Jul 12
You are a very attentive mother - good for you!
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
I did research it and I did not like what I found. The next time he goes to the doctor if he is still doing it I will talk to his doctor about it.
1 person likes this
@choybel (5042)
• Philippines
30 Jul 12
At first I thought I never personally knew a child in my life that went through the same but then I remembered my niece went through the same thing at probably the same age, so I guess it's really just a phase.
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
Okay good. That is what I am hoping for. He likes attention so he might just be trying to get attention! I hope it passes soon because it is getting on my nerves. Lol.
@Hatley (163781)
• Garden Grove, California
29 Jul 12
hi LovingMyBabies as hes only 4 I think its probably just a phase. My little daughter when she was just a toddler did that too but again she was brain damaged at birth so please do not think for one moment I am suggesting that with your son at all. my little girl would cry out"Pick baby up 'sometimes it was "Pick Lisa up mommy. Lisa wants a drink. She was born not breathing and the doctor refused to rescue her by C section so it took a half hour to get her to breathe. she consequently could not suck or nurse but I fed her formula with a spoon until she learned to drink from a cup. Your son is an entirely different situation.I would really not worry about it for awhile as he will probably change in time but if you really are concerned you might talk to your pediatrician about it.I really would just wait as I think its just a stagewhen I was little I was like that too and the adults would go around saying "she so bashful, shes so shy." I got the idea bashful meant I was really weird. to this day I am not comfortable in large crowds. I think some children just are not outgoing by nature and thats the way they will be as adults which is okay to me. I mean life would be really boring if we all were just the same.Shy adults are not necessarily a bad thing,I think its better than in your face adults who make people back off. lol lol lol
• Valdosta, Georgia
2 Aug 12
Yeah I think it is just a phase too. I should never have looked into it so much because it scared me when I did. No I know your not suggesting that Hatley. I wish the doctors did the right thing for her and you and your husband. It makes me so sad. If they just did a better job...I'm sorry. Yeah he is the kind of child that likes the attention so I am thinking that has something to do with it too. I agree, shy is better than being so outspoken you drive people away. The only bad thing with shy is its harder to make friends. I am shy and I have always had a hard time making friends.
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
30 Jul 12
my son talks that way too..my 2 year old that is.. and i guess it is just a phase as i could also remember my other son going through this. he would say JJ wants water.. or JJ likes to watch Spongebob
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
Ugh, it is getting on my nerves! My oldest never went through this stage at all. My youngest has not gone through it yet either. He knows how to say it correctly, he thinks it is so funny every time he does it. I hope he stops soon!
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
31 Jul 12
since he think its funny, therefore he is aware of it..and eventually will stop.
@ally12 (1202)
• Philippines
30 Jul 12
May I ask who is jackson? Is jackson his brother or just an imaginary friend? Coz my daughter was also like this when shes about two or three year old..She would use other names even name of dogs to express what she really wanted to tell you. Like one time, she was kissing and hugging me while I was sleeping on bed then when I woke up i kissed her too and hugged her, then she suddenly said,"you know mommy Frudo is bad smell" and she turned her head away from me. or sometimes instead of saying "I like this" she will say " Laira like this" and she even speaks with an imaginary friends, some are real people some we dont know who. At first I dont know what to feel, should I be frightened or feel funny about it? But i think all these are just part of child's growing up stage but of course we as parent should be on guard and knows when to intervene and how to correct them. Babies or young child are just starting to build or know their identity, starting to learn communicating. I would say its their learning process so just correct him everytime and explain how he suppose to say what he said. Another point to consider is kids are a great imitator. maybe you also speak such way to him like " Mommy will change your nappy.. " they imitate us because they thought its the right way. But for you to aid your worries better see his pediatrician and ask his advise.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
2 Aug 12
My son's name is Jackson. He is talking about himself. Lol. He has never had an imaginary friend, none of my children have actually. I am surprised that none of them ever had one. I think my son is just going through another phase of his. Lol. He likes attention and I think that is why he is doing it. I have been correcting him and he is not doing it as often so thats good!
@sender621 (14894)
• United States
30 Jul 12
It is not unusual for a young child to go through describing themselves in the third person. it is a way of acting things out that they may be uncomfortable with. It will come to an end when something else comes along to replace the stimulation of the acting out.
@911Ricki (13588)
• Canada
30 Jul 12
It could very well be a stage, does he go to school or preschool? I know many kids who dont they tend to have these type of behaviours. I always compare myself to my siblings to these things. My two brothers never went to preschool, no activities, nothing, then my sister and I went to preschool, and a bunch of social acitivities dancing, skating, swimming so on. When my two brothers were younger (mind you they have an age gap one is now 30, and the other is 17) both have these exact behaviours the really person they only spent time with was my mother, to this day you can tell by their personality and behaviour the lack of social contact, behaviour they are very selfish, and sharing is down the drain , also work habits (not that they are I mean selfish badly, just little things it picks up). Whereas my sister and I were taught to go to these activities, taught to share not with each other but other kids, and so on. We have the most work ethics, and you share or compromise. I dont have kids, but this is my view on not just my family but those around me many with these traits at a young age, end up being worse as adults. But you can fix it now, with the anti social clingy type behaviour bring him to say the park, or preschool for a day or two over time he will loose these traits. In a college course I learnt many kids have these behaviours, but you need to break the habit before it goes any further. The third person I believe is a phase I know many friends kids who did it as well, just correct him.
1 person likes this
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
I am hoping it is a stage. He does not go to school yet, I have many kids here every day that I babysit for though. I was thinking maybe he picked it up from one of them or something. My son is very social with kids because of the children I watch all the time. They are around many other children every day. He is just so super shy around new adults and clingy when they are around! He is fine with the other children though. Yeah I think it is just a phase too. Hopefully it will pass soon because it is getting on my nerves! Lol.
1 person likes this
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
29 Jul 12
That seems a bit unusual but I have heard it before....because someone addressed the child that way...if you haven't done that it might be just a phase.....
• Valdosta, Georgia
30 Jul 12
It is unusual which is why it worried me but he is the kind of kid to always want attention. It could be an attention getter. He does some things that just blow my mind just to get some kind of attention. I am hoping he will just stop and it will be done with.
@shaggin (71664)
• United States
30 Jul 12
Aww when little kids do that I think it is so cute. Neither of my kids do that but my friends son who is 4 and a few months younger then my son talks in third person. Hes done it for quite a few months at least. It probably is just a stage. He has always been very clingy to his mother. He plays well with other kids now but was very scared to ever let go of his mothers hand up until about a year ago.
• United States
31 Jul 12
I suggest that with the 3rd person talking I would rephrase things when he says it. So like when he says he is thirsty respond with "are you thirsty" or "ok its good that your thirsty" He will hear you saying this about him but not using his name so he may start doing it too. I would just keep track of when he does it and maybe there is another reason he does this. Does he do it more in new areas? If he is anti-social start getting him out more and around more kids,show him that it is ok to be friendly and try new things. I think that this could all be a phase but to be safe just keep a little journal of when he does these things with details then this way if it doesn't stop you have something to go off of with a doctor.
@inertia4 (27961)
• United States
27 Aug 12
I have never encountered this with my kids when they were small. They would say I'm thirsty. Maybe you should ask your doctor about this and see if it is something that kids do. It might be, just because my kids didn't do it doesn't mean it does not happen. Or ask a child therapist. I don't personally think you have anything to worry about. Maybe he picked it up from a cartoon on TV or something.