What will be your answer if your 12years old daughter ask you this?

@cttolledo (5460)
Legaspi, Philippines
April 11, 2013 8:41am CST
Hi mylotters! Just wanna hear the opinion of parents out there specially those daddys... I am single, not aware about kid's issue but my friend confide me that her daughter is now in the moment of asking questions about love, and according to my friend last night her daughter asked her if it is okey if she can have a boyfriend..my friend was shocked and speechless, instead of answering the question, she opt to divert the attention of her daughter to other topic because according to her she wasn't ready to answer her daughter with that type of topic and she is thinking what to feel by her daughter if she said no... My friend had this problem now since she obviously doesn't want her daughter to have a boyfriend with that age. What if your daughter ask you with the same question, what would be your answer?
6 people like this
19 responses
@rsa101 (37932)
• Philippines
12 Apr 13
Well I do think that when your daughter starts asking like that you should be frank and should answer it. If I were the mother I would just say that she is still too young and should focus on studies first. Maybe she could entertain the suitor but with limitation of not going beyond being bf-gf. If the parent would avoid answering it then the daughter can construe it as either they are tolerating it or she may just go underground and pursue what she wants since her parents is not answering her queries. Just do not be harsh and be as normal as you can be in answering it so that your daughter would not be rattled and be afraid of asking it again. Trust should be establish at all times so that your daughter will not keep secrets from you. Keeping secrets can be equally dangerous if that happens since you will be blinded what is happening with her so you should be as friendly and open as you can with it.
2 people like this
@rsa101 (37932)
• Philippines
12 Apr 13
Yeah you answer what is being asked only no need to be detailed about it and just wait for it to be asked. Trust between your daughter should be established. If the conversation need to be light and casual, then do it. I think you do not need to be afraid since her daughter is in that stage where this things do happen and it is important that her parent's guidance is provided at this point in time.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
As srisahara said in his comment ( please see above).. you can discuss about love in a bit, and no need to go on the details.. Thanks for sharing!
2 people like this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Yeah!..explanation should limit on the level of understanding of the daughter...
1 person likes this
@rog0322 (2829)
• Cagayan De Oro, Philippines
11 Apr 13
Hi, I think it would be a good time to tell her about the real issue about boy-girl relationship. Ask her what it means to have a boyfriend, what she shall do with it, let her explain everything about it. It would be mighty interesting to know her thoughts about it and correcting her whenever possible to put her in the right track. It would not be good to start off on a wrong foot, so to speak. She is about to embark on a journey that could make or ruin her future if left unattended.
2 people like this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
11 Apr 13
Correct! i told my friend to explain to her very well what's the meaning of her question about boyfriend..let her understand that falling inlove is a responsibility not a simple job to do...but i think my friend find hard time dealing this kind of issue..
1 person likes this
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
12 Apr 13
12 years old is such a tender age to be in love. Crushes are normal. But to let a girl at her age to be in love might not have a good effect on her most especially that she is vulnerable. I think, that instead of trying to avoid the subject, your friend should talk to her daughter and explain to her that falling in love is normal but at her age, it should wait. There are a lot of things that she needs to enjoy and explore. Love, at a proper time will be a lot beautiful for her.
1 person likes this
@jenny1015 (13366)
• Philippines
13 Apr 13
I can understand what you mean, sid556. Our daughter might listen to whatever we tell them and believe us, but there is also a fear of being influenced by friends. You know how kids are these days. When they put they are all together, they seem to have these toughness in them that everything they can possibly do without fear. And I guess is, we just need to have a very good relationship with our daughters and keep an open communication about everything.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
15 Apr 13
Yeah.. must have open and close relationship.
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Thanks jenny.. I realized that raising a kids it's not a joke!
1 person likes this
@roshigo58 (4859)
• Pune, India
12 Apr 13
Hi, It is very strange that your friend's daughter has boyfriend at the age of only 12. It must be very shocking to your friend. The daughter is also very bold and she didn't hesitate while asking this bold question. She doesn't feel anything wrong she is doing. But if I were in your friend's shoes I would not allow my daughter to keep contact with her boyfriend. I would have been told that it is not the right age. You have to concentrate on your career and not on anything else. I don't have any daughter. I have only son.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Hi rosshigo! Actually her daughter has no boyfriend yet, that's why my friend was so shocked when her daughter asked her that kind of question, she just can't imagine that her daughter who treated by her like a baby asked her with such question...she's upset because that question are unexpected.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
15 Apr 13
Hi sid! First of all thank you so much for active participation in my discussion and I'm glad that you have shared you own point of view with this topic. Actually, I do respect your opinion regarding this one.. It's natural to hear different responses and reaction with this because we came from different country with different cultures and beliefs,and I 'm happy because I'm learning other cultures..!Happy mylotting Sid!
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
11 Apr 13
I understand that. I have been told a girl that age will be interested in boys. id say get teacher or counselor at school to help with this. They are also trained in this kind of stuff.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Yeah.. parents should communicate with the teacher to closely monitor her daughter when she is in school.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Yesr maria.. teachers are good in reading behaviors of the students.
1 person likes this
• Mexico
12 Apr 13
Sometimes teachers know them as well as parents do.
1 person likes this
@ayeeesha (1127)
• Philippines
11 Apr 13
Refusing to talk about won't help. The kid will still ask questions about that. For me, the best way is to address the question and answer upfront and at te same time, explain to her the consequences, especially since she's too young. Chances are, she doesn't fully understand anything yet so better talk to her properly and answer and explain what needs to be answered.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Her silence about the issue might create assumption on the part of her daughter that her mother is okey about boyfriend issue.So better to talk bout it as early as this time to compromise everything.
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
She has no other option but to deal with it.. my friend cannot divert topics like that all the time!
@ayeeesha (1127)
• Philippines
12 Apr 13
That's true. There's no point of avoiding the topic since she's going there anyway. That's why as much as possible, address the issue and talk to her and explain her the consequences, otherwise she might do something behind her parents' back that she might regret.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
12 Apr 13
For most girls at that age, having a boyfriend is very innocent. I would and did say yes to my girls on this. They, of course, had restrictions. They did not go out alone on dates or anything that an older teen would. The boy would come to our place for dinner and they'd listen to music, watch tv etc. They are not long term relationships nor are they meant to be. The thing is that by ignoring the daughter's questions, that mother is losing a perfect opportunity to have an important talk with her daughter. She is possibly building a wall between her and her daughter that she is not aware of. The daughter will sense that her mother is awkward to talk about such things and may not bother asking next time.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
15 Apr 13
And so will your Cttolledo. I understand that different cultures have very different beliefs and while I may not agree with them, I do respect them and while I have some very strong convictions, I am always open to being wrong.
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Really? are you sure your wife allows your daughter to have a b-friend at age 12? LOL.. As I'v read the above responses, most of them specially those mothers answered "NO" and "YES"( upon reaching the right age).. so I'm thinking if your wife have the same opinion as yours...
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
15 Apr 13
Hi Sid and Hatley! You both have a point but again there are people around here who are conservative and has different culture as yours.. So, Your ideas maybe acceptable or not to us, depending on our culture and beliefs..but your opinion will surely be respected.
@jazel_juan (15747)
• Philippines
12 Apr 13
I have an 8 year old daughter and lately i know she know what a crush is..but quite honestly i do tell her it is ok to have a crush, it is ok to have a boyfriend if the right time comes. BUT i do stress out that she MUST tell me. For quite honestly it is ok for her to go through all that, given she must be honest. i would rather have her be honest with me and have a bf than have a bf and do it behind my back.. as for her, she could answer her daughter truthfully.. and not turn away from her.. if i was your friend i would say that she could at the right time and age.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Yeah.. Maybe that's the best answer to her daughter' question.
@lelin1123 (15595)
• Puerto Rico
11 Apr 13
This is very simple. I would say "Sweetheart you are way to young to have a boyfriend." "You need to concentrate on school and being a kid. Boys are not necessary at this time of your life." You have time for boys when you are alot older like seventeen or eighteen" that "Having a boyfriend at this age will just get you in trouble." I didn't have a boyfriend till I was nineteen close to twenty. I don't understand the kids of today wanting boyfriend so young. It's really digusting to me.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
12 Apr 13
Maybe it is the culture difference. I had a boyfriend when I was 13 and that was back in the late 60s. Most girls here do start really dating around 15 or 16. Way back in my great grandmother's day, girls got married and had children by 15 or 16 (some younger). Technically, our kids should be ready to be on their own at 18. So many parents shelter their children and try to keep them like children right up until they are almost 18 and then wonder why they falter and stumble as adults. We are the only species that has 18 long years to raise up our young and so many parents spend a good portion of those 18 yrs just protecting and trying to keep them from learning what they need to know as adults.
2 people like this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
15 Apr 13
I agree. We have different culture here in Philippines when it comes to marriage. 26 up is the marrying age here..Parents are still responsible to their kids up to they graduate in college and some parents still doing it even if their child has their own family already.. Filipinos has this family ties that other countries don't have...
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
I'm thinking that too.. kid's today are different.. they are too aggressive, they wanted to do what adults are doing.. scary on the part of the parents.. i think parents should double time in monitoring their kids and always communicate with them to know what's in their mind...
1 person likes this
@Dominique25 (9464)
• United States
11 Apr 13
My answer would be no. And I would really sit down with her and have a heart to heart conversation about her feelings and at the same time her age and maturity. For me when a person starts to court they should be in a position to take on family responsibilities and have a marriage. So I would talk with my daughter about those things and help her to see that there is more involved in a relationship than just being in love and happy, and cheery. It's good for children to know where we stand on issues and why.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
I think No parents will obviously allow their 12 years old daughter to have a boyfriend.Thanks for sharing
1 person likes this
@riempie9 (1021)
• South Africa
12 Apr 13
If the mother cannot answer the questions herself, she must either speak to a therapist and get advice or a family member who is close and can give good advice. Sons and daughters who are in the midst of a torrid relationship however may not want to hear it. These are important questions for teenagers. The choices they make now will decide the route they take. Please, mothers, don't take this lightly. Even Judge Mathis gives second chances. Speak to a knowledgeable person and make a decision that will benefit your child.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
I think my friend can still handle it, its just that she was quiet shocked and in the process of composing how to deliver her answer to her daughter without so much complications...well my friend are not used to it.. she's her only child...
1 person likes this
11 Apr 13
too young to get exposed my niece once asked me the same thing before when she was so young and many suitors since she's a very gorgeous sweet sweet girl, I just told "your too young to be in a relationship there are lot of things to enjoy that won't last that long and there's a lot of time for having such relationships. Even sometimes we feel that it is time it won't help us to grow more and there is a right time for that, after doing your obligation to finish your studies and earn your degree and for sure the best things in life will comes next. Everything will come hand in hand you just have to be patient to get the best for you" and it did worked
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
11 Apr 13
I agree. 12 yrs old is young for having commitments..
1 person likes this
@srisahara (4508)
• Indonesia
12 Apr 13
If I have a daughter on 12 years old, I will give a bit explanation about love for her. But I will limit our explanation based on her knowledge. She still too young to understand about love, but if we do not answer her question, she will looking for from other sources that maybe dangerous for her. I think, 12 years is enough to understand a bit of love.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
you are right srisahara! Explanation should limit to or based on the child's level of understanding about love.. So a bit information about love is okey just to satisfy her curiosity about love.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
11 Apr 13
say yes but only if she's on the right age. just explain that at her age she cant handle a relationship yet. tell also that she needs to focus more on studies than any other.
1 person likes this
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
I like it.. that would be a good and very positive way of answering her daughter's question.
1 person likes this
@jaiho2009 (39142)
• Philippines
11 Apr 13
Twelve years old is too young for that kind of relationship, but good enough to discuss with sensitive subject like this. I prefer to answer my daughter that, she is too young to have a boyfriend- girlfriend relationship. I will try to explain to her the consequences- in a manner not to hurt her feelings, but to make her understand that she might consider enjoying her child life instead of getting into any serious relationship. It won't be an easy task- and I am sure it will take time to make my daughter understand my point.
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
I realized that raising a teenager is not an easy job on the part of the parents..Thanks for sharing!
• India
14 Apr 13
Hi friend, i wonder why your friend changed the topic? we must give our answer straight forward to such kind of questions. As her daughter is asking question to her, which means she is asking permission to her mum to have a BF. Your friend must explain the pros and cons in having a boy friend and she is not in the proper age to have a boy friend. It will help her daughter to know about her mother's attitude. If my son ask this question to me, i will give my straight answer to him
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
15 Apr 13
hi vid! Because she wasn't ready to answer it.. and the question just a come unexpectedly .. but my friend had talk with her daughter already about it...Thanks to your response!
@kokomo (1867)
• Philippines
1 May 13
Well, I think she was too young to be in love and I guess if I were in her mother's shoe, I would explain to her little by little that she is not yet at the proper age to be in love and it was only for ladies and adults. I'll tell her in the most detailed way that love is so complicated and she needs to learn more about love so that she will not be hurt because love sometimes is so painful.
• India
11 Apr 13
She should not have diverted the attention of her daughter instead should have explained her atleast in a simple way. Refusing to talk on that topic is not an option this will create more curiosity in her mind. She can take any step to know these things so its better to explain it
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
According to my friend, she will talk her daughter about it, but she's just taking it slow and thinking of the best way not to hurt her daughter's feeling .
• India
11 Apr 13
very simple i will explain to the child that this is not the age to indulge in such activities. and will tell the child that he is not physically or mentally mature to indulge in such act and that he can love any one after he becomes old. after all the child might be asking due to lack of awareness about what love actually means. if we explain to the child then he will surely understand.
@cttolledo (5460)
• Legaspi, Philippines
12 Apr 13
Correct too young for boyfriend thing.. yeah let's hope that she will understand her mother .