Have you tried the in shower lotions/moisturizer something like that? I did just now and felt too oily. I washed it off fast after that. God for bid that get under my foot. I would fall down busting open my head.
I never new shower lotions were a thing...that would be my mom's new addiction, she loves lotions. That is odd that it made you oily though, perhaps there are other shower lotions that won't make it happen.