Should clothes in larger sizes cost more?
November 23, 2017 5:43am CST
Every now and then this subject hits the headlines and retailers are accused of ‘sizism’ and discrimination against fat people. So should clothes for larger people be more expensive? If so how would this work – would each size larger be slightly more expensive than the next one down, or should there be a sort of banding of sizes? Or should all clothes of the same style be the same price? Presumably for this to work the price of the smaller ones must include a premium to subsidize the larger sizes, since larger clothes obviously require more materials to make. Anyone who has ever sewn or knitted knows that you need more fabric, thread or yarn to make a larger garment. As far as I know, no-one yet has complained that they shouldn’t have to pay extra for a couple more balls of wool or metres of fabric than would be needed by a smaller person. Having said that I have never noticed different prices on the same garment in different sizes. Have you noticed different prices? Should all sizes be the same price? All rights reserved. © Text and image copyright Fleur 2017.
17 people like this
• Olney, Illinois
I have seen many times where a 2xx or 3xx t-shirt will cost more than smaller sizes. I accept that, since it does take more material to make them. Normally, I see blue jeans priced the same regardless of size, but I'd never really thought about it.
• United States
I see prices that are $2 more for plus sizes. However, when they go to extreme pricing and the cost is nearly double, I shake my head and try to find a more reasonably priced item. Often times you'll find clothing in a catalog that are double the price of what you'd pay in a store. That is ridiculous!
• Preston, England
yes sizes should be of an even price. True, extra large costs more than medium size but that is balanced out by smaller sizes with some people being below average height and weight too - extra charges for being overweight amounts to literally being a fat tax for many many clothes are actually machine cut rather than hand tailored, sewn, knitted or crocheted
• United Kingdom
It does seem a bit odd if clothes are the same price when the very large ones can be literally twice the size of small ones, but as others have pointed out the cost of the materials is only a small part of the cost to the retailer. And if that was the case then baby clothes should be really cheap, which of course they are not. I have mixed feelings on this really. Shoes for example are the same price for all sizes. On the other hand if you make your own clothes you pay more if you need more fabric.
Many years ago, when I lived in France, you paid different prices according the size of the clothes. I still remember there were 3 different prices. Later it was said it was a discrimination toward the obese people, so they discriminated the thin people making them pay more and make all the prices the same. Who gained in this discrimination game? Surely not the customers.
• United Kingdom
Here I thought it was usual for all of one style to be the same price no matter what size, but I have read about places charging more for large sizes. As has been pointed out, for a bulk order from a retailer the cost of the fabric is only a small part, so maybe it makes little difference. What about shoes, they are usually the same price for all sizes, aren't they?
@Fleura Shoes are the same price and it has always been the case. Fabric anyway makes the difference, my mother was a seamstress and I remember she explained me from which size you have to waste a lot more fabric. For shoes is finally a matter of only a few cm., but a dress for an obese woman takes the double of fabric than a dress for a thin woman. My sister in law was obese and I could have easily made two dresses for me from one of hers.
First of all, I want to comment on what you tagged in your post. Being fat or overweight isn't body shaming. We have to realize that we are created perfectly in the image of God and that we are all beautiful no matter what size we have and that being sexy and beautiful does not count on the outside but on the inside. As for your question, I don't think shirt who does have different sizes differ in prices too. I love shopping clothes and so far I have never encountered to see any shirts who differ in sizes differs in its prices too. :)
• United Kingdom
Thank you for your comment. I agree that beauty is within; I put those tags because I have read about people complaining that they were being 'body shamed' by being charged more for larger clothes. Personally I have never noticed this - but then I rarely shop for clothes anyway.