Book or Movie version?

@tech40 (23128)
Philippines
March 23, 2018 11:22pm CST
These past movies, most of those stories were created from Comics or books and, each of those has their own scenario, there are so many cut scene's on movie version unlike to book, but which do you prefer? The movie, Comics, or Book?
2 people like this
6 responses
Jessa Bumagat
@Jessabuma (31700)
• Baguio, Philippines
24 Mar 18
I would prefer book because it is a complete version unlike on movies.
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
I agree! There are times I feel sad because there are part or scene that I read but I never see on the movie
1 person likes this
Jessa Bumagat
@Jessabuma (31700)
• Baguio, Philippines
24 Mar 18
@tech40 yes that is why, I prefer book than movie
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
@Jessabuma But if you're giving a chance to direct a book into a movie, are you going to include everything in the book? or you'll summarize it?
1 person likes this
Michelle
@infatuatedbby (95001)
• United States
24 Mar 18
Honestly I do not like to read, so I'd rather watch the movie version.
1 person likes this
Michelle
@infatuatedbby (95001)
• United States
25 Mar 18
@tech40 No no books for me. :) Movies is the easier route for me. :P
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
25 Mar 18
@infatuatedbby I feel the effects in movies than books hehe but my imagination works wider in reading books
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
I'm a fan of reading books before, but since I've been busy working, I prefer watching movies now.
1 person likes this
Tina Dalasinski
@Tina30219 (81540)
• Onaway, Michigan
24 Mar 18
It don’t matter to me some are different. The movie can be different than the book and vice versa.
1 person likes this
Tina Dalasinski
@Tina30219 (81540)
• Onaway, Michigan
26 Mar 18
@tech40 Right
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
25 Mar 18
Well yeah, but the source will remains original hehe
Your Highness Emperor Albert Whisker
@CaptAlbertWhisker (32507)
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Mar 18
Comic book movies usually insults the material to make it digestible to casuals. in case of novels, I prefer television adaptations as they are more accurate to source material.
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
I can relate, and I also agree, Television is nearer to facts than movies.
Your Highness Emperor Albert Whisker
@CaptAlbertWhisker (32507)
• Calgary, Alberta
24 Mar 18
@tech40 You just cant summarize 20 hours of a book to a 1 hour movie.
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
@CaptAlbertWhisker I got the point, probably those are the reason why there are a lot of cutscenes.
The Horse
@TheHorse (205752)
• Walnut Creek, California
24 Mar 18
I dn't usually watch comic boo movies. Let's see. Catch 22. The movie was good. The book was better. The Kite Runner. The movie was good. The book was better. The French Lieutenant's Woman. The movie was good. But the book was better. Dr. Strangelove. The movie was great. Was there a book?
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
20 Apr 18
Yeah, books are more detailed then movies, some movies used the book as a referenced in their movies, but not all good movies come from books
Honey143
@sw8sincere (5204)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
I prefer movies. I get tired of reading. hehe
1 person likes this
Jandie
@tech40 (23128)
• Philippines
24 Mar 18
I also agree, We're busy doing our job for the whole day,
1 person likes this