Eragon the movie ,, IS it what u wanted ..

@keedap (304)
India
January 8, 2007 12:35am CST
I just saw the movie and i was really disappointed ,, The way story has been twisted ... the roles of brom and Murtagh have been cut short a lot . The trip to Thierm has been removed .. . waht do u think
1 person likes this
7 responses
@ugachaka (297)
• United States
9 Jan 07
As long as you don't compair the movie to the book it was a decent movie. I would still take the book over the movie anyday.
1 person likes this
@ikinta (1238)
• Indonesia
19 Jan 07
I think they dont have the budget like LOTR. At first I thought the movie will be something like LOTR. I was dissapointed too..
@juicemilk (2286)
• Australia
15 Jan 07
I liked the movie, obviuosly no where as good as the book, but I still enjoyed it. I didn't like the girl who played Arya though, you couldn't even tell she was an elf. My boyfriend came with me to see it and now he'st hinking about reading the books. So I think it would be better to see the movie before reading the books to avoid disappointment. Will be interesting to see if they make the next book into a movie as well...does anyone know if they have plans to do that?
• United States
14 Jan 07
the movie was very badly done. Even the author of Eragon said that on the Eragon fan site (that part was later removed, i think like 12 hours after it was put up). I never knew that the horned urgals didn't have horns, that brom and Murtagh played such short roles, etc etc etc, i can go on for a while.
• United States
10 Jan 07
My hubby and I both read the book and then went to see the move a couple of weeks later and we both where very dissapointed with the movie. It's not just completely different then the book but it also seemed cheaply made. Also I don't understand why they couldn't even do small things from the book, like the collor of the horses and haircollors and the Aria in the movie does not match the description in the book at all. Anyway great book bad movie.
@Ariana17 (92)
• United States
10 Jan 07
I'm going to have to agree with ugachaka there...and if you think of it in terms of "lord of the rings" no other fantasy movie will measure up. you can't compare every sci-fi movie to "Star Wars"
@natuser28 (907)
• United States
9 Jan 07
A poor man's "Lord of the Rings"