Social Promotion: Yes or no???

@82idiots (595)
United States
January 20, 2007 2:59pm CST
Social promotion is when public schools pass failing students to the next grade level just because they are falling too far behind from their peers. Do you agree with this practice? Is it wise to promote a kid just because he or she is getting older? Would it be wiser to drop students from school who fail more than 3 times maybe? What are your thoughts on this?
1 person likes this
4 responses
@sunshinecup (7871)
20 Jan 07
Grade retention as been proven over the years NOT to work than work. When you keep a child behind from their peers, they tend to shut down and the result are not positive. Social promotion is a good idea not being properly used. The idea is to promote the child, but target the problem and find a solution as well. For instance, a child at one time could have been retained due to very low reading levels. Now they must be promoted. The problem is schools are doing just that, and not addressing the reading problem it's self. Many States in this country refuse to acknowledge the existence of Dyslexia, a very common reading disorder. By not addressing, the problem children who are dyslexic will never be able to over come their disadvantage. So when used properly yes social promotion is a very good idea. However once again, public schools are half _ssing it and not doing the rest of the work required to help the children.
1 person likes this
@82idiots (595)
• United States
20 Jan 07
agreed. The frustration and feeling of failure alone is what keeps motivating them to failure.
@mikaghi (388)
• United States
20 Jan 07
i don't agree with social promotion.also student should not be dropped just coz he/she is failing too much. we should try to find reasons for their failure and help them to succeed.
1 person likes this
@sunita64 (6469)
• India
3 Mar 07
Somehow marking students on the basis of answer they have given has many loopholes and result in many school dropouts so I feel this social promotion is fine.
@masca11 (320)
• Romania
21 Jan 07
I don't know how is in your country but in romania if you fail to pass 3 times your out . That means your not capeble to understand so your send to a special school who deals whit special kids. You don't have a chanse to get old in the second grade is to embarising.