American Idol- When all of the Judges are saying no,what makes these people thin

@catherIN (430)
United States
January 30, 2007 7:10pm CST
When all of the judges are saying a clear no, you can not sing.Why on Earth do these people try singing again? What makes them think they are going to change their minds? All three said no, get the point. geesh
2 responses
• United States
31 Jan 07
So true. But I guess when you've been waiting in line for that long only to be told "no" I can see how it would feel like a huge waste of time. Still, it makes them seem way too desperate. They should just leave with their dignity still in tact.
1 person likes this
@catherIN (430)
• United States
31 Jan 07
Maybe that is part of it. Some of those people look like they really think they can changed the judges minds.I understand when one is saying yes and one has said no.Of course, I say more power to them, try to convince that third judge.But when all three say no, absolutely not. Hang it up. It isn't going to happen.They just end up making fools of theirself at that point.
@lpetges (3036)
• United States
31 Jan 07
i think they should already have gone through the first auditions, and let us see some talent. like on Nashville star-they have already made their picks to the last 10 or something. I don't really watch the idol unless it is near the end. i cant stand to see people being made fun of.
• Canada
31 Jan 07
I dont know wat makes them think they can sing but at least they try, but after tryin so much, i think you have to give it a rest sometime.
1 person likes this