Did the right person win Top Chef?

@Fishmomma (11464)
United States
February 1, 2007 2:23am CST
I wanted to know, if you felt Ilan should have won Top Chef this season or should Marcel have won for taking a chance with new dishes? I felt Ilan should have won, as he didn't blame others for mistakes made with the dishes or the food that was left behind.
2 responses
@inked4life (4228)
• United States
2 Feb 07
I really thought that Sam and Ilan would have gone to the final, but am just glad that Marcel didn't win...what a pompous,arrogant little a$$ he is...and what is with that hair? They should have shaved it off when they had the chance...LOL
@Fishmomma (11464)
• United States
2 Feb 07
I thought it would be Sam and Ilan also. That would have been an interesting challenge, as selecting the right two people could have made a huge difference. I'm glad the last episode did not cause us to not see another season, as the show had already been picked up for another season.
@kabella50 (309)
• United States
1 Feb 07
I haven't seen the finale yet but I have recored it.I guess Marcel won and really,if the young french girl wasn't going to win I think Marcel should have won,just because he really understood what was expected of them during the whole competion.He knows what a chef does.He may have personality problems with others but that guy understands food.
@Fishmomma (11464)
• United States
2 Feb 07
Marcel didn't win, as Ilan was selected as the winner. I agree with your statement that he has personality problems, as he sure wasn't liked on the show. One of the biggest reasons he didn't win will be clear when you are able to see the show. Enjoy the show and I'm looking forward to next season. Thanks for the reply.