M.S.Dhoni or Dineh Karthik. Who is better? Justify.
By svdinesh
@svdinesh (220)
India
February 4, 2007 9:25pm CST
M.S.Dhoni, the sensation in the hearts of every cricket fan. With his incredible batting he has earned that.
Dinesh Karthik, the sort of player we are searching for.
Both do keeping well (satisfactory). But coming to the batting, no doubt Dhoni dominates Dinesh. But Dinesh has consistency where Dhoni lacks behind.
So, whom do you choose as INDIAN cricket team wicket-keeper?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@a_manick (879)
• India
5 Feb 07
Dinesh Karthik is a better wicket-keeper than Dhoni. So, Karthik should be given the gloves. Dhoni should be selected as a pure batsman and should bat at No. 3.
We need to do something special if India want to challenge teams like Australia. Dhoni at No. 3 should certainly provide that special addition to India. Think about it.
@nidhinrv (103)
• India
7 Feb 07
what is this man?board exam question paper or what?haha...justify...Do one thing put (8 marks) on the right side
@nanhegujral (4632)
• India
6 Feb 07
They both are good keeper as well as good batsmen. Dinesh has played few very good innings and have impressed everyone by his batting skill. But I think that Dhoni still has the positive point as he is a great attacking batsmen and is very active behind the wicket.
@parassiniprashob (479)
• India
5 Feb 07
i think mahendra singh dhoni is the best and better than dinesh karthik, becaus ehe has got the power to hit the bowler hardly and has got lots of stamina
@dramya (24)
• India
7 Feb 07
I like both of them. I donot watch cricket much. My brother is crazy about it. From his knowledge I can say that Dhoni is known for his blasting batting. Dinesh Karthik has shown his talent in the critical times recently.
So, what I feel is both of them must be in the team.
@yogeshreddy (194)
• India
6 Feb 07
yes dhoni is the powerful player in our indian cricket team.
he has stamped in our indian hearts,but karthik is also
good player , he is not better than dhoni , i think both can
do keeping well , but my choosing is dhoni our indian cricket team keeper.
