What do you think of "What Have You Done" by Within Temptation?

Philippines
February 14, 2007 4:52am CST
Seriously. I was quite disappointed with that. Their collaboration with that...whoever he is, ruined Sharon's voice, and the composition just...sorry for the word, sucks. It's redundant, very un-melodic. But I like "The Howling" though. :P
1 person likes this
7 responses
@di44ito (496)
• Bulgaria
12 Jul 12
I can`t agree with you. This is one of my favourite songs. I like this duet a lot.
@carradee (91)
• United States
24 Apr 07
It's a bit different, a development, but it's still the band. It's just a bit more metal than they usually get. It's not melodic because it's not supposed to be; it's describing something discordant. I happen to like how the music reflects the topic. I'm immensely fond of all the songs I've heard on the new album. Granted, "What Have You Done?" isn't my favorite, but I do believe it'll be a good transition for people in the US used to our common rock to come to appreciate the rest of WT's songs. We'll see how correct I am come July. -'Dee
9 Apr 07
The more I listen to it the more I like it to be honest and the album version is better than the radio/tv edit. I like The Howling and The Cross from the new album although im still not sure about it . . . I think I actually prefer The Silent Force as an album.
• United States
4 Apr 07
I love it infact I love the whole new album
@bogdyyyyy (380)
• Romania
1 Apr 07
Pretty good song but i dont like it very much . For me it looks like a normal song. And NIGHTWISH RULLZ.
@andben (1076)
• Italy
7 Mar 07
I don't agree with you. Sure, this isn't their best song and it's nothing new, but I like it. Try to listen to another time.
@Eisenherz (2911)
• Portugal
26 Feb 07
Woah...I didn't even noticed they're back with a release already! I'm going to have to search for this album, thanks for the reminder. Hoping to see them at some festivals as well this Summer.