any violent reactions about American Idol's top 24?

Philippines
February 16, 2007 12:01am CST
Personally, I can't get how the three judges chose the top 24. I mean, let's face it, there were lots of very good singers besides some in the top 24, and some of my bets during the auditions were cut! The last two people who were picked for the top 24, man, they were obviously not the best ones and were consistent bummers, but they surprisingly made it! Fortunately, Lakisha and the back-up singer made it.
2 people like this
9 responses
@jsgrand0 (246)
• United States
16 Feb 07
What happened to Ebony? She was the black girl that auditioned with the other 2 blonde carhops!? I missed when they showed hollywood week, but did they even show her?! Her audition was amazing. I also really liked Sanjya's sister. And what about the Sarah girl that sang "over the rainbow" with the LONG curly dark hair? I hate how they do that..they need to work on their editing. There are so many contestants that blow us away during their auditions and then we never see or hear from them again!
• Philippines
17 Feb 07
Yeah, i liked ebony too. She got cut off during the group singing.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
between sundance and tommy, tommy was way much better, sundance was their favorite so they had to choose sundance, ugh!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
Yeah. We'll see, sundance and antonella really has to prove that the judges were rigth in choosing them. All eyes are on them after that controversial decision of the judges.
1 person likes this
@sweetrala (1440)
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
I think Alaina Alexander, she wasnt that good.And the choices between Sundance and Tony,id pick Tony and Antonella Barba and the other girl, id pick the other one coz she is way much better than Antonella.I think they pick her coz she looks good,and that really sucks!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
Yeah. The last scenes on the latest episode totally sucked. But anyway, they have to prove themselves during the live performances.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Feb 07
I am so glad that the backup singer made the top 24. I still don't get how they decided on the last guy slot and the last girl slot. Tommy and the other girl who broke down deserved to make it to the top 24.
• Philippines
19 Feb 07
One thing I know, they're not a particularly memorable bunch. Usually, by the time the judges choose the top 24, I would already have my top 5 bets. Now.. I have three, and Lakisha's the only name I remember. *sighs*
1 person likes this
@forjosie (1548)
• Indonesia
19 Feb 07
I think is not only voices. may be there's something else that influenced the judged to choose them.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
i agree! it was a beauty contest!
• China
16 Feb 07
well any body can say anything but it still doesnt change the fact that they are the judges and are free to do whatever they chooses to do.
1 person likes this
@sunnypub (2131)
• United States
16 Feb 07
I totally agree with you. I ma not sure what they were thinking when they chose some of the people they chose. Of course we have to remember that we didn't get to see everything and the judges did, so maybe their decissions were based on stuff that only they saw. I think all but two of the people that I really liked got cut. I am just happy that we are on to the 24 and well on our way to the top 12. The auditions are nice but I really like when we get to start seeing the live competitions. At this point I don't think I even know enough of the people to make a prediction of who I think will win. I don't feel like we really got to know the people this year like past years. I feel they rushed the auditions and Hollywood week. I am glad that Lakisha made it too. I think she has a great voice.