Being Summoned For Jury Service?

Jury Service - jury service, being summoned to be on a jury.
February 25, 2007 6:08pm CST
I am always worried that I may be summoned for jury service. I don't know whether I would make a good juror or not, as from what I have witnessed, it usually comes down to how good the Prosecutor or Defense Lawyer is, if the evidence is not there right infront of you? I understand that Jurors are chosen at random from the electoral roll to serve on a jury and their job is to decide the outcome of a trial, but are we truly unbiased in our views? If you were summoned, would you be able to go into court open-minded and non judgemental and be able to make a rational decision?
13 people like this
28 responses
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
26 Feb 07
I have been summoned twice now, but never actually even got picked to be picked, I just sat in the jurors waitng area for 3 days each time, I was working in those days and it was nothing but a big bother, now that I am not working I wouldn't mind it...
26 Feb 07
I have known people this has happened to. What a waste of time!! Thanks for your response.
1 person likes this
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
26 Feb 07
I went through the jury selection process, that is I was one of the extra ones chosen in case one of the jury got sick. Luckily I was not chosen. I say that, because in Canada when they choose the jury, they have the accused sitting in a chair in the middle of the room so if he looks poor even though he killed someone, you are tempted to be all so sympathetic and vote for a lighter sentence or if he is a Native Canadian (Cree or Assinboine or Dakota Sioux, etc.) if you are prejudiced you are tempted to give a heavier vote or if you are full of guilt that you are a white person, you might excuse what he did. I wonder if that is the same way they choose juries in the States. I hope not because no one can be impartial when they see the accused. It is up to the prosecuting or defense attorney to question you without the accused present.
26 Feb 07
Wow, that is heavy. I suppose this is why the Lawyers have to be so good at their job, so that even if someone may have different views, the evidence will be so strong even they will have no choice but to agree. Thanks
@Ellecee (102)
• United States
26 Feb 07
I have been summoned. THREE times. After the last time the judge told me I shouldn't worry about being summoned for 5 years. I was only chosen once of those three times to serve-and I was chosen as an alternate. The worst thing about being an alternate was I had to still be there every day, but didn't get to participate at the end. Nice. If I had to do it again, I would, but I have problems with knowing that I could be a deciding factor in someone's life.
3 people like this
26 Feb 07
Thats what worries me. I was summoned once but I was not in the country, thank goodness. That was nearly 20 years ago and I hope they don't choose me again. To have to decide someones fate is definately a big responsibility. They say things run in three's so hopefully you won't be summoned again!!!! Thanks for your comments.
2 people like this
• Australia
26 Feb 07
An interesting discussion. No, I have never been called for jury service, but because I am in favour of our judicial system, I would have to be in favour of jurors being called. In one sense, I would like to be on a jury. I would appreciate the mental exercise and weighing the facts, one against the other. I think I would be objective and not swayed by emotion. On the other hand, while I believe it is the best system of determining justice, I'm not sure how having a person's fate in my hands would affect me. I would probably tend towards mercy and unless it was a clear-cut case, I would have to argue for acquittal. The main reason I hope I'm not called is the amount of time involved. I would greatly begrudge the time. I do know of friends who have been called for jury service. They dressed well. The man wore a suit and tie. The women dressed in their Sunday best. They were immediately dismissed. On both occasions the jurors chosen were sloppily dressed. If that is the usual way, my "let-out" would be to dress well.
• Australia
26 Feb 07
I'm sure that would do it! May I borrow it if I'm called? No. On second thoughts it would be too hot here.
26 Feb 07
LOL, as I shiver!!
26 Feb 07
Sunday Best - Sunday best attire
I agree with what you have said. I don't think I would be very good at making such a big decision on someone elses life. Especially when you hear of people being wrongly accused. I have the perfect attire to get out of being chosen if this is the case. What do you think?
@shywolf (4514)
• United States
26 Feb 07
I understand being nervous about being called up for jury duty. I've always felt really scared of it, but that's because I'm so shy. I really don't know if I would do a good job or not, knowledge-wise, or if I could be non-judgemental. I just don't know how I would get through it, period. In fact, my best friend at the time had some trouble with some local boys who sprayed mace in her face (for no reason, it was sad) and she had to go to juvenile court with them. I should have been a witness, as I was there, but I guess that everyone saw that I was so incredibly shy that I wouldn't hae been any help to the case, so they didn't even call me. I really didn't expect that, since I was actually the only one who was right there with her when it happened. But they didn't even try to summon me. I never said that I wouldn't try, they just left me alone. It was pretty surprising. Anyway, the boys did get in trouble, thank goodness. And I really do hope that I never get called for jury duty. I don't know what I would do.
2 people like this
26 Feb 07
To be a witness in a trial must be very nerve-racking. Being so shy is such an affliction, I understand because I would be the same. I once gave a statement and was in fear of having to go to court over it, but luckily it never materialised. I know I would have been a wreck if it had. Thanks for your comments.
2 people like this
@cjsmom (1423)
• United States
26 Feb 07
I don't know how I would be as a juror; pray I never have to find out. I think it would be so hard because I have my own opinions on everything and even if they were to ask me if I could be unbiased, I don't know that I could answer yes to the question. We are all human and to me, the only good juror would be a robot, so-to-speak, that basically had no opinions about anything.
26 Feb 07
I know what you mean. Thanks
• United States
26 Feb 07
Don't worry, be happy. Nothing to worry about. Jury duty is one of the most unique experiences you can have. I just finished a trial two weeks ago. It was one that changed some of my opinions and got me interested in new subject matter. It was a case regarding a nursing hiome administrator and now I know alot more about what goes on in nursing homes -- for good and bad. I'm glad to have had the experience and to have served with some nice and intelligent people.
2 people like this
26 Feb 07
Thanks for such positive coments.
@rosie_123 (6113)
26 Feb 07
I don't think anyone is truly unbiased - that would be impossible. But I perceive you as someone intelligent, well-educated, and willing to listen and learn, so I personally think you would be a far better juror than most! In many cases nowadays, the Defence Lawyer will have anyone vetoed if they do not think they would be suitable for their client anyway, so the system is already quite biased towards the defendant. I don't think you have anything to worry about should you be called.
26 Feb 07
I didn't realise this about the Defense, it does sound wrong. Thanks for the vote of confidence rosie, I am touched!
@AmbiePam (85469)
• United States
26 Feb 07
I was summoned at the age of 25 and was very surprised. I had numerous medical excuses I could have used, but I really wanted to be involved if I could help. I thought I would go and see what happened. I was one of the people grilled, but ultimately was not chosen. I was so glad. It was excrutiating on my back problem and if I ever get to do it again, I will consider it long and hard before going. Of course, you have to get an excuse from your doctor, but if I was able, I was going to be there. I found the prosecutor annoying and the defense attorney offensive. The best part was meeting the people from all walks of life. I just don't understand why, when it was an all day thing, did they not provide lunch?
26 Feb 07
I've heard alot of people say they have been summoned, but never get chosen. If they expect you to wait around all day they should supply some kind of refreshment. I am hoping I will never find out. Thanks.
26 Feb 07
oh yeah i got picked all times when i in the waiting area, and when we went in the court the judge will call all the people name he wanted in the jury 2 stand when u name was called u would have to stay behind with the other jury, and when u have been picked u are not aloud to speak to any one about the case no matter what,
1 person likes this
26 Feb 07
It does sound like an experience. I was summoned nearly 20 yeras ago but was out of the country so maybe my time has passed. Thanks for all your comments.
• United States
26 Feb 07
If you were to go in, hear what the trial is about and form a decision based on the summary, then you'd not be open-minded and should not serve. I have many prejudices and opinions, but I can not make an informed decision based on a couple of minutes of summary. I also believe that I could be open-minded. I would want to see all of the facts and as logical person would. Further, if you cannot keep from forming a decision because of your solid prejudices you should be open about that to the court because you'll end up doing more harm than good. Everyone deserves a fair trial.
1 person likes this
26 Feb 07
I agree, Qaeyious responded earlier by stating that in America they have to fill in a questionaire if they are chosen which asks about their involvement and opinions on different matters. It would not be a fair trial otherwise. Thanks for your comments!!!
• United States
26 Feb 07
I registered to vote when I was around 20 so I KNEW I'd start getting things for Jury Duty. I have had two so far in my life. One came during the summer and both times it was at times when I was at part time jobs that DIDNT pay for jury duty. So IF I had gotten to go I would have missed work and only made $8.50 per day which was really about 1hr of work at either of my jobs. YEAH that would suck! The first time I went down and prayed I wouldnt get picked. Just for the reason of NOT enough pay. I never got called. We got out early and I NEVER was called. They changed it up a few years later I believe it was 2005 for me again. This time I was working another part time job still NO pay. I had to call in EACH day for FIVE days and each day pray NO getting picked. I was SO happy I didnt get picked that last day I was dancing! Yeah! I still havent gotten picked. I'd be an okay jury person. As a christian I hold some beliefs bad so maybe I wouldnt be a super great one but I'd be honest for sure. HOPE I never get picked to actually serve. But you never know it could happen and I've gotten plenty of my life for it to actually you know yeah. *shrugs* oh well
1 person likes this
26 Feb 07
Your prayers have definately worked so far. I hope this continues for you! Thanks
@Chele2k2 (241)
26 Feb 07
Funny I should see this discussion, my husband has recently been summoned for jury service, it starts in 2 weeks! He has been on a jury before (approximately 3 years ago) and was selected, the case didn't last long as the person charged, pleaded guilty shortly after it went to court. I am glad I haven't been chosen, I would try my best to be impartial, should it happen. I guess no one can be really sure of how unbiased they are until they're sat there listening to the case and hearing all the evidence.
1 person likes this
26 Feb 07
I wish your husband well in 2 weeks time. It does seems that if you have been summoned once, you are usually called up again. Thanks for your response.
@myCyndi (26)
• United States
26 Feb 07
I have been summoned for Jury Duty about 4 times I think. I have only gone down to the courthouse once though. The other times I asked to be dismissd because of a financial strain (I was self employed) and most recently because I need to be home to take care of my son. The ONE time I went in (my first summons) I was picked to serve on the jury. It was actually a very cool experience, one I am happy I had. It wasn't difficult being rational about the case at all. The facts are given to you and you go off of them. We found the accused guilty on 2 charges and not guily on 1 :) That was about 10 years ago! Crazy stuff.
1 person likes this
26 Feb 07
4 times, thats quite alot. Thanks for sharing this. I am sure I would find it an experience, I suppose I am worried about getting summoned to the Old Bailey on a really big murder trial or something just as bad.
• United States
26 Feb 07
I would love to make it on a jury. I am a trial lawyer and have experience on the other side. But has a lawyer we are always wondering what is going in on the other side and behind the scenes. We always think we know what is important to jurors, but we are probably wrong much of the time. However, since I am a lawyer it is unlikely that I would make it on. People going to jury duty should not be concerned about being a "good juror." Everyone is a good juror, that is how the system works. A jury of our peers requires people with difference experiences and viewpoints. So, don't sweat it.
1 person likes this
26 Feb 07
Thanks for the reassurance.
@wolfie34 (26771)
• United Kingdom
27 Feb 07
They have yet to catch up with me, so far I've never been called, maybe because I've had spells of unemployment, whether that makes a difference or not. I would hope that I was unbiased but I sincerely hope that I am not called to a case which involves crimes on children. I think if the person was found guilty and was given a pathetic sentence then I would find it hard to not express my anger! Trouble is too many lenient sentences are handed down now and even if I contributed into a miscreant being sent down, would they get the right punishment. I think it may not be a bad thing that I don't get called up LOL. If I was judge I'd throw the book at them, I wouldn't be so lenient.
28 Feb 07
This country stinks when it comes to giving out sentences. I have realised if I ever wanted to kill someone all I have to do is run them over and I will most probably get 6 yrs, but only do 2 yrs!! The judges are all living in cloud cockoo land!! Thanks for your response.
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
27 Feb 07
well i dreaded also that moment..but im lucky im an asian not implementing a jurur system..but i have seen movies with jurur on the lead(demi moore)its a tough job and a risky one...maybe i should be open minded all the time and fair to all evidences presented..that if im given a chance to be one..
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
27 Feb 07
not jurur system ..its a jury system..
27 Feb 07
So who passes judgement in your country and is it a fair system? It isn't like what they depict in the movies though from reading some of the responses here. Thanks.
26 Feb 07
well i can telll u this i was summoned and when i received the letter i did not want to go, as at the time my doctor gave my a sick note and i sent it receord post back to the court, any away a year later i received another one for jury service, this time i went, and it was the great experience i have ever face but was also scary met sum wonderful people, i have also just started work at a bp station so taking time off wasnt good, but my boss had no choice but to give me leave with pay so when i did 2 weeks jury serivce i received a big fat pay cheque at the end of it, which was also great. but when we had to give our decision that was really hard.i went thought 3 diffrent cases, and the police was no way happy with are verdit, but if u get summoned i would say go for it as it is really truly a great experience, if i had the chance i would do it again, also when u have finish court service u can be liky to be called back again, but if it past over 2 years after u did jury service u will not be called again,
26 Feb 07
Well I'd refuse to do it as I'm not getting involved with making choices which cannot be for sure + I'm not someone who'd go into something like this with criminals and personally I'm not bothered by the out come of the fact I will not be forced or roped into this. I wouldn't be judgemental as it's important to hear the facts although this still wouldn't get me in court. I'm not sending anyone down with my vote and the law cannot make me although they would probably try. Kudos ~Joey
26 Feb 07
the law can make u go if u refuse it with out a go reson u can be sent to prison, this is what they told us in court when i was called for jury service, and they can also fine u if u refuse to go every time u have been called, its best to get it over and done with, do not refuse it as this is not a joke, u will get in trouble if u refuse the service, the only way to get round this if u have a good reason if they dont agree with ur reason they will make u go
@kate1356 (697)
• United States
26 Feb 07
If you live in the US you can't refuse jury duty. The court can impose fines (or even jail time) for failure to show up for your jury duty. I understand your concern about the system not being perfect (and about possibly making a wrong judgement).. but it is your responsibilty as a citizen to take part in the judicial process.
1 person likes this
@jbrowsin66 (1321)
• United States
27 Feb 07
Sometimes they question the prospective jury members before the trial and if you don't know whether you could make an unbias decision, tell them, they'll dismiss you if they can. Otherwise don't worry, just do the best you can and discuss it with the other jury members and weigh the facts. Usually you don't get on a terribly hard case, if one at all. I've been chosen twice and you have to show up, but then they may not be busy enough that week. They prepare you very well for your duty. It was a good experience for me.
1 person likes this
@jbrowsin66 (1321)
• United States
27 Feb 07
Sometimes they question the prospective jury members before the trial and if you don't know whether you could make an unbias decision, tell them, they'll dismiss you if they can. Otherwise don't worry, just do the best you can and discuss it with the other jury members and weigh the facts. Usually you don't get on a terribly hard case, if one at all. I've been chosen twice and you have to show up, but then they may not be busy enough that week. They prepare you very well for your duty. It was a good experience for me.
27 Feb 07
Thanks for the info, much appreciated!