Pick one person from the top 24 who's already been eliminated...

United States
March 9, 2007 12:27am CST
to put back on the show. who would it be? who would you take off to do it? for me, even though it would be a girl for a guy, I would take Sanjaya off and bring back Sabrina. I was so shocked when they announced that Haley made the top 12. another person I might have held onto was A.J. Tabaldo. I thought he deserved better.
2 people like this
5 responses
@brendalee (6083)
• United States
9 Mar 07
I agree with you that Sabrina shouldn't have been eliminated. But I would pick to bring back Sundance. I liked him. And I would definately get rid of Sanjaya. He was a sweet kid but he didn't have a lot of talent.
1 person likes this
• United States
9 Mar 07
Absolutely... you know, nothing against the kid, he's a good kid who knows that he has already made it further than he deserves. I commented about this to my wife: look at his face, he genuinely looked upset to be there. I have no problems with Sanjaya, it's the talent around him and the fact that he doesn't measure up. I liked Sundance a lot as well, but I thought he did get a free pass after the first week in the Top 24. He was awful, and most of the clips they showed of him in Hollywood week were pretty bad too. I thought that he'd done enough to save himself for the Top 12 though. ,but I guess America has proven me wrong... MELINDA DOOLITTLE FOR AMERICAN IDOL 2007!!!!
1 person likes this
@sunnypub (2131)
• United States
9 Mar 07
I think I would have to fix the errors from tonight. Send Sanjaya and Haley home and bring back Sundance and Sabrina. I don't think they are the best but they certainly deserve to be in the top 12 more than Sanjaya and Haley. If I went a little farther back then I would have to say Nicholas. I thought he had a better voice, and better performance skills than at least 3 of those who are in the top 12.
@leedug (921)
• United States
9 Mar 07
100% bring Sundance back. Every season someone gets a raw deal, and this season it was him. I agree about Sabrina too. She would be the next to be brought back.
• United States
9 Mar 07
sanjaya would be gone and sundance back
@kgwat70 (13396)
• United States
9 Mar 07
I too would bring back Sabrina as she was one of my favorites on the show and was very disappointed that she got voted off. I think we have no clue about how to vote. This is a singing competition and people should be voting based on that only. I would definitely take Sanjaya off as he does not deserve to be there. Heley should be gone too so I would get rid of Haley and bring back Sabrina. I would also get rid of Sanjaya and keep Sundance on the show. He should not have been eliminated either. I liked A.J. as well.