Weird In Laws!

Australia
April 9, 2007 2:09am CST
Ok, now i get along with my inlaws just fine but over the last 2 or 3 years my MIL has decided she wants to be like her 17 yr old daughter ~ punk/goth. I have no problem with this except she has such a big influence over her MANY grandchildren. I don't really want my daughter asking if she can get her eyebrow or labret pierced just coz Nana has it done. I know one of my nieces already did this & said she wanted her tongue done because Nana did. Do you think what Nana is doing now is ok or do you think she needs to remember that these Grandkids are very impressionable & should tone it down a bit? Please realise i have no problem with them, i just think it's a little bit late to start acting 16 (she had kids at 16 so wants to go back there)! Any thoughts? Please share:)
7 people like this
15 responses
• Canada
9 Apr 07
Just keep trying to explain to the kids that just because someone else does it, or it looks cool on someone else, doesn't mean they have to do it too. Tell them that people are individuals, and they need to do what is right for them, not what is right for someone else. Might not hurt to have ths same discussion with your mother-in-law.
3 people like this
@Stiletto (4579)
9 Apr 07
I'm a granny but I don't spend my time baking pies and knitting nor have I any intentions of doing so in the future. When I look after my grandaughter (who is still a baby) we're usually dancing round like lunatics to AC/DC, not sitting in a rocking chair! And since when have kids wanted to look like their granny? I mean - I loved my granny but NO WAY would I ever have wanted to look like her!! I know your niece said she wanted her tongue pierced because her Nana had hers done but really that was probably more to get a reaction than anything else. Kids are usually good at working out what will push their parents buttons. In your MIL's case it sounds like she is making up for lost time which is common with women who have children very young. I had my daughter when I was 18 and there's no doubt you do miss out on a lot of things. The whole punk/goth thing might just be a phase she is going through - she may just need to get it out of her system. However even if it is something she sticks with then I don't really see the problem. Surely what matters is how she treats her grandchildren and whether she is a positive influence in their lives - and having body piercings and wearing strange clothes doesn't exclude her from being a positive influence.
2 people like this
• United States
9 Apr 07
I could not have said it better myself.
9 Apr 07
I'm 55 years young with a son of 22 and, as the user ID suggests, I'm a goth and have been since its very beginning way back in the late 70's. I have four tattoos and wear goth clothes. Not all of us oldies are resigned to sitting in a rocking chair knitting you know. Heck, I was in the mosh pit at an Iron Maiden gig last December :-) If your Mum in Law wants to do what she wants, then good luck to her. No one has the right to dictate how to act and behave in this day and age, it is her right to decide for herself. If the younger kids think she is cool and want to copy her, all you really need to do is simply say, "when you are old enough to make up your own mind"
@syain1972 (1011)
• Singapore
9 Apr 07
I guess she must have felt that she had missed a lot of things in life since she had kids when she was 16. I do believe its like a mid-life crisis thing that she's going through. Did you ever ask her why she's behaving this way? I think someone can just give her a gentle reminder that the grandchildren are at this impressionable age and could easily be influenced. However, please do so in a discreet manner as she might get offended. Good Luck!
2 people like this
@prestocaro (1252)
• United States
9 Apr 07
WOW! Your kid's Nana sounds like fun, lol! I think if your daughter asks to get pierced, you should tell her that she can, when she turns 18 and can pay for it herself. Once she's 18 and can pay for it herself, your opinion won't matter as much, anyway. Your MIL sounds like she missed her window of opportunity to have a moratorium. This is what most kids/teens/young adults do in high school and college -- they experiment and try new things to see if they like them. She never got that chance and now that she's got the time and means, she wants to do it. If you feel comfortable with that, great! If not, you should talk to her about your concerns, so your kids don't get mixed messages or anything. You may feel that it's late for her to return to that mindset or lifestyle, but clearly she doesn't and she intends to. Some things are simply beyond our control and understanding, lol!
• Australia
10 Apr 07
Thanks for your thoughts! To her it's probably fun & to all the ones who don't have to accociate with her :) All i know is that it looks pretty wrong when a mother at mid 40's goes to metal concerts with her 16 yr old & they look like twins :) I just wish she's gone through this phase before all her grandkids came along! Not for myself though but for her kids, i know my partner gets embarrassed by her when they're out & about! Take care :)
• New Zealand
9 Apr 07
I don't know. To be honest, I don't see a huge problem with it. I don't see why people should have to "act" a certain way, or why she should look like a Nana just because she is one. I actually think it sounds kinda cool, as long as she is smart about it. Like if the kids wanted their eyebrow pierced, she could say "It is okay when you're my age, but you have to wait til you're 16".
• Australia
9 Apr 07
There's no reason for her to act a certain way but we need her to understand she's had plenty of time to act this way, why wait until she's mid 40's with 9 Grandchildren before she starts acting like she's 16. I'm glad you think it's kinda cool coz to us it's kinda embarrassing, all her kids are disapproving (except the youngest) & hate going out in to public with her - i guess it's different when it's not your own Mum but i feel for all of her actual kids (including my partner) who hate the fact she's doing it now. Thanks for your comments though :)
@missybal (4490)
• United States
9 Apr 07
YIKES!!! Well it's really her choice what she does with her body however your children are too young to be able to do what ever they want with theirs. I would have a talk with her and ask her to tone it down at least when she is around her grandchildren. At least with yours. Just ask her to take out the extra earrings in the tounge and eyebrows and that when she is with your children and cover the tattoos too if she has them. Really she does need to understand that you don't want your kids to just follow her example. It's bad enough when friends their own age have stuff like that but to have a grandmother who is also making a statement that it is completely normal it really looks like everyone is doing it. She doesn't have to change completely just be respectful of how you are raising your children.
1 person likes this
@mansha (6298)
• India
10 Apr 07
smeone's going through a crisis, may be she wants to revisit her youth, I suggest try and talk to her and get her enroolled in some dance classes or something she likes instead of becoming a punk. tell her if you have to that she looks dreadful in the getup. soemtimes you have to be cruel when saying the truth to face but I think in long run she will be sorry and ashamed of what she is doing right now. Its better if the family talks to her.
1 person likes this
@lucy02 (5016)
• United States
9 Apr 07
Yes, that is weird for a grandmother. I would try talking to her about it. Maybe she doesn't realize how ridiculous she looks. If that doesn't work then I think I would kind of limit her contact with my kids somewhat. Maybe explain to the kids that grandma is a little strange but you still love her.
1 person likes this
@bindishah (2062)
• India
9 Apr 07
I think your MIl is probably going through some crisis. I mean who in that age would want to get piercings done or wear gothic clothes. I think the family needs to sit down with her and tlak this out. let her know her actions have repurcussions as can be seen by your niece getting her tongue pierced. Tell her to tone it down just a bit atleast in front of the kids. Im sure she will understand if you explain it to her nicely as a family.
• Canada
9 Apr 07
I think Nana has the right to choose what she wants to look like and be comfortable with that. However, when she's doing it in front of the kids, and they're young and impressionable, she's going a bit too far. Young kids are impressionable anyway, and the fact that Nana has such a huge influence over them is going to cause some major headaches. The family needs to sit down with her and talk this over. Explain that you're not trying to tell her how she can and can't look as such, just that you're worried about the influence that this is going to have on her grandkids. Hopefully she'll tone it down just a bit. I wish you luck.
1 person likes this
@sunshine4 (8703)
• United States
9 Apr 07
How old is you MIL? I think that she might be trying to fit in and doesn't know how, so she is trying to be cool and acting like a 16 yr old. What does your husband think? I am 43 and would never get my tongue peirced and I am not a grandma. Something is going on with this woman. Very weird. What about her children who have children that she is influencing? Do you all feel this is inappropriate? If so, maybe you all should have a talk with her and tell her that she is a huge influence on your children and you don't feel she is teaching them appropriate behavior with all the piercings ect. Maybe if she realizes that you aren't happy with this, she will change. If it were me, I would not bring my child around as much due to this weird behavior and I would tell her that is why I am not bringing my child around. Good luck.
@bad1981 (799)
• United States
10 Apr 07
I agree with you, she needs to be grown up and not act like she is 16 now. If she has many grandchildren then she should think about how that affects them. Hang in there and hopefully it is just a stage that passes.
1 person likes this
@muscare (3068)
• Australia
9 Apr 07
Someone needs to tell her to start acting her age. It's bad enough when kids have people like Paris Hilton and co to influnce the things they are doing, but when you have a grandmother who is obviously going through some sort of crisis, the lin needs to be drawn somewhere. I would not be letting my kid see too much of her until she starts acting like the mature person she should be!
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
10 Apr 07
My mother got her nose pierced and my daughter hasn't asked to get hers done. I think your MIL is an adult, she done raised her kids, she can do what she wants. You are the parent of your kids and you can tell them no when the time comes and that Nana is an adult and they are not.