sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Did I say already that religion was child abuse?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion 5 years ago

Here's another example of what religion can do to children, when properly indoctrinated, and this turned my guts out. What this kid did "in the name of Allah" could have been done by any other kid, for any other preposterous god.

Just read on...


----------

Taleban uses boy to behead 'spy'

The Taleban in Afghanistan have used a boy of around 12 to behead a man they accused of spying for the US.

Parts of a video of the beheading were broadcast on the Dubai-based al-Arabiya TV network.

The Taleban said the dead man, Ghulam Nabi, had given the US information which led to an air strike in which a senior Taleban commander died.

The video footage shows Mr Nabi being blindfolded with a chequered scarf and making what is said to be a confession.

The boy, wearing a camouflage jacket and wielding a large knife, denounces him as a spy and then cuts off his head.

The father of Mr Nabi, who lives in Pakistan and who confirmed that his son was the man killed in the video, said his son had been a loyal member of the Taleban.

Senior Taleban commander Akhtar Mohammad Osmani was killed during a December air strike on his car in southern Afghanistan.

From:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/6579487.stm

----------

"Religion is an insult to human dignity. With or without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion."
-- American physicist Steven Weinberg.

 

religion
sponsors
California Drug Attorney
We Are Skilled in Drug Cases. Call us today for a Consultation.
NoCuffs.com/800-662-8337

Pur Rehab& Detox Center
No More Alcohol& Drug Addictions, Finance and 10% Discount Available
www.PurDetox.com

Drug Substance Abuse
Tired of Searching? We Can Help. Call Directly. 877-627-4391.
4Rehabilitation.com/SubstanceAbuse

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  religion, atrocities, god, abuse, acts of violence
 
1. myLot reputation of 87/100. TeresaK (8081)   5 years ago

This could happen when anyone is fanatical about any cause, religious or otherwise. It's not religion that is the problem, it's fanaticism. Not all people who have faith are fanatics.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

The problem is that people are liable to commit all sorts of atrocities provided that they are sanctioned by some kind of authority. And there's no bigger one than a divine autority, even if it's unlikely to exist.


myLot reputation of 64/100. us2owls (2086)   ranked 602 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

I agree with you - and it is the fanatics that cause and/or allow kids to do this kind of thing. No matter what the religion there are nut cases in everyone.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8018)   ranked 223 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

...religion, like all things can be abused.. and it is for politics.. a-theism is also a belief and the atrocities carried out by a-theism has racked up quite a total of casualties, from the marxist/darwinian slaughters in the name of commune-ism.. and fascism (which to this day tries to hide its occult leanings behind a so called christianity, or at least history tries to record it that way by some) - I am including the holocaust of the preborn in this casualty count from the a-theistic camp.. I do not, however wish to outlaw a-theism, or jail them or persecute them.. as I still believe in the chrisitian roots of freedom and also free speech, etc..


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8018)   ranked 223 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

..even tho a-theism is responsible for the dissolution of society and family.

California Drug Attorney We Are Skilled in Drug Cases. Call us today for a Consultation.  NoCuffs.com/800-662-8337
 
2. myLot reputation of 89/100. cremechese (4490)   5 years ago

What people have done in the name of God and country is atrocious. (I'm not much for jingoism, either.) I'm a big fan of Bob Dylan's "With God on Our Side". These type of extremist people can justify anything they do using anyone. I'm afraid zealotry is never going to end.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

You may be interested in this link, then:

http://blacktom.blogspot....

And yes, I do agree with you.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8018)   ranked 223 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

..some zealots are easy to spot..


myLot reputation of 48/100. revdauphinee (4113)   ranked 2,092 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

and some hide behind their so called "peacefull faith"

Pur Rehab & Detox Center No More Alcohol & Drug Addictions, Finance and 10% Discount Available  www.PurDetox.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 79/100. wenkinnoc (455)   ranked 1,961 out of 6,502 in religion   5 years ago

And what of science? How many lifes have been lost and destroyed in the name of so called progress? many of the tecnhology used in NASA are based upon research committed by the nazis in concentration camps.

It is not religion itself that is bad, it has people who use it as a front and mask to stand up and abuse and hurt people. These people, who use religion to train suicide bombers, child killers and the like, are extremly cunning and take a warped and corrupted view of Holy texts, in an attempt to justify their vile actions.

I am not terribly religious, I dont attend Church and am part of a group that my faith disapproves of, but even so, I know the basic tenants of being a good person, but to claim that religion is the root of all evil is an affornt to the hard work carried out by members of the clergy.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

You could have started your post with "and what of gardening?" that it wouldn't have been any more relevant. Don't compare apples and pears, please.

Just re-read the quote I posted at the end of the BBC article:

"Religion is an insult to human dignity. With or without it you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion."
-- American physicist Steven Weinberg.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8018)   ranked 223 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

Quoting an authority? Prejud-ism in the name of an authority?

Drug Substance Abuse Tired of Searching? We Can Help. Call Directly. 877-627-4391.  4Rehabilitation.com/SubstanceAbuse
 
4. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElusiveButterfly (9602)   5 years ago

It saddens me when children are used to carry out acts of violence. Of course, the child would be considered a man in some cultures. But, neither man nor child should commit take another human life.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

Unfortunately, this kid is considered a hero and "the hand of God" by the b@st@rds who made him do such a horrible act. He'll still be marked for life, as taking another human being's life is the most traumatic event anyone can experience. Believe me!


myLot reputation of 91/100. loralee (319)   ranked 2,439 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

His life is over before it barely had the chance to begin. And I agree with you Thomas. I can't imagine there being a worse traumatic experience. I suppose even true heroes (surgeons, firemen, etc) can go through trauma or feel stained if the lives they are setting out to save are not saved.

Substance Abuse Alcohol & Drug Rehab. 888-907-4714. Insurance & Financing OK.  TheDrugRehab.com/SubstanceAbuse
 
5. myLot reputation of 48/100. revdauphinee (4113)   ranked 2,092 out of 6,502 in religion   5 years ago

you should clarify this it is not "religion"per-se it is islam! when did a Christian ever do such a thing???Maybee back in the crusades we have much to answer for but this type of atrocity is going on todaYChristians have evolved Muslims have not!!!


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

I do agree that Christianity has come a long way since the atrocities the Church was regularly performing in the past. It doesn't make it any better, though. This kid has committed an awful deed that will mark him for life. And what for? For some dubious entity he's been made to believe in.

The principle remains the same.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

Oh, and I forgot to mention that the Pope telling the Africans not to use condoms -- in countries ridden by AIDS! -- is the latest attempt at mass murder by the Roman Catholic Church.

This one may be born out of stupidity instead of sheer evil, but the result is the same...


reluctantexan (94)  5 years ago

ALL religions subvert true humanity!


myLot reputation of 63/100. Latrivia (1976)   ranked 1,184 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

The hands of Christians are not unsullied by blood. Hate crimes committed by Christians still continue today. Mind you, none of them exist on this scale, but that doesn't excuse the fact that some Christians still hurt and kill others because of their religious beliefs.


myLot reputation of 48/100. revdauphinee (4113)   ranked 2,092 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

Latrivia then they are not true christians for even Jesus said not all who call him christ will be recognised
Matthew 7: 20. Thus, by their fruit you will recognize them.
21. "Not everyone who says to me, `Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven.
22. Many will say to me on that day, `Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?'
23. Then I will tell them plainly, `I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!'


myLot reputation of 63/100. Latrivia (1976)   ranked 1,184 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

And yet Muslims who commit atrocious acts are seen as true Muslims? You did know that, like Chrisitians, Muslims too condemn the extremist acts of their brethren, right?
If extremist Christians are not viewed as true Christians, then why are extremist Muslims viewed as the shining example of Islam?

Oh wait...the media, that's why.


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8018)   ranked 223 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

One of the most repeated things everywhere these days is that fanatic jihadism is not true Islam.. If we haven't heard that we must be living in a cave.. Anybody using blanket condemnations, is not as wise as they might think they are.. Islamists don't speak out much, cause, well, I wouldn't be sticking my neck out!!


myLot reputation of 48/100. revdauphinee (4113)   ranked 2,092 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

I repeat if a christian ever commited such atrocities as these folk do thewre would be such AN OUTCRY FROM FELLOW CHRISTIANS AGAINST IT WHY CANT ISLAM DO SO ?BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT AGAINST IT IS THE ONLY CONCLUSION TO BE TAKEN HERE !


myLot reputation of 63/100. Latrivia (1976)   ranked 1,184 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

If you haven't heard the outcry of Muslims against Jihadists, then you have either closed your ears to it in order to maintain your narrow minded and prejudiced outlook on Muslims, or you just haven't been paying attention. Maybe you, like so many other people, have boxed yourself away in your own little world, so that nothing outside of it can reach you - not even the truth.
If you don't believe me, go to Google and type in "Muslims against Jihad". This will yield 1,420,000 results. Knowing that there's over a million websites out there all containing information about Muslims against Jihad, I somehow find it hard to believe Muslims are keeping quiet.

You sound awful judgemental for a Christian. Maybe you're not quite the Christian you think you are.

Drug Abuse Help Overwhelmed? Don't Know Where to Start? Free Help, Call 888-527-0071  Drug-Rehab.org/DrugAbuseHelp
 
6. myLot reputation of 37/100. Gnosisquest (777)   5 years ago

You are correct Thomas; religion is definitely child abuse!

I do not approve of the American regime in their war against Iraq as it has practically wiped out all possibility of subverting the fundamentalist Islamic cult known as the Taliban.

Iraq was not a threat to the west under Saddam but now it looks like the Taliban has gained a foothold there also.

The Taliban which can be compared with the Christian right wing movement in christian countries lie to their children in the name of their God of delusion. This God was created in their own image of subversion promoting their most barbaric impulses and preventing society from establishing a civilized society.

In the same fashion that you are able to tell the worth of a person by his action you can judge the value of any religious system by the adherents to the religion. The value of booth the Christian and Islamic doctrines have failed. As the Bible states, the religion is a stumbling block to humanity and truly nothing good can possibly come from either of these barbaric cults.

Ras


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

Atrocities are usually committed when the perpetrators are subjected to authority. And what greater authority than a divine one -- even if it doesn't even exist!

You may be interested in this, Ras:

http://blacktom.blogspot....

Substance Abuse Need Help Finding the Best Rehab? We Can Help. Call 877-329-0880.  AboveItAllTreatment.com/Abuse
 
7. myLot reputation of 89/100. CritterKeeper (325)   ranked 389 out of 6,502 in religion   5 years ago

Even without religion people would continue to do these horrible things, they'd just justify them differently.
Your quote is interesting but it doesn't hold any more or less "truth" than any religion. It's just a hip shot sound byte, great as far as an eyecatching headline but nothing more really. "Good" people do "evil" things all the time with or without religious justification.
Maybe it's just time for folks to start really questioning such absolute terms like "good" and "evil". I'm quite sure that there are those out there that would say that this post is "evil", especially using inflamatory language like "any other preposterous god". Does that MAKE it or you evil in some way? Just like a rose by any other name smells as sweet, a week old dead fish lying around in the sun stinks the same no matter what you call it.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

Interesting point of view, even if I don't quite agree. You may be also interested by the link I posted above.


myLot reputation of 89/100. CritterKeeper (325)   ranked 389 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

In reading the link I found the same thing stated in different words:
This research highlights the possible cause of religious extremism and the violent actions that result from selective reading of the scriptures, focusing essentially on retribution instead of absorbing the overall message of tolerance that religions are supposed to convey.
I'm reminded of the old days when it was "Commies" who were the popular American enemy. It wasn't based on a difference of religious beliefs but political/economic. People seem to need some sort of "common enemy" to point at and will use ANY difference they find convenient. Once it was blacks against whites, Communism against Capitalism, today Islam is just the popular target, and tomorrow it may be BLONDES will get fed up with being "oppressed" by all the stereotypes, blond jokes, etc. and rise up! LOL Religion is really irrelevant to it all.

Substance Abuse Centers Find the Right Drug Rehab Center. Financing Available. 866-426-6549.  RehabHelp.com/SubstanceAbuse
 
8. myLot reputation of 96/100. curvychick77 (1047)   ranked 1,737 out of 6,502 in religion   5 years ago

Some people are religious freaks. It is very true for some. They have a facsination with religion and they start to believe in certain things, or that you are supposed to do certain things. It could also be a mental problem, but not everyone is a religious fanatic. This kid was probably brought up that way, which can be abuse, but with that being said, people can also make up their own mind.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

What can you do when you're 12 and people tell you that the god you've been indoctrinated to believe in wants you to chop someone's head off?


myLot reputation of 48/100. revdauphinee (4113)   ranked 2,092 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

ONE WORD HERE "aLLAH""!

Indiana Drug Rehabs Drug & Alcohol Addiction Rehabs In Indiana. 888-883-0490.  RehabilitationUSA.com/Indiana
 
9. myLot reputation of 78/100. thatcrazyqbanita (2012)   5 years ago

The problem is fanaticism. I'm nto religious at all, but I do believe some people need faith because they are vulnerable and it gives them a sense of hope and happiness. But in any religion this can occur


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

"But in any religion this can occur"

My point exactly!

Drug Abuse Treatment Do You or Someone You Love Have a Drug Problem? 877-549-2072.  StopYourAddiction.com/DrugAbuse
 
10. myLot reputation of 80/100. whiteheather39 (15571)   ranked 172 out of 6,502 in religion   5 years ago

That particular example is of abuse but that was an example of how extreme and fanatical the Muslim religion is. I really don't think one can categorize all religions by this one particular branch.


myLot reputation of 58/100. Thomas73 (598)   ranked 959 out of 6,502 in religion  5 years ago

What I wanted to point out was the fact that you can make innocent people do the most horrible things given the proper indoctrination/brain-washing. And this is how I see religion, although I admit that this is an extreme case and most believers -- regardless of their religion -- would not do that. It just made me sick when I read it, and I wanted to share it with you all.

Substance Abuse Tired of Searching? We Can Help. Insurance OK, Call Now 855-212-9034.  BestDrugRehabilitation.com/Abuse
 
sponsors
Substance Abuse
Alcohol& Drug Rehab. 888-907-4714. Insurance& Financing OK.
TheDrugRehab.com/SubstanceAbuse

Drug Abuse Help
Overwhelmed? Don't Know Where to Start? Free Help, Call 888-527-0071
Drug-Rehab.org/DrugAbuseHelp

Substance Abuse
Need Help Finding the Best Rehab? We Can Help. Call 877-329-0880.
AboveItAllTreatment.com/Abuse

similar discussions
Why is it religion causes a lot problem and war?
Have you notice? If religion can bring peace and love why is there is war? I am Catholic but I...
do u pray bfore and after bedtime?
as a roman catholic, we are obliged to do praying bfore and after bedtime..follow what god wants us...
Did Obama pick the wrong fight?
Obama, in his ultimate stupidity, decided it would be a good idea to FORCE Catholic organizations...
Religion is the most mysterious of subjects
Religion is the most mysterious of subjects, but not the morals and values it represents - love,...
why Adam is not the first man on earth
The Bible says:" So God created man in his own image and, in the image of God created he him;male...
I believe what I believe because I researched it.
Yeap, what a mouthful of a title that is. In religion (I'm from a Christian background) there's...
DEMONS? Seriously...
I have heard many stories around people being possessed by demons. At first it seemed very unusual...
who is Jesus Christ? is he a God or he is a Prophet?
Hello guys please clarify your answer i dont know how do you threat Jesus Christ is he a God or he...
Paganism in Christianity
Some Religious groups are using graven Images or statues in worshiping God, especially here in the...
Christians...what if Jesus had not been born?
Serious question for debate here...would you still follow God? Think about it before you blindly...
sponsors
Substance Abuse
Alcohol & Drug Rehab. 888-907-4714. Insurance & Financing OK.
TheDrugRehab.com/SubstanceAbuse
Drug Abuse Help
Overwhelmed? Don't Know Where to Start? Free Help, Call 888-527-0071
Drug-Rehab.org/DrugAbuseHelp
Substance Abuse
Need Help Finding the Best Rehab? We Can Help. Call 877-329-0880.
AboveItAllTreatment.com/Abuse
Substance Abuse Centers
Find the Right Drug Rehab Center. Financing Available. 866-426-6549.
RehabHelp.com/SubstanceAbuse
Indiana Drug Rehabs
Drug & Alcohol Addiction Rehabs In Indiana. 888-883-0490.
RehabilitationUSA.com/Indiana
Drug Abuse Treatment
Do You or Someone You Love Have a Drug Problem? 877-549-2072.
StopYourAddiction.com/DrugAbuse
Substance Abuse
Tired of Searching? We Can Help. Insurance OK, Call Now 855-212-9034.
BestDrugRehabilitation.com/Abuse
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.