In Defense of American Idol..  

I am excited about American Idol’s upcoming show this week, for many star performances are to benefit those in need. Some of the performers are Annie Lenox, No Doubt, and there is even a surprise appearance by Celine Dion! My friends and I are anticipating what will happen, for we each have our individual favorites. I know I do! It is great that American Idol is doing something to give back to the community, and I know I will be watching tonight and tomorrow!

In defense of American Idol and recent publicity, perhaps audiences should think twice before being critical of singers and the show. One reason is because it is often easier to comment when you are not in the hot seat yourself. Could you get up there and sing? I know I am not ready for that. And even though Sanjaya was voted one of the worst singers this season by more than the American public, neither the viewers nor the audiences are doing the singing in front of the cameras and complete strangers. In addition, just because a vote isn’t going your way, doesn’t give anyone the right to critique without considering all the facts, the least of all a fan’s musical biases. And the fact is that American Idol is about something bigger than you and me.

American Idol is about helping people regain a sense of themselves, especially through improving someone’s quality of life directly. The show clearly allows us the chance to give something back to the community. Now whether that generosity is through singing or donating money to programs that will help people gain their lives back and to consequently live a better life, the point is something is being done. That’s more than I can say about most people worried about their cell phone bills. So instead of sitting on your comfortable couch critiquing American Idol or Sanjaya, maybe consider that all those involved in the show are giving something back of their own free will.

A true American Idol gives without expecting anything in return. When putting one’s sense of self on the line via taking a chance and risking personal safety or assumptions, stepping out of the comfortable zone is priceless. The non-material reward is enough in itself. In short, the satisfaction of trying is a reward. Secondly, most people do not have the guts to get up in front of a crowd to speak, much less reveal their hearts and souls by singing to strangers who will judge them on more than their singing. Perhaps tonight before we watch American Idol, take a moment to consider giving back at least more than a critical vote.