Some say schools giving Muslims special treatment  |
| |
| http://www.usatoday.com/n... By Oren Dorell, USA TODAY Some public schools and universities are granting Muslim requests for prayer times, prayer rooms and ritual foot baths, prompting a debate on whether Islam is being given preferential treatment over other religions. The University of Michigan at Dearborn is planning to build foot baths for Muslim students who wash their feet before prayer. An elementary school in San Diego created an extra recess period for Muslim pupils to pray. At George Mason University in Fairfax, Va., Muslim students using a "meditation space" laid out Muslim prayer rugs and separated men and women in accordance with their Islamic beliefs. Critics see a double standard and an organized attempt to push public conformance with Islamic law. "What (school officials) are doing...is to give Muslim students religious benefits that they do not give any other religion right now," says Richard Thompson, president and chief counsel at the Thomas More Law Center, an advocacy group for Christians. Advocates say the accommodations are legal. "The whole issue is to provide for a religious foundation for those who are observant while respecting separation of church and state," says Salam Al-Marayati, executive director of the Muslim Public Affairs Council, based in Los Angeles. Many schools accommodate the Christian and Jewish sabbaths and allow Jewish students to not take tests on religious holidays, he says. Barry Lynn, of Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, says however that the law is murky on these expressions of faith. And the American Civil Liberties Union says overt religious symbols like crucifixes are not legal, but whether Muslim foot baths and prayer rugs fall into that category is not clear. "That's a difficult one, and it's right on the edge," says Jeremy Gunn, director of the ACLU program on freedom of religion and belief in Washington, D.C. At the forefront of the movement is the Muslim Students' Association, which has formed a Muslim Accommodations Task Force to push for foot baths and prayer rooms. At least 17 universities have foot baths built or under construction, including Boston University, George Washington University and Temple University, and at least nine universities have prayer rooms for "Muslim students only," including Stanford, Emory and the University of Virginia, according to the MSA's website. The association did not return calls seeking comment. Zuhdi Jasser, a Muslim and chairman of the American Islamic Forum for Democracy, which promotes separation of mosque and state, says he is concerned about the accommodations. "Unusual accommodations for one faith at the cost of everybody else doesn't fall on the side of pluralism," he said. At George Mason University, non-Muslim students were asked to observe Muslim rules in the prayer area, such as keeping men on one side and women on the other and removing their shoes, according to Broadside, the school newspaper. Alissa Karton, assistant to the vice president for student life, said the article prompted the school to order students to roll up prayer rugs when not in use and move the dividers. The University of Michigan agreed to install foot baths after talks with the MSA, said Terry Gallagher, director of public relations at the campus. Some Muslims ritually wash their feet before praying five times a day. Daniel Pipes, founder of the Middle East Forum, a conservative think tank, sees the requests as part of a movement to force the public to acquiesce to Islamic law. "The goal of Islamists is the application of Islamic law," Pipes says. In the San Diego case, a substitute teacher at Carver Elementary School alleged that teachers were indoctrinating students into Islam. The San Diego Unified School District determined that a teacher's aide was wrong to lead Muslim students in prayer. Carver still has a special recess to allow 100 Muslim students to pray. The ACLU, which has often sued schools for permitting prayer, says it is waiting to see what kind of policy the school settles on before deciding whether to sue. It says promoting prayers is unconstitutional. "If you start carving out time in the school day that you would not do but for the need to let students pray, then it begins to look like what you're trying to do is to assist religion," says David Blair-Loy, legal director for the ACLU in San Diego. Thompson says such conflicts are bound to proliferate. He and other Christians, he says, are preparing to ask for equal consideration such as a Christian prayer recess. "What you're going to see out there is more of these kinds of cases as the Muslim community tests how far it can go in the public school system," he says. "If this can happen for Muslims, it can happen for Christians and other religions." | | | | | |
| |
| | Earn HS Degree Online Earn Your High School Degree. Accredited& Flexible. Get Help Now! HighSchoolDiploma.net
| Serve God& Our Fellowman 100% Online Master Degree (MEd) in Religion for Busy Christian Workers EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info
| Super cheap Carving Knife Carving Knife at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops& 23 Mil products. www.Carving-Knife.best-price.com
|
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
|
|
| |
oneandonemakesix (23975)
|
5 years ago
| | I agree with you, but I think there are going to be long and hard fought battles over this, and I think we saw this coming, and its been slowly happening over the country, to include special meals during Muslims Holy Holidays. But right now 'some' places are really trying to give muslims extra consideration because they are so many times crying discrimination, because the Terrorists Groups like Al-Qaida are a faction of Muslim religion to an extreme.... So I think people are afraid that if their demands are not given into then there will be a lawsuit of discrimination, when in actuality they are opening themselves up to lawsuits from others for discrimination. mooch | | | |
elairz (215)
|
5 years ago
| | umm. i will keep this short. here my thought on this issue. the prayer room bit is nice..but the foot baths is not really necessary. the prayer room could be used by other religion, i see nothing wrong with that as long the room kept clean. and the student who prayed there should bring their own mat. as for the extra recess. i think in the school hour, there only one prayers only. the other they can do it at the mosque or home. however giving extra recess for this would seem special treatment from the others perspective. there are solutions to this. seem like this goes longer than i intended too. before i end this i would like to ask a question. a muslim need to do 5 prayers a day, everyday. each has to be done within a time limit. as im not that knowledgeable about other religion. so here the question. are there any other religion that have time specific things need to be done everyday? i suppose there is, but all the same please enlighten me. | | | |
sndcain (3075)
|
5 years ago
| | To my knowledge, only Islam has such strict, strangulating rituals that prevent devout Muslims from intregrating without special accomodation. I don't need a special room to pray, and I don't have to bathe before I speak to God either. | | | |
RealIolo (761)
|
5 years ago
| | They don't deserve any more considerations and accommodation then do those of other faiths. Definitely not to these extremes. It isn't as though they are special or deserve preferential treatment. | | | |
| |
| Earn HS Degree Online Earn Your High School Degree. Accredited & Flexible. Get Help Now! HighSchoolDiploma.net | add comment | | |
|
|
2. oneandonemakesix (23975)
|
5 years ago
| | If they are not going to allow Christianity and other religions in schools, then I think it should be a thing that is clear across the board, and not allow any of this religion in schools, an extra recess for kids to go and pray is going way out fo the way to give special treatment to muslims, and I disagree with it. People are so going out of their way to accomodate Muslims and not thinking how it discriminates against other religions. One more reason why I homeschool. Mooch | | | | | | |
MSV1313 (2239)
|
5 years ago
| | You know, they have removed recess and phys ed (gym) entirely from many schools to save money (at the detriment of our childrens physical and mental well being) but they are willing to give recess time to ONE particular religious group? Something is VERY wrong with that picture and our founding fathers must be spinning in their graves! | | | |
| |
| Serve God & Our Fellowman 100% Online Master Degree (MEd) in Religion for Busy Christian Workers EducationDegreeSource.com/Free_Info | add comment | | |
|
|
3. raydene (5491)
|
5 years ago
| | Hello Sweets, I have no problem with schools giving these spaces and time for prayer as long as they give it to all religions and groups. The problem lies in special treatment for one group. In the USA this group has been suffering from some discrimation and giving special treatment to this group will only increase this problem! Thanks for bringing this to a discussion. Have a great day R | | | | | | |
| |
| Super cheap Carving Knife Carving Knife at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products. www.Carving-Knife.best-price.com | add comment | | |
|
|
4. HighReed1 (881)
|
5 years ago
| | OK. Let me see if I have this straight. There is supposed to be 'seperation of church and state'. There is NO prayer session for any religion because school is part of 'state'. Even The Pledge of Allegiance is being messed with because some people don't like to say 'God'. This 'seperation' doesn't apply to Muslims, even though they are in OUR country going to OUR schools. We have to respect their religious beliefs, even though OURS aren't respected. A prayer room 'for muslims only'? Footbaths and prayer mats? Can we say 'asking for trouble'? Muslims already have a foothold in the US with their 'religous camps' that teach weaponry. That has a 'muslims only' sign on it too. We have learned to get along fairly well with the schools not allowing Bibles or prayer or Christmas in them. Now we are going to have to let Muslims do their thing in school, even though WE can't? Exactly WHY are we even considering giving them more rights than US citizens have? | | | | | | |
zukepr (11761)
|
5 years ago
| | It doesnt stop at footbaths and prayer mats Major corporations are installing bedays for these people You know those special toilets that squirt water to clean your behind? All because these people dont beleive in using toilet paper. | | | |
sedel1027 (12989)
|
5 years ago
| | I have not heard of corporations installing bedays for them. That is a bit much. At the end of 2005 I was working in Houston and one of the employees was Muslim. He brought his prayer mat to work and prayed, but it was on his lunch hour. I don't see a problem with that, he was doing it on his own time. Other than that, there were no special concessions made for him. In my opinion, that is how it should be for everyone. | | | |
MSV1313 (2239)
|
5 years ago
| | I also worked with some Muslim gentlemen who did the same thing. It was not a problem, and they asked for no special treatment. They were well liked by everyone. | | | |
| |
| Visit mormon.org Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ & the Mormon faith www.mormon.org | add comment | | |
|
|
5. zukepr (11761)
|
5 years ago
| | This completely ticks me off!! I see the same problem here in my town with accomodations that are being made for people that come to this country from Somalia. Major industrial corporations are making special accomodations for these people to pray at work Schools are making special accomodations for these children to pray at school yet the legal citizens of this country dont get the same kind of religous respect and our kids cant even say the pledge of allegiance because it has the word "God" in it. I dont understand what makes these people so friggin special. Us legal citizens are tired of seeing these people get special treatment from the government while we have our rights stripped away And the most screwed up part of all of it is that these people dont give a rats a$$ about the rest of the people around them and they appreciate what they are being given. they just take and take and all they care about is themselves They bring disease into our country and they suck up everybit of whatever our government gives them and they treat us like we are lower than the dirt beneath their stinking feet! You just had to get me started on this didnt you? LOL | | | | | | |
HighReed1 (881)
|
5 years ago
| | Now don't forget the hypocrisy that goes with this.... They don't like the word 'God', it is supposed to be 'Allah'. Yet they don't seem to have a problem with our money, that just happens to say 'In GOD We Trust'. I wonder if people will actually stand up and scream if the government tells them they will have to pay to print new money that says 'Allah'? | | | |
zukepr (11761)
|
5 years ago
| | UMMM If it gets to that point where we have to print new money for them I am leaving, I will go to Canada or Mexico or the middle of nowhere right smack dab in the middle of the ocean on some deserted island. I wonder how much our government really expects us to tolerate These people are living here tax free and are being handed everything while our citizens are struggling to raise our families. | | | |
MSV1313 (2239)
|
5 years ago
| | Maybe if someone DID propose that Allah be printed on our dollars people would finally wake the hell up and realize that our very civilization is being taken down peice by peice and given away to whoever b!tches the loudest. You know people in America won't tolerate having their MONEY messed with! Maybe WE need to set up our cmps for "citizens only" and train in weaponry? Oh no, I suppose that would be violating the aliens civil rights wouldn't it? And the "right to keep and bear arms" only applies to those who wish us harm lately anyway. | | | |
fizzytom (435)
|
5 years ago
| | America is based on immigration! I hate to hear such intolerance. "They" bring disease to your country? What disease? Americans aren't doing so badly. If so many Americans can afford to be so fat then they are OK | | | |
HighReed1 (881)
|
5 years ago
| | America IS based on immigration. It's when the same immigrants (or those here on visas) expect special treatment that we get annoyed. I'm not sure about the diseases, but I have seen them treat the US citizens like dirt. And the comment about Americans being fat.... Besides just being RUDE, exactly how much do you know about our economy? Do you even know how many US citizens are living below poverty level? Yeah. Those families are doing REAL well. NOT!! Do you consider Russians to be doing well? I believe there are quite a few 'fat' people over there as well. | | | |
fizzytom (435)
|
5 years ago
| | I was in Russia last year actually. The majority of Russians have a pretty bad time of it. Unless you are prepared to break the law and have friends in high places its hard to get by. However, it cannot be denied that a society that has such high levels of obesity is not a hungry one. Food in the USA is VERY cheap - much cheaper than in the UK or in many opther countries. I would be interested to know just what dieseases immigrants are bringing in to America. It disappoints me to hear people speaking so ill of other human beings | | | |
sndcain (3075)
|
5 years ago
| | The obesity epidemic can be largely attributed to the result of poor nutrition; poor people can't afford to eat well, so they eat cheap, high calorie, high fat, mass produced food that is filled with preservatives and chemicals. The very thing that makes outsiders think America is so prosperous is the result of poverty. Organic food healthy food, costs MORE. Many families can't afford it, so they eat what they can afford. | | | |
elp388 (1846)
|
5 years ago
| | Sndcain is correct! fizzy, that was a very rude and arrogant thing to say about Americans... pretty good coming from someone who's avatar is a picture of FOOD! LMAO! | | | |
fizzytom (435)
|
5 years ago
| | Yes- an aubergine - its a vegetable! Its not a Big Mac or some other piece of junk food that Americans are renowned for over-eating | | | |
flowerchilde (8070)
|
5 years ago
| | ..it's normal for people to b*t*ch when they are losing rights but more and more foreigners are moving in and their american rights are increasing.. (like lower college tuition, etc). And I have heard this about diseases from Somalia.. no reflection upon them.. but I do believe it's true. Besides you sound a bit prejudice against american sitizens.. And a prejudice is still a prejudice, even if it's politically 'correct'. The political 'correct' thought is America is to blame.. for whatever... But just because you 'move to the head of the class' doesn't neceassarily mean you did evil to get there.. This was a christian based country and it prospered for that very reason. Not to say we were perfect.. but at least mothers and grandmothers, etc. didn't have to worry about the mortal lives and safety of the children when not in direct eyesight.. What does this have to do with immigration? Perhaps, nothing. But it has to do with throwing over our own roots and embracing everybody else's, while discriminating and seeking to make more and more laws against our own foundation.. and changing the history account also.. Namely there is no phrase "separation of church and state" in the constitution.. but the words are actually.. "Congress shall not have an enforced state belief and faith" (this should include the fAr from proven theory of 'evolution'!) and this phrase continues with the much ignored "and shall noT prohibit the free exercise thereof!" - "Freedom from religion"? No way! Why'd so many name their offspring Micah and Isaiah, Samuel and the like? This used to be a different type of country.. and thus did we prosper... but we've thrown it away.. Mark my words. | | | |
| |
| The Church Jesus Built What happened to the church Jesus began? How will you recognize it? www.ucg.org/bible-study-aid | add comment | | |
|
|
6. margieanneart (16724)
|
5 years ago
| | I have seen and heard of this many times. They sometimes do it with other minorities too. This is a subject not easly written about on here, so I cannot say anymore. I don't think that any one religion or nationality should get extra treatment though. | | | | | | |
| |
| Local Wood Carving Find Wood Carving Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews! Local.com | add comment | | |
|
|
7. sedel1027 (12989)
|
5 years ago
| | This is completely out of hand. If the Muslims want a place where their kids can go to school and participate in their religion, then they need to have separate schools just like the Catholics and other religions do. It is not fair to anyone to allow one religion to have special rights for prayer, etc in a school and others do not. In a public school, religion should be completely left out. There is no reason for anyone to practice their religion in a public school. | | | | | | |
sndcain (3075)
|
5 years ago
| | The problem with separate schools is that it breeds even more suspicion and mistrust. You've heard of the Stop the Madressa" campaign? American's don't want Muslim schools because we don't want our children indoctrinated into Islam, and "separate but equal" was found to be unconstitutional. | | | |
sedel1027 (12989)
|
5 years ago
| | No, I have never heard of the Stop the Madness and I live in the US. I don't see how them having their own schools will allow our children to be affected by them. It is no different then them having their own churches, which they already have. Many of these kids do go to muslim schools they just are not large schools. Where I use to live in Louisiana there were groups of muslims and people from India that lived in large buildings and they taught the kids. We are talking 100 people to a building. Of course that was waay before Sept 11th. Even after that, they did not change their lifestyle. | | | |
flowerchilde (8070)
|
5 years ago
| | ..they have a school in NYC and they are not open about what they are teaching.. their t-shirts say something about "Intifada.. NYC" - What I'm saying is many are skeptical of what they will be teaching in the schools.. Europe is having just such a problem as they tolerate the fiery teachings in the Mosques.. It may be nice to say we shouldn't be suspicious.. but what if we're wrong? | | | |
sedel1027 (12989)
|
5 years ago
| | If they teach within the Mosque and it is part of their actual religion, then no one can comment upon what i sbeing said. The school I am referring to are more like home schools. The people live in the same building the school is, they work next door. Personally, for me this is not just about Muslims it is about all immigrants taking over our society. I truly believe that the government needs to step up and get rid of all of the illegal immigrants in our society and not let ANYONE in until we get ourselves together. | | | |
| |
| After School Child Care Search Local Babysitters Today. Find Your Ideal Sitter. Fast & Easy www.Care.com/babysitter | add comment | | |
|
|
8. fizzytom (435)
|
5 years ago
| | Equality does not mean making things the same for everyone. It means allowing everyone what they need according to their differences. If you don't need to pray why get upset that someone who does needs a prayer room or a break? Why do you have to have a break or a room for yourself? If you don't need to pray you don't need the break! | | | | | | |
elp388 (1846)
|
5 years ago
| | why should these kids get special breaks at all? this is not church that we are talking about, this is public school... the objective of public school is to learn math, reading, spelling, science etc... if their religion doesn't allow them time to learn anything other than religion then they need to think of opening a school that will cater to their special needs. Christians that want to incorporate the Bible into their studies have opened schools to cater to these needs, I'm sure you have heard of Christian schools. When I was in school I prayed quiet a lot, I did it silently in my head.. and I believe that God was able to hear me without me getting on my hands and knees and reciting a prayer.. I didn't have to take time out to speak to God and I didn't have to have a special room or recess to do it, nor did I expect to be treated differently. I suggest they do the same thing or build themselves a church/school that will allow for their prayer time. | | | |
| |
| Find Jobs All job listings. Indeed.com one search. All jobs. indeed.com/jobs | add comment | | |
|
|
9. revdauphinee (4113)
|
5 years ago
| | It is a double standard we have in this country seperation of church and stater we also need seperation of mosque and state however preferential treatment is never ever given to christians | | | | | | |
| |
| Job School Enroll In Job Training School. Get The Skills You Need To Work Today. rwm.org | add comment | | |
|
|
10. elp388 (1846)
|
5 years ago
| | I would like my kids to be allowed the opportunity to say a prayer in school.. I would love for my kids to have the chance to learn a few Bible verses in school.. I would also like my children to be able to testify in school about how Jesus saved and washed their sins through his sacrifice and blood.. I would like my kids to be able to gather around the flag pole every day and say a prayer for our leaders and their country and for the soldiers that are fighting for this country.. day in and day out... I would also like my kids to have a chance to recite the 10 commandments in class... yet, those things were taken away from them, because of a little thing that our country has set in place called "separation of church and state" in other words.. your church or religious affairs have no business in a public classroom. now, if my children (who are Christian AMERICANS) are denied the chance to practice their religion in their classrooms and in their schools.. why are Muslims allowed to practice theirs? while America is bending over backward to accommodate these enemies of the US and it's people.. our children are sent home for doing a report on Jesus! you know, if I felt that a country needed to accommodate only MY beliefs and ignore their own.. I would hope that that country would have enough damn sense to send my butt home! wouldn't you??? while their religion is being held to the highest of priorities, when are they given the chance to learn reading and math and all of those other subjects that are required in order to receive a diploma? are they going to have to make the school day longer for everyone else so these people can get all their prayers in? heck, while we are at it.. lets just rename out country Palistimerica! lol! | | | | | | |
fizzytom (435)
|
5 years ago
| | America's enemies are not "Muslims" as a whole but it sounfds like you are saying that's how it is. What is happening internationally is nothing to do with religion. The majority of Muslims do not agree with what is happening in the supposed name of ISlam. I can see your point that ALL faiths should be allowed to follow their own customs but I fear you are making Muslims a target when they should not be | | | |
HighReed1 (881)
|
5 years ago
| | How are we supposed to know which Muslims are not against us? They won't stand up and say anything and we can't read minds. | | | |
elp388 (1846)
|
5 years ago
| | fizzy, anyone who moves or sneaks into our country and MAKES our citizens bow down to their demands... and hide like rats in caves and spew out hate toward any religion that is not Islam and blows away 3000 people in one day.... is our enemy! sorry if that's not the liberal answer you were looking for but I am certainly not alone in my feelings... and as HighReed stated... how exactly are we to know which ones are the nice ones and which ones are not??.. they don't speak up against the evil ones in their own cult. | | | |
fizzytom (435)
|
5 years ago
| | I live in the UK so I face the same threats as people living in the US. However, I do not regard the Muslim communtiy as a whole as a threat. I reagrd terrorists as a threat and they can come from any section of the community | | | |
elp388 (1846)
|
5 years ago
| | perhaps you don't think of them as "the enemy" YET, but if they have their way... one day you will! I suggest you do some reading up on this FINE religion... they actually are guaranteed a reward in heaven for killing anyone who ISN'T muslim. of course if you are muslim already, you might be safe for a while; but they have no problem killing their own people (especially if they are women). | | | |
| |
| New Zealand Bone & Jade New Zealand Maori carvings, art, craft and jewelry in bone and jade. boneart.co.nz | add comment | | |
|
|
| | Visit mormon.org Reach Spiritual Fulfillment through Christ& the Mormon faith www.mormon.org
| The Church Jesus Built What happened to the church Jesus began? How will you recognize it? www.ucg.org/bible-study-aid
| Local Wood Carving Find Wood Carving Near You. See Actual Customer Reviews! Local.com
|
|
| |
| |
| |